On opposing any and all efforts to increase taxes.
Nathan Deal on Monday, May 10th, 2010 in pledge
Deal's support for T-SPLOST veers from tax pledge
A political litmus test is causing trouble for some of Georgia’s most powerful elected officials.
Gov. Nathan Deal and other top Republicans have faced criticism for endorsing a proposed 1 percent sales tax to fund 157 transportation projects across the Atlanta region. The overall price tag is in the billions. A voter referendum on the tax will be held July 31.
Blasphemy, the critics say. You promised not to support any tax increases, they’ve complained to Republican lawmakers who have spoken in favor of the referendum.
PolitiFact Georgia wondered whether the lawmakers have indeed reversed course -- particularly since some facing the criticism signed a specific pledge to oppose any tax increases.
The lawmakers and their spokesmen said no.
PolitiFact Georgia began a search for clarity.
The Washington-based Americans for Tax Reform has become a major player in Republican Party politics with its Taxpayer Protection Pledge. More than half the members of the U.S. House of Representatives have signed the pledge. Nearly half the U.S. Senate has signed it. Nearly all the signers are Republicans. Both U.S. senators from Georgia (Saxby Chambliss and Johnny Isakson) have signed the pledge, along with GOP House members Paul Broun, Phil Gingrey, Tom Graves, Jack Kingston, Tom Price, Austin Scott and Lynn Westmoreland.
More than 50 members of the Georgia Legislature have signed the pledge.
So, too, has Deal, who signed it May 10, 2010, during his campaign for governor.
A couple of Democrats in the Georgia House of Representatives are listed on the pledge list.
ATR believes any new legislation or changes to an existing tax structure that results in a new tax increase on individuals is a violation of the pledge by lawmakers who have signed it. Some Democrats blamed ATR President Grover Norquist for last year’s failure by Congress to agree on a long-term debt deal.
In recent weeks, some GOP lawmakers have done the unthinkable -- taken on Norquist in the media. They have complained the pledge doesn’t offer enough flexibility to handle the federal government’s financial challenges. But those are federal issues.
Here, we are concerned with a local penny sales tax increase that would raise a lot of money for transportation projects.
The proposed Georgia sales tax would raise about $7 billion over the next 10 years, planners have said.
We asked Norquist whether Georgia lawmakers who’ve spoken in favor of the referendum have violated the pledge they’ve signed.
"It does violate the pledge," he said. "It’s a rather significant tax increase."
The language in the pledge is different for federal and state officials.
The federal pledge asks signers to oppose any and all efforts to increase the marginal tax rate on individuals and oppose any net reduction or elimination of deductions or tax credits "unless matched dollar for dollar by further reducing taxes."
The state pledge is less detailed, simply stating that the signer "will oppose and veto any and all efforts to increase taxes."
Although some federal lawmakers from Georgia such as Chambliss and Westmoreland have spoken in favor of the referendum, PolitiFact Georgia decided to focus more on state leaders since the sales tax does not fit the description of what constitutes a violation of the federal no-tax pledge.
The 1 percent sales tax, also known as T-SPLOST, has the support of some commuters eager for any improvements to shorten travel time. Some proponents also argue the projects will help the region’s economy by hiring people to work on the proposed jobs. Some opponents argue that the project list will not do enough to improve commuting in metro Atlanta. Some say it will not get enough motorists out of their cars and into mass transit. Others are skeptical that the plan will be carried out as stated by regional leaders.
Deal’s name was atop a flier for a May 23 fundraiser in support of T-SPLOST held at the home of former Cousins Properties CEO Tom Bell in Buckhead. The governor said it is important to attract companies to the state. Deal has spoken in support of the referendum to several large audiences in recent months, such as at the Atlanta Press Club, at an event in Savannah and to the Greater North Fulton Chamber of Commerce.
Deal spokesman Brian Robinson said it’s unfair to say the governor has flip-flopped on his commitment not to support a tax increase. Robinson said the referendum was approved before Deal took office.
"This is not a violation of the pledge. [Nathan Deal] has cut taxes. This passed before he was governor. He is advocating for Georgians to approve it, not imposing it on them," Robinson said via email.
Robinson added: "Governor Deal didn’t father this baby."
Robinson said the T-SPLOST is in line with conservative principles such as consumption-based taxes. He also said the proposed penny tax is "the best program" to help reduce the region’s gridlock problems.
"The fact is Grover Norquist doesn’t have to commute in Atlanta," Robinson said.
Norquist said if state leaders feel compelled to spend more on transportation, they should spend less in other areas.
Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle isn’t on the list of people who’ve signed the pledge, but he’s taken heat for his support of the referendum. Cagle spokesman Ben Fry made an argument similar to Robinson’s that a referendum is different than state lawmakers imposing new taxes.
"In the end, Casey Cagle has as much say as any Georgia voter," Fry said.
Some state lawmakers who signed the pledge and made statements that suggest they support the referendum didn’t respond when we called.
Others, such as Amos Amerson, leaving the House of Representatives after 12 years, said he decided the pledge isn’t always practical and asked in a 2002 letter to be removed from the list when he heard talk about raising the cigarette tax to help fund skyrocketing state health care costs. Amerson said he never received an answer to his request.
As for his support of T-SPLOST, Amerson said: "Georgia has to do something for road improvements. We just do not have the money."
There’s a good debate to be had about the issue of transportation spending.
The problem for lawmakers who signed the pledge is it specifically states "that I will oppose and veto any and all efforts to increase taxes."
The T-SPLOST is an increase in the sales tax. There are no cuts to make it revenue-neutral.
Deal gets a Full Flop.
Published: Friday, June 8th, 2012 at 6:00 a.m.
Americans for Tax Reform Taxpayer Protection Pledge signed by Nathan Deal
Americans for Tax Reform pledge information
Americans for Tax Reform Taxpayer Protection Pledge signers 112th Congress, http://s3.amazonaws.com/atrfiles/files/files/120111-federalpledgesigners.pdf
Atlanta Journal-Constitution editorial on transportation plan, May 9, 2010.
Flier promoting fundraising reception in support of the transportation referendum
News release from the office of state Rep. Amos Amerson, May 28, 2010
Telephone interview with Grover Norquist, president, Americans for Tax Reform, May 23, 2012.
Telephone interview and emails from Brian Robinson, spokesman for Gov. Nathan Deal, May 24, June 7, 2012.
Telephone interview with Ben Fry, spokesman for Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle, May 25, 2012.
Telephone interview with state Rep. Amos Amerson, May 30, 2012.
The South Hall Gazette, "Georgia GOP split over T-SPLOST," April 29, 2012
WABE-FM article, "Governor Deal Discusses Legislative Achievements, Promotes T-SPLOST," April 17, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Georgia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.