PolitiFact.com
Powered by PolitiFact.com
The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Kasich

"Since 1904, the Ohio victor has won the presidency 25 out of 27 times "

John Kasich on Monday, June 21st, 2010 in a statement posted to his website

Ohio's voter opinions a steady bellwether for presidential elections

Republican challenger John Kasich warns that if Democrat Ted Strickland is re-elected governor it could pave the way for Barack Obama to take Ohio in 2012. 
 
And given Ohio's track record for predicting the presidency, that could guarantee Obama's re-election, he says.
 
"Since 1904, the Ohio victor has won the presidency 25 out of 27 times," Kasich says on his website. 
 
Kasich is correct that Ohio has picked the winner in all but two elections since 1904. Voters backed Republican New York Gov. Thomas Dewey (and his running mate, Ohio Gov. John Bricker) over Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1944. In 1960, voters favored Republican Vice President Richard Nixon over Sen. John F. Kennedy.
 
We wanted to see just how much of a difference Ohio's vote has made over time, and if the gubernatorial elections signal anything about subsequent presidental votes.
 
Since 1904, when the state backed Theodore Roosevelt, few presidental elections have been so close that Ohio's vote could have swung the result. Ohioans backed Woodrow Wilson's re-election in 1916, a close race in which any of 10 states could have flipped the result. And Ohio could have made a difference in either 2000 and 2004 when it backed George W. Bush, first over Vice President Al Gore and then over Sen. John Kerry.
 
But those are the only three elections in which a change in Ohio's result would have swung enough electoral votes to change the presidency.
 
Will the outcome of this year's gubernatorial election affect how Ohio votes in 2012, as Kasich contends? History doesn't appear to be on his side.
 
There have been 13 gubernatorial elections since Ohio changed the governor's term to four years. Democrat Michael DiSalle won the first, in 1958, two years before Kennedy's victory. But Ohio didn't back Kennedy. Seven other times since, Ohio's pick for governor didn't match its party choice for president two years later. The state has matched, though, on the last three, backing Republican Bob Taft II and then supporting Bush and backing Strickland before voting with Obama.
 
The answer to the state's accuracy as a presidential bellwether may lie in its population. "The state itself represents very well the political diversity of the country," Eric Rademacher, co-director of the University of Cincinnati's Institute for Policy Research, once told The Plain Dealer. The institute sponsors The Ohio Poll.
 
So while Ohio can't say it's the decider (Bush already claimed that title), it can boast that it's the presidential predictor -- a claim supported by 25 of 27 correct votes, including 12 in a row.
 
We rate this statement True. 
 
Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Friday, July 23rd, 2010 at 10:30 a.m.

Subjects: Elections, History

Sources:

National Archives Electoral College results
 
Ohio Historical Society, The Governors of Ohio
 
The Plain Dealer, "Presidents: Ohio really knows how to pick 'em," May 9, 2004

John Kasich For Ohio campaign video, "Stop Ted Strickland, Stop Barack Obama,"  June 21, 2010

Written by: Robert Higgs
Researched by: Robert Higgs
Edited by: Jane Kahoun

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Ohio Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe:

Keep up to date with Politifact Ohio: