"We have lost 600,000 jobs over the period of the last 10 years. Only Michigan and California have done worse."
John Kasich on Tuesday, February 22nd, 2011 in an interview on CNN
Gov. John Kasich says only California and Michigan lost more jobs than Ohio in the last decade
Jobs were the leading issue in Ohio's 2010 election campaign, and the issue has lost none of its importance or utility to officeholders.
Gov. John Kasich brought it up twice in two days in interviews on CNN. The first-term Republican cited the state's loss of jobs among the reasons he backed Senate Bill 5, which would eliminate collective bargaining rights for state employees.
"We have lost 600,000 jobs over the period of the last 10 years," Kasich said. "Only Michigan and California have done worse."
We thought that was worth checking, especially because employment figures are estimates, measured several different ways.
The Current Population Survey (CPS) is based on household interviews conducted each month by the U.S. Census Bureau for the Bureau of Labor Statistics. It counts employed individuals, and its data is used in calculating unemployment.
The monthly Current Employment Statistics (CES) survey uses payroll records and counts unique jobs. Normally the headline jobs figure, it is preferred by the Congressional Budget Office and Bureau of Labor Statistics for measuring job growth.
According to the CES survey and the Bureau of Labor Statistics, there were 5,002,900 jobs in Ohio in December 2010. Ten years earlier, in December 2000, the number was 5,613,000.
That's a loss of about 610,000 jobs -- and the decline is even larger from the peak level of 5,638,100 jobs in May 2000.
Kasich had Ohio's number right.
But was it the nation’s third worst?
California, which had 13,897,100 jobs in December 2010, lost 803,000 jobs from December 2000, and 1,305,500 jobs from the state’s peak level of July 2007, according to the CES survey.
Michigan had 3,831,500 jobs in December 2010, a loss of 832,800 from December 2000.
Kasich was correct that both states lost more jobs than Ohio from the start to the finish of the decade ending last December. No other states lost more by that measure.
But there’s a footnote we’ll also add about boom-or-bust Florida, which qualifies as both a gainer and a loser. The state gained about 30,000 jobs from December 2000 to December 2010, when it had 7,193,900 in the CES survey.
From its peak level of March 2007, however, Florida has lost 876,500 jobs -- more than any state except California.
But for purposes of the Truth-O-Meter, words matter. Kasich’s statement was that over the last 10 years, Ohio lost 600,000 jobs and that only Michigan and California have done worse. And in terms of net change over the decade, he’s right on the money.
We rate his statement as True.
Published: Friday, March 4th, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.
CNN, "CNN Newsroom," Feb. 22, 2011
CNN, "John King, USA," Feb. 21, 2011
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Ohio employment
Bureau of Labor Statistics, state employment statistics
Department of Numbers, Employment Overview
Ohio Department of Jobs & Family Services, Ohio Labor Market Information
Dallas Morning News, "Ohioans' exodus to Texas offers lesson to Lone Star State," Jan. 2, 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Ohio Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.