The STAR Ohio fund "just received the highest possible credit rating one of these funds can receive."
Josh Mandel on Wednesday, October 5th, 2011 in an email to supporters
Ohio Treasurer Josh Mandel touts investment pool's credit rating
Critics of Republican Ohio Treasurer Josh Mandel describe him as an overly ambitious politician who focuses on his next election rather than his current job.
This gripe has grown louder as Mandel, elected treasurer last November, recently emerged as a candidate for U.S. Senate to oppose incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown, who is up for re-election next year.
While he campaigns for the Senate race, Mandel has promoted his work as state treasurer, whose responsibilities are to safeguard and invest the state’s money.
The treasurer also invests money for local governments through the STAR (State Treasury Asset Reserve) Ohio fund, an investment pool with assets of more than $4.1 billion.
Mandel, a former Lyndhurst City Councilman, touted the fund’s credit rating in an email to supporters in early October. The STAR Ohio fund "just received the highest possible credit rating one of these funds can receive," he wrote in the Oct. 5 email.
Mandel went on to praise his staff for making tough decisions in the midst of an unpredictable economy. He also contrasted the fund’s performance against the recent downgrade of the United States’ credit rating.
Given his Senate candidacy and the consistent accusations he is an absent officeholder, PolitiFact Ohio decided to check Mandel’s claim about his performance as treasurer.
The treasurer’s office directed us to its news release on Sept. 8. The release included a letter from the credit rating agency Standard & Poor’s, along with recent news stories about local government investment funds. Like other credit rating agencies, S&P analyzes the creditworthiness of various governments, government-backed funds and other investments.
On Aug. 23, S&P sent a letter to the state affirming a AAAm rating for the STAR Ohio fund.
Unfamiliar with the lower-case "m" attached to the rating, we looked it up under S&P’s ratings definitions.
The "m" subscript signifies a money market fund rating, which assesses the fund’s ability to maintain a stable net asset value. AAAm is the highest of these ratings.
"Higher rated funds are expected to have stronger capacities to pay investor redemptions in cash during times of high market stress because they generally comprise shorter maturity and higher quality investments," according to S&P.
Mandel is accurate in saying the fund received the highest possible rating. He also told supporters the fund "just" received the rating, so we wanted to check whether the rating was upgraded under Mandel, or if the fund maintained a high rating established under previous treasurers.
Jeff Sexton, a spokesman for S&P, said STAR Ohio has received a AAAm rating since 1995, the first year S&P rated the fund.
Although Mandel has simply maintained the high rating, a public finance expert said the treasurer deserves some credit. The highest praise, however, should be reserved for the fund managers who maintained the rating during the financial crisis in 2008, said Kevin O’Brien, executive director at the Center for Public Management in the Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs at Cleveland State University.
"He deserves credit for maintaining that (rating) from January until now," said O’Brien, a former financial analyst for Moody’s Investors Service, another credit rating agency. "They maintained the bond rating; they didn't achieve the bond rating."
We checked with Mandel’s office to get an idea of how the STAR Ohio fund is managed. Spokesman Seth Unger said the office’s investment department works with financial advisers to manage the fund. Unger said investments are bought and sold daily.
The STAR Ohio fund did, in fact, receive the highest rating possible, as Mandel’s email claimed. But the rating already had been in place for 16 years. It did not improve under Mandel, as a reasonable person might assume from his email. And while he gets some credit for maintaining the rating, his email overstated the case.
Those are important details that add context. We rate the statement Half True.
Published: Thursday, October 27th, 2011 at 6:00 p.m.
News release from Mandel’s office, "Treasurer’s Local Government Investment Fund, STAR Ohio, Receives Highest Rating from Standard & Poor’s," Sept. 8, 2011.
Email from Mandel to his supporters, Oct. 5, 2011.
Standard & Poor’s report, "73 Fund Credit-Quality Ratings Lowered And Removed From Credit Watch Following U.S. Sovereign Downgrade," Aug. 8, 2011.
Standard & Poor’s ratings definitions.
Phone interview with Kevin O’Brien, executive director at the Center for Public Management in the Maxine Goodman Levin College of Urban Affairs at Cleveland State University, Oct. 21, 2011.
Email correspondence with Mandel spokesman Seth Unger, various dates in October.
Phone interview and email correspondence with S&P spokesman Jeff Sexton, various dates in October.
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Ohio Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.