Says Sen. Sherrod Brown "cast the deciding vote on the government takeover of health care."
Josh Mandel on Wednesday, May 23rd, 2012 in a campaign commercial
Josh Mandel says Sherrod Brown cast the deciding vote for a government takeover of health care
Republican Josh Mandel, the Ohio state treasurer hoping to unseat incumbent Democrat Sherrod Brown from his U.S. Senate seat in November, makes the most of the 30 seconds in his TV ad "Change." The campaign spot makes at least five separate claims about the two candidates.
PolitiFact Ohio will take a look at several of them in the days ahead. For this factcheck item we’ll look at the statement that Brown "cast the deciding vote on the government takeover of health care."
The statement claim caught our attention because it combines two claims we've examined before.
To back it up, the commercial cites the Senate's roll call vote of Dec. 24, 2009, on H.R. 3590, Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, the health care reform law commonly known as Obamacare.
Did Brown cast the deciding vote? That depends on how you define "deciding."
Mandel's campaign and the National Republican Senatorial Committee both have explained their logic in crediting or blaming Brown for the deciding vote: The measure passed with the 60 votes that were required. Anything short of that would have effectively killed the legislation through the equivalent of a filibuster.
Every vote is decisive, therefore every vote is "deciding," they say. The NRSC has made the same claim about other Democratic senators, too.
There is, however, also this to consider: Before the votes were taken, Democrats and Republicans kept a count of supporters and opponents, and Democrats could only round up 59 proponents to end debate -- until Ben Nelson of Nebraska agreed to join in. News coverage on that day, Dec. 19, 2009, described Nelson as the crucial 60th vote to break the filibuster.
Brown’s vote was actually the seventh "yes" among the 60 senators who supported a Senate bill that had to be reconciled with a House version on Christmas Eve 2009. His vote was cast early in the roll call, which is done in alphabetical order. When the two sides came together and the Senate voted on the final version, on March 25, 2010, Brown voted eighth.
Both measures passed with exactly 60 votes. Brown's vote was crucial. Following the rationale of the Mandel camp and of the NRSC, any of those 60 votes could be called a deciding vote. But Brown did nothing (such as holding his support until the last moment) that would justify singling him out.
What about the other part of the claim, where Mandel's ad refers to the health care act as "the government takeover of health care"? Mandel’s ad repeats a claim that has been reviewed numerous times by PolitiFact and rated False or Pants on Fire.
PolitiFact national recognized it as the 2010 "Lie of the Year." FactCheck.org called it "nonsensical" and a "whopper," saying the reform plan is neither "government-run" nor a "government takeover." The Washington Post Fact Checker classified it as myth.
It is true that the law does significantly increase government regulation of health insurers. But it is a system that relies on private companies and the free market. Contrary to the claim, more people will get private health coverage. The law does not include the public option, a government-run insurance plan that would have competed with private insurers.
Brown’s vote for the health care reform legislation was crucial, but was it the deciding vote? A listener hearing the Mandel ad could be lead to believe Brown’s vote had more weight than other votes. Yet, he certainly did not cast the 60th vote, and he did not have to be wooed for support.
And it is not accurate to state that he voted for a "government takeover of health care."
On the Truth-O-Meter, this claim from Mandel’s ad rates False.
Published: Wednesday, May 30th, 2012 at 6:00 a.m.
Josh Mandel Campaign, "Change," May 23, 2012
Govtrack.us, H.R. 3590
PolitiFact, "What makes a vote 'the deciding vote'?" Oct, 26, 2010
The Plain Dealer via Cleveland.com, "Was Sherrod Brown really the crucial 60th vote for 'Obamacare?' It depends on how you count," April 14, 2012
Politico, "NRSC: Tester was '60th vote' for ACA," March 23, 2011
PolitiFact, "The flood of falsehoods about the health care law," March 21, 2012
PolitiFact, "PolitiFact's Lie of the Year: 'A government takeover of health care'," Dec. 16 2010
FactCheck.org, "Government-Run’ Nonsense," Nov. 21, 2011
Washington Post, "Myths and facts about 'Obamacare," Jan. 18, 2011
PolitiFact New Jersey, "Chris Christie slams health care reform as 'a government takeover of health care," Oct. 23 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Ohio Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.