Says "under Oregon law, girls from 15 years of age and up are given complete control over whether to be sterilized or not."
CNSNews on Friday, August 10th, 2012 in a news article.
In Oregon, do 15-year-olds have complete control over sterilization?
In early August, CNSNews.com published an article with the headline "Obamacare Mandate: Sterilize 15-Year-Old Girls for Free –Without Parental Consent."
"Thanks to an Obamacare regulation that took effect on Aug. 1," read the article, "health care plans in Oregon will now be required to provide free sterilizations to 15-year-old girls even if the parents of those girls do not consent to the procedure."
The article went on to note that "Under Oregon law, girls from 15 years of age and up are given complete control over whether to be sterilized or not."
The story got picked up by several websites, quickly making its way around the web – and into our mailbox.
Of course, we were curious, too, so we got to checking.
Before we get to our findings, here's a little context about CNSNews.com for those – like us – who had not heard of it. CNSNews.com, based in a Virginia suburb of Washington, D.C., says its goal is to "provide an alternative news source that would cover stories that are subject to the bias of omission and report on other news subject to bias by commission." It is not affiliated with Catholic News Service, which sometimes uses the same CNS abbreviation.
First, we checked the larger context of the article to see if "Obamacare" (the Affordable Care Act) requires health insurers to cover sterilization. We made several calls before we finally came up with a solid source that confirmed the new law requires providers to cover sterilization without cost to the patient. According to the U.S. Health Resource and Services Administration, services that fall under "women's preventive health care" are supposed to be covered for free, including mammograms, screenings for cervical cancer, prenatal care, contraception, sexually transmitted infection counseling and – yes –"sterilization procedures."
As for the more salient detail – the age of consent in Oregon – we found a piece of Oregon law, which states that "a minor 15 years of age or older may give consent, without the consent of a parent or guardian of the minor, to: Hospital care, medical or surgical diagnosis or treatment by a physician licensed by the Oregon Medical Board …"
Essentially, CNSNews.com linked those two pieces of information – the new requirements that insurance companies cover sterilization for free and the fact that Oregon's age of consent for health care is 15 years old.
The idea that 15-year-old girls would be lining up for free on-demand sterilizations struck our readers either as scary - "Is this true?" - or ridiculous - "This can't be true."
We kept reporting.
We checked whether sterilization had always been covered by the Oregon Health Plan, the state-run health care insurance program that covers 600,000 people a month. We called Oregon Health Authority spokeswoman Alissa Robbins, who confirmed that it has been included since the plan's inception in 1994.
We also asked how many 15-, 16 – and 17-year-olds had received sterilizations under the plan. Robbins checked records for the last 10 years and found no sterilization procedure for a 15-year-old or a 16-year-old. As for 17-year-olds, she said, at most one such procedure is performed each year, though some years none is performed. She couldn't tell us the reason, she said, because it was "protected health information." However, it seems clear to us that the procedure for young women in that age bracket is exceedingly rare.
Robbins also pointed us to ORS 436, which lays out the warnings and consent procedures for anyone seeking sterilization, including minors. If a physician feels a minor is not capable of making an informed consent to be sterilized, her only recourse is to go to court and ask a judge to order that she is.
We also checked with OHSU Hospital to see what the process would be for a minor looking to be sterilized there. Spokeswoman Tamara Hargens-Bradley got back to us with a lengthy email.
For any patient under 30, she said, the hospital offers counseling about "long-acting reversible contraceptives" and "the risk of regret" in young women who are sterilized.
The "most likely scenario in which a teenager would request sterilization," she wrote, "is if she has a medical condition so severe that pregnancy would be life-threatening."
If sterilization is not needed medically and a teen insists, Hargens-Bradley said the OHSU ethics committee would get involved. "(T)hat would be very unusual and cause concern about whether the patient is capable of providing fully informed consent."
She ended on this note: "The health care reform offering contraception for free does not REQUIRE a physician to provide care they do not feel is safe for the patient. It requires that insurance plans cover all contraceptives available."
After some vacation phone tag, we were able to talk to Michael Chapman, the CNSNews.com managing editor who had worked closely with the story's author, an intern who is no longer there.
"Our story is factual," Chapman said. "Out story reports what the law is in Oregon and it reports what the federal regulation is."
Chapman said the article was stymied in part by little response from the Oregon Health Authority. "It's great they're willing to say more now that the story has come out.
"Nearly all health insurers must provide sterilization ... that's a fact."
In a subsequent email, Chapman pointed out language on the Oregon Health Authority's consent to sterilization form that reads "I was told that the decision to be sterilized is completely up to me."
The form is the last step in many checks and balances that is only signed after the patient finds a physician willing to perform the procedure.
Now let's pull this together. Our reporting found that it's true that the health care act requires sterilizations to be free. It's also true that 15-year-olds can consent to health care without parental consent.
But CNSNews.com goes even further by alleging that "under Oregon law, girls from 15 years of age and up are given complete control over whether to be sterilized or not."
The statement would be accurate if it said health care plans in Oregon are required to pay for sterilizations for 15-year-old-girls. But instead, the statement confuses the insurers with providers – i.e. physicians – stating that 15-year-olds have "complete control." That's not true.
What a 15-year-old girl may want and what a medical provider is willing to do, at least in this case, are two very different things. Health care providers are under no obligation to provide sterilization on demand. In fact, free sterilization is not available on demand for 15-year-olds in Oregon. A 15-year-old must first convince a doctor that the procedure is medically necessary. While sometimes it is -- to treat cancer, for instance --a decade of records from the Oregon Health Plan and the explanation of procedures at OHSU show sterilization of 15-year-olds is incredibly rare.
In Oregon, 15-year-old girls do not have "complete control" over whether to be sterilized. We rule the statement False.
Published: Friday, September 7th, 2012 at 4:13 p.m.
CNSNews.com, "Obamacare Mandate: Sterilize 15-Year-Old Girls for Free -- Without Parental Consent," Aug. 10, 2012
Emails from Liz Delapoer, spokeswoman for Planned Parenthood - Columbia Willamette, Aug. 19, 24 and 27, 2012
Health Resources and Services Administration, "Women’s Preventive Services," Aug. 27, 2012
Healthcare.gov, "Affordable Care Act Expands Prevention Coverage for Women’s Health and Well-Being," Aug. 27, 2012
Oregon Revised Statutes, Chapter 109 - Parent and Child Rights and Relationships
Oregon Revised Statutes, Chapter 436 - Sterilization
Emails from and interviews with Alissa Robbins, spokeswoman for the Oregon Health Authority, Aug. 27 and 31 and Sept. 4, 2012
Email from Tamara Hargens-Bradley, spokeswoman for Oregon Health and Science University, Aug. 31, 2012
Interview with Michael Chapman, a managing editor and CNSNews.com, Sept. 4, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Oregon Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.