She "led the fight to stop health insurance rate hikes and saved Rhode Island families over $150 million."
Elizabeth Roberts on Thursday, October 28th, 2010 in a campaign commercial
Printed words undercut truthfulness of Lt. Gov. Roberts' health insurance savings claim
In her bid for reelection, Lt. Governor Elizabeth Roberts cites her efforts to keep health insurance costs down in Rhode Island.
In her television ad called "Clear," a narrator says: "Elizabeth Roberts? She led the fight to stop health insurance rate hikes and saved Rhode Island families over $150 million dollars."
Meanwhile, the words on the screen say "Elizabeth Roberts," "stopped insurance rate hikes," and "saved over $150 million."
So what you see is a claim that Roberts "stopped insurance rate hikes" and what you hear is "led the fight to stop health insurance rate hikes."
We wondered what was behind the claim.
Roberts campaign manager Daniel Meuse told us that the ad referred to a 2009 request by Blue Cross and UnitedHealthCare of New England to raise rates. (Our files show the requested increases were as high as 16.3 percent. The insurance companies ultimately withdrew their requests, but succeeded in getting increases this year.)
First of all, Roberts, as the lieutenant governor, has no ability to block rate hikes. That authority lies with Health Insurance Commissioner Christopher Koller.
Meuse acknowledged that Roberts lacks any authority to stop a rate hike. But he said that she deserves credit for leading the campaign against the hikes, which is the claim made by the narrator.
Meuse said Roberts met with business groups and rallied them against the proposal. "She was the only public official who went and testified."
So we decided to check on her role as a leader of the opposition.
A June 2, 2009 Providence Journal story about a Warwick news conference reported that Roberts joined business leaders to protest the proposed increases. We got through to three of the five business people mentioned in the story and asked whether Roberts led the fight. All agreed.
J. Michael Vittoria, president of the Rhode Island Business Group on Health, which represents 75 small and large employers, said there was plenty of opposition to the rate hikes proposal and it probably would have been expressed to some degree, but Roberts and her office successfully focused it.
"If the question is whether she was responsible for making that happen? My opinion is, yes she was. I'm not saying it wouldn't have happened without her doing it, but I think she was the point of the spear there," said Vittoria. "Essentially, she led the way in terms of getting a number of different businesses together to articulate what everybody felt anyway."
"I would absolutely characterize her as someone who led the fight for the repeal of this increase," said Donald Nokes, president of NetCenergy in Warwick, who joined Vittoria and Roberts to lobby against the plan on talkradio. "It came at a very bad time and it just wasn't something we felt should be accepted."
Linda Lulli, an associate vice president for human resources at Bryant University, agreed that Roberts helped rally opposition. "In think the visibility and that level of involvement of the stakeholders, I think, had some influence on the changes that were made by the [insurance] carriers and their positions."
As for the $150 million estimate, Koller told us in an email that "the 150 figure was my office's estimate, at that time, of the annual aggregate incremental costs which employers would have paid for health insurance had the rates submitted by the three insurers been approved."
One other important point: Roberts talks about saving Rhode Island families over $150 million dollars. But in employer-sponsored health plans, employees usually pay a portion of the premium. It's the businesses that save most of the money. In addition, many employees do not have families.
For that reason, when it comes to the verbal claim, the Roberts assertion isn't completely true.
And because the words that appear on the commercial make the untrue claim that she blocked the increase, it further undercuts her -- to use the Stephen Colbert word -- truthiness.
So rate her seem claim as Half True.
Published: Saturday, October 30th, 2010 at 12:01 a.m.
YouTube.com, "Clear," LtGovRobert's channel, accessed Oct. 28, 2010
Interview, Daniel Meuse, spokesman, Elizabeth Roberts campaign, Oct. 28 and 29, 2010
ProJo.com, "Health insurers withdraw rate increase request in R.I.," July 3, 2009
ProJo.com, "Update: Critics blast health insurance increases in R.I.," March 18, 2010
Projo.com, "'Businesses say health-care hikes unreasonable,'" June 3, 2009
Interview, J. Michael Vittoria, president, Rhode Island Business Group on Health, Oct. 29, 2010
Interview, Donald Nokes, president, NetCenergy, Oct. 29, 2010
Interview, Linda Lulli, associate vice president for human resources, Bryant University, Oct. 29, 2010
Email, Christopher Koller, Rhode Island health insurance commissioner, Oct. 29, 2010
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Rhode Island Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.