Decriminalizing marijuana "will save the state anywhere from $4 (million) to $11 million dollars."
John G. Edwards on Tuesday, June 5th, 2012 in a debate on the House floor
Rep. John Edwards says decriminalizing marijuana would save $4 million to $11 million for Rhode Island
On June 13, 2012, Governor Lincoln Chafee signed into law legislation that decriminalizes possession of small amounts of marijuana. As of April 1, 2013, having 1 ounce or less will be a civil offense, punishable by a $150 fine.
Rep. John Edwards, D-Tiverton, was the bill’s prime sponsor as it moved through the Assembly for the third consecutive year.
During a June 5 House debate, he told the story of how, as a construction manager, he employed two skilled carpenters in their 50s who were barred from working on federal projects because "they had a stupid arrest when they were young for simple possession" of marijuana.
Most people don’t go to prison for having a small amount of marijuana, Edwards said, "but they do get arrested and the arrest never goes away." Not only would his bill curtail those arrests, said Edwards, "it will save the state anywhere from $4 (million) to $11 million dollars and it will also allow our police to do what they do best and that’s catch criminals."
We were curious where Edwards got his cost saving figures; $4 million to $11 million is a pretty wide window.
Edwards told us he got his information from Wallace B. Gernt Jr. and Christopher Reilly, the president and vice president respectively of The Bradford Group, the Rhode Island public relations firm. One of its clients is the Marijuana Policy Project, a Washington, D.C., group trying to change marijuana laws around the country.
When we contacted Reilly, he acknowledged a certain haziness hovering over the figures: "There’s a lot of different thoughts of where those numbers come from."
Then he sent us two reports and had the Marijuana Policy Project forward a memo that a Harvard University economist sent Rhode Island lawmakers earlier this year.
One report was from the Special Senate Commission to Study the Prohibition of Marijuana, issued in March 2010. It notes that in 2009, Rhode Island police made 2,546 arrests for marijuana possession, first offense. (It doesn’t say how much pot each suspect had.)
But the report does not say how much money Rhode Island could save by decriminalizing marijuana. It defines the savings only as "significant".
The second report was "The Criminal Justice Costs of Marijuana Prohibition in Rhode Island," issued in 2010 by the Rhode Island nonprofit group OpenDoors, which helps people released from prison. That report, supported by the Marijuana Policy Project, says Rhode Island stands to save a whopping $12.7 million a year by decriminalizing possession of an ounce or less of marijuana.
We contacted the main author of that report, Nick Horton, who told us that most of the purported savings -- $11.2 million -- wasn’t calculated by OpenDoors at all. "That figure is not mine," said Horton.
It turns out that number came from Jeffrey Miron, the Harvard economist, and his 2010 report that studied how much money the United States would save if it legalized all drugs.
In his one-page memo to Rhode Island lawmakers this spring, Miron provided the general equation he used to reach his $11.2 million figure but never plugged in any actual numbers: "I guess when you are a Harvard professor, you no longer have to "show your work,’’ Robert Capecchi, a legislative analyst for the Marijuana Policy Project, wrote in an email when Politifact asked for the details.
When we called Miron, he said his estimate -- which related exclusively to police enforcement savings -- came from a 2010 report he did for the libertarian Cato Institute: The Budgetary Impact of Ending Drug Prohibition. The study found that by legalizing all drugs, the United States could save $41.3 billion a year.
The study includes a state by state analysis of drug arrests that Miron used. For instance, 2007 data from the FBI’s annual Uniform Crime Reports shows that in Rhode Island that year the police made 26,966 drug arrests. Of those, 1,922 were for marijuana possession. (Again, the data don’t say how much marijuana each suspect had.)
By dividing 1,922 by 26,966, Miron determined that 7 percent of all arrests that year were for marijuana possession.
He then used other data from state government and the U.S. census -- some coming from 2008 -- to conclude that the total police expenditure in Rhode Island was $287 million. Seven percent of that is $20.1 million.
Then he estimated that half of the marijuana arrests were incidental to other more serious charges. Kicking those out, he calculated the annual police savings would be $10.5 million.
That’s not the $11.2 million cited by OpenDoors, but Miron says the $700,000 difference is likely because the data he used was several years old.
In a follow-up conversation, Edwards conceded that he never thought the savings would total the $11 million he cited on the House floor. "It’s more on the lower end of $4 million," he said.
He based that, in part, on some of his own calculations of prison savings -- a point that Miron, the Harvard economist, said he was surprised to hear Edwards talking about because "almost no one is in prison for [minor] possession."
But Edwards says he asked Corrections officials for a one-day snapshot of the prison population about a year or so ago. On that day, 42 people were being held for marijuana possession. He multiplied that by the average cost of holding one person at the ACI for a year ($44,000) and came up with a quick $1.8 million savings.
Corrections Department officials told us Edwards’ methodology is wrong because those inmates are scattered among many different units, so their absence would not lead to any staff reductions. They did say there would be some savings by having those 42 beds empty -- about $154,602.
That’s a long way from $1.8 million, let alone $4 million to $11 million.
State Rep. John Edwards was specific in his claim that decriminalizing marijuana will "save the state anywhere from $4 (million) to $11 million dollars."
Edwards later backed away from the $11 million figure.
Yet neither he nor any of the advocates he worked with to get the legislation passed could substantiate even the lesser amount.
Therefore we rate his statement a smoldering False.
Get updates from PolitiFactRI on Twitter. To comment or offer your ruling, visit us on our PolitiFact Rhode Island Facebook page.
Published: Sunday, June 17th, 2012 at 12:01 a.m.
Interviews and e-mails, Rep. John G. Edwards, D-Tiverton, June 7, June 12, 2012
Interviews and e-mails,Christopher Reilly, vice president of The Bradford Group, June 12, 2012
Interview, Nick Horton, policy analyst, OpenDoors, June 12, 2012
Interview, Jeffrey Miron, director of undergraduate studies and senior lecturer on economics, Harvard University, June 12
Interview and e-mail, Robert Capecchi, legislative analyst for the Marijuana Policy Project, June 12, 2012
Marijuana Policy Project, accessed June 12, 2012
RILIN.state.RI.US, "Special Senate Commission to Study the Prohibition of Marijuana," March 2010, accessed June 12, 2012
OpenDoorsRI.org, "The Criminal Justice Costs of Marijuana Prohibition in Rhode Island," March 2010, accessed June 12, 2012
Cato.org, "The Budgetary Impact of Ending Drug Prohibition," 2010, accessed June 12, 2012
Rhode Island Department of Corrections, report to General Assembly on potential savings related to decriminalizing marijuana, May 2012
Memo from Jeffrey Miron, Harvard University, to Rhode Island Legislature, March 7, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Rhode Island Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.