The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Lavender

Says state’s mandated tests come from an English company.

George Lavender on Monday, April 29th, 2013 in in Texas House of Representatives debate

George Lavender says an English company supplies Texas public-school assessment exams

During a legislative session marked by backlash against state-mandated testing, Rep. George Lavender offered an amendment to drop some Texas exams for an Iowa alternative.

"I think we need to get at least an American company doing our tests instead of an English company," the Texarkana Republican said April 29, 2013, during debate on a House bill to cut and shorten some tests given under the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness.

The bill won House approval, but without Lavender’s amendment to substitute the Iowa Tests of Basic Skills for certain STAAR exams, which was tabled.

Does an English company provide Texas’ tests?

Since September 1981, according to histories of Texas testing on the education agency’s website, the state’s primary contractor for statewide assessment programs has been the same: the company known today as NCS Pearson, Inc.

By phone, Lavender told us, "I know they have a lot of employees in Texas and I know they have a lot of employees worldwide, but the fact is that they’re a British company, and I would much prefer a U.S.-based company to be doing our testing." The Texas program isn’t functioning as intended, he said, and there are other tests that "have been proven to work across the country."

Susan Aspey, vice president of public affairs for New York-based Pearson North America, told us by phone, "Pearson PLC is the parent company. It is based in the U.K. Pearson’s North American education businesses are based here in North America. Pearson’s testing businesses are based in Minnesota. In the state of Texas, Pearson employs 1,800 people."

Specifically, NCS Pearson is incorporated in Minnesota, she said. Corporate websites and profiles from Bloomberg Businessweek show the company is headquartered in Bloomington, Minn., and was founded in 1962 as National Computer Systems to score psychology diagnostic tests; the name changed to NCS Pearson in 2000 when it was bought by U.K. company Pearson PLC.

Pearson PLC today is a global education services company headquartered at 80 Strand in London that also owns book publisher Penguin and the Financial Times news organization. It listed 42,980 employees in its 2012 annual report, including 18,552 in "North American education" and 16,751 in "international education." Aspey said, "Pearson employs three times as many people in the U.S. as it does in the U.K."

Under NCS Pearson’s 2010-2015 contract with Texas’ schools agency, the company will be paid $468 million for STAAR and Texas Assessment of Knowledge and Skills (TAKS) tests and services. Two of the largest subcontracted amounts were listed as going to online learning company Desire2Learn, based in Canada, and Chicago-based communications firm RR Donnelley.

And who writes the STAAR tests? Three subcontractors plus Texas educators, agency spokeswoman Debbie Ratcliffe told us by email. Items for the test are drafted, she said, by the San Antonio-based K-12 Education Division of a global, private organization, the Princeton, N.J.-headquartered nonprofit Educational Testing Service, and two companies named Lone Star and Tri-Lin Integrated Services. Then they’re edited by the agency and committees of Texas educators, Ratcliffe said.

Our ruling

Lavender said the state’s mandatory tests come from an English company.

Pearson, the parent company of Texas’ testing contractor, is English. Then again, NCS Pearson is incorporated in Minnesota and was American-owned until 2000. Also, test items are generated by subcontractors including the San Antonio division of a global organization headquartered in New Jersey.

Lacking these clarifications, the statement rates as Mostly True.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Monday, May 6th, 2013 at 10:34 a.m.

Subjects: Education

Sources:

Texas House of Representatives, floor debate, April 29, 2013


House Bill 2836, 83rd Texas Legislature


Amendment offered by Rep. George Lavender to House Bill 2836, tabled April 29, 2013


Telephone interview with state Rep. George Lavender, R-Texarkana, April 30, 2013


Texas Education Agency, Technical Digests 2001-2011, accessed online May 6, 2013


Telephone and email interviews, excerpted, with Susan Aspey, vice president of public affairs, Pearson North America, May 3, 2013


BloombergBusinessweek, company overview of NCS Pearson, Inc., accessed online May 6, 2013


BloombergBusinessweek, company snapshot of Pearson PLC,, Inc., accessed online May 6, 2013


Pearsonassessments.com, "Our History" web page, accessed May 6, 2013


Pearson.com, "Our History" web page, accessed May 6, 2013


Pearson PLC "Annual Report and Accounts, 2012," accessed online May 6, 2013


Texas Education Agency contract with NCS Pearson, Inc., signed June 14, 2010


Email interview, excerpted, with Debbie Ratcliffe, Texas Education Agency communications director, May 2, 2013


Email interview, excerpted, with Tom Ewing, director, press relations, Educational Testing Service, May 3, 2013

Written by: Sue Owen
Researched by: Sue Owen
Edited by: W. Gardner Selby

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Texas Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Texas Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe: