Rudy's Florida pitch
With the Florida primary as a make-or-break contest for Rudy Giuliani, the former New York mayor is making an appeal to Floridians with a TV advertisement that makes a variety of claims about his record in office and touts his position on a critical issue in the state — the high cost of homeowners insurance.
From the first line — "Taxes. Insurance. Housing. All a mess. But Rudy Giuliani knows how to fix those" — the 30-second spot paints Giuliani as the candidate who can solve the ills plaguing the average voter. It features a soothing male voice talking as appropriate stock footage rolls in the background.
Dubbed "Jumpstart," the ad is the first of this political season to specifically highlight a Florida-centric issue by mentioning Giuliani's advocacy for the national catastrophe fund. It makes bold claims across the board, but we focused on these three claims:
* "He reformed welfare before others tried." Giuliani can certainly lay claim to being out front on welfare reform, and his overhaul of the New York City welfare system is nothing short of astounding considering he did it "in the teeth of the most intense opposition" from nearly all of the most significant political forces in the city, said Lawrence Mead, professor of politics at New York University.
But Giuliani can't claim New York was the first in the country.
One of the first effective welfare-to-work programs was initiated in San Diego in the early 1980s, Mead said. And Wisconsin instituted an ambitious welfare-to-work program prior to New York City (which is why some people have called former Wisconsin Gov. Tommy Thompson, a onetime presidential candidate, the father of welfare reform). In fact, Giuliani hired one of the architects of the Wisconsin plan to help create changes in New York City.
So if the ad was comparing Giuliani just to his Republican opponents, it's right. Giuliani began making changes shortly after being elected mayor, so 1994. That predates the governorships of Mike Huckabee and Mitt Romney. As for Sens. John McCain and Fred Thompson, the federal welfare reform laws passed in August 1996.
But the ad doesn't narrow the field at all, so we can only deduce it means he reformed welfare before everyone else. And that is False.
* "He's the only candidate who will fight for a national catastrophe fund to reduce insurance rates." It's true, Giuliani is a strong supporter — the strongest in the GOP field. But other candidates have also expressed support, or at least an open mind.
On a spectrum — from supportive to skeptical — this is how they appear to fall: Giuliani, John McCain, Mitt Romney, Mike Huckabee, Fred Thompson. Ron Paul and Duncan Hunter go unranked because they haven't spoken about it.
So when an announcer says Giuliani is "the only candidate who will fight for" a national fund, he has a case. He pledges to be a strong advocate, unlike the other candidates. But some others in the field are open to a federal role in securing homeowner insurance in high-risk areas, so we rate his claim Mostly True.
* He "delivered more tax relief than the other Republicans combined." As any economist or tax expert will tell you, comparing the candidates on tax issues is a bit like trying to hug a greased pig.
Background material provided by the campaign for the ad claims that by the end of Giuliani's term as mayor, New Yorkers' "tax burden" was reduced nearly 20 percent. Under Mike Huckabee, it states, Arkansas residents' state tax burden increased nearly 19 percent; and under Mitt Romney, Massachusetts residents' state tax burden increased about 8 percent.
The Giuliani campaign said those numbers were based on the Tax Foundation's method of calculating the percentage of the state income being taken in state tax.
The Tax Foundation, which was kind enough to analyze tax burden figures for PolitiFact, came up with slightly lower figures for the increases under Mike Huckabee and Mitt Romney: 14 and 7 percent, respectively.
But here are a couple of things to keep in mind. First, the Tax Foundation doesn't do those calculations for cities, so the Giuliani campaign's 20 percent figure is one they arrived at themselves. Also, as Bill Ahern of the Tax Foundation points out, the statewide tax burden his group calculates includes local taxes that a governor doesn't control.
Ahern also warned that tax burden numbers don't tell the whole story. Each person led in different situations. For example, he said, Huckabee was under court order to increase education spending in Arkansas. "Is that him raising taxes?" Ahern asked. "Well, he signed it."
Consider as well, Ahern said, that Romney fought hard to decrease the income tax rate in Massachusetts from 5.3 to 5 percent, but he couldn't persuade the Democrat-controlled legislature to go along with him. "Any honest reading of the record would show he's a tax cutter," Ahern said.
As for federal legislators like John McCain and Fred Thompson, Giuliani's team discounted them altogether. Neither were executives in a state, city, municipality, county or other government, "and thus could not deliver tax cuts."
Given the many confirming sources, it's clear Giuliani has a strong record on tax cutting. However, his claim of delivering "more tax relief than the other Republicans combined" is next to impossible to accurately judge, so we rate the statement in Giuliani's ad Mostly True.
Sources:Rudy Giuliani campaign, "Jumpstart," Jan. 16, 2008
Independent Budget Office of the City of New York, Welfare And Work, Feb. 14, 2005
Interview with Lawrence Mead, professor of politics at New York University and author of "Government Matters: Welfare Reform in Wisconsin," Jan. 18, 2008
Interview with Ron Haskins, Senior Fellow, Economic Studies at the Brookings Institution and author of the book "Welfare Over Work."
Tax Foundation, State and Local Tax Burdens Compared to Other U.S. States, 1970-2007
Club for Growth, White papers, On each candidate's record on economic issues
New York Daily News, "Rudy's real tax record," by E.J. McMahon, Aug 6, 2007
Interview with Bill Ahern of the Tax Foundation, Jan. 18, 2008
Interview with E.J. McMahon, a senior fellow for tax and budgetary studies at the Manhattan Institute, Jan. 18, 2008
Interview with Nachama Soloveichik of the Club for Growth, Jan. 18, 2008
Interview with Jason Miller of the Giuliani campaign, Jan. 18, 2008
St. Petersburg Times, Giuliani takes early swings for president, April 5, 2007
St. Petersburg Times, No promises, just blunt talk from McCain, Sept. 2, 2007
St. Petersburg Times, Buzz blogs: Thompson on Cuban stogies, Terri Schiavo and cat fund
St. Petersburg Times, State is gaining in GOP clout, May 20, 2007
Interview with Kristy Campbell, Mitt Romney campaign, Jan. 16, 2008
Interview with Jeff Sadosky, Fred Thompson campaign, Jan. 16, 2008
Interview with Jason Miller, Rudy Giuliani campaign, Jan. 16, 2008
We want to hear your suggestions and comments.
For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.
Keep up to date with Politifact :
- Sign up for our e-mail (about once a week)
- Put a free PolitiFact widget on your blog or Web page
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Truth-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on GOP Pledge-O-Meter items
- Subscribe to our RSS feeds on Obameter items
- Advertise on PolitiFact
- Shop the PolitiFact store for T-shirts, hats and other PolitiFact swag