The story

Off key in Music City

By Bill Adair
Published on Tuesday, October 7th, 2008 at 11:55 p.m.


SUMMARY: In a town hall-style debate, McCain and Obama tangle in Nashville. We check their claims and find some truth and some stretching.

In their first town hall-style debate, John McCain and Barack Obama grabbed the microphones and strolled around the Nashville stage as they fielded questions from people in the audience and others who had submitted questions over the Internet. We've checked the following items so far:

• Obama repeated a misleading Democratic talking point that suggested oil companies are failing to drill for oil in 68-million acres. That suggests they're not trying and ignores the long time it takes to get approval to drill. We rated that one False.

• McCain was correct that he has broken with the Bush administration on global warming. He's been lauded as a leader on the issue. We rated his claim True.

• We found McCain was way off with his claim that Obama has voted to raise taxes 94 times. So far off, in fact, that we gave it a False.

• Obama was correct that earmarks account for only about $18-billion; that is less than 5 percent of this year's budget deficit. We gave that one a True.

• A year ago, we gave McCain a Half True for his claim that 50,000 people made their living off eBay. Now he says 1.3-million people do, so we raised our ruling to False.

• McCain loves to cite Obama's requests for political pork. In the Nashville town hall, McCain said Obama had "voted for" a $3-million overhead projector for a Chicago planetarium among the nearly $1-billion in pork he supported. We rated that one Mostly True.

Advertisement
Bookmark this
About this story

Sources:

See individual Truth-O-Meter items.

Researchers: Bill Adair

Personalities: Barack Obama, John McCain

Related rulings:
John McCain on Economy, Tuesday, October 7th, 2008. Ruling: False | Details
Barack Obama on Government Spending and the Federal Budget, Tuesday, October 7th, 2008. Ruling: True | Details
John McCain on Global Warming and the Environment, Tuesday, October 7th, 2008. Ruling: True | Details
Barack Obama on Energy, Tuesday, October 7th, 2008. Ruling: False | Details
John McCain on Government Spending and the Federal Budget, Tuesday, October 7th, 2008. Ruling: Half-True | Details

Contribute

No, we don’t want to take your money. But we are more than willing to listen if you know of any facts or story ideas for the Truth-O-Meter. truthometer@politifact.com

PolitiFact.com

PolitiFact is a project of the St. Petersburg Times and Congressional Quarterly to help you find the truth in the presidential campaign. Every day, reporters and researchers from the Times and CQ will analyze the candidates' speeches, TV ads and interviews and determine whether the claims are accurate. >> More

Logos
Sorting out the truth in politics
Candidates

Search PolitiFact via Google

Browse
Feeds

Get PolitiFact:

Knight Batten Award
Advertisement