The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Becerra

"We've had 11,000 attempts to amend the Constitution since 1789."

Xavier Becerra on Friday, July 29th, 2011 in a press conference

Of 11,000 attempts to amend U.S. Constitution, only 27 amendments have passed

At a press briefing about the debt limit negotiations, Rep. Xavier Becerra, D-Calif., criticized a Republican push for a balanced budget amendment. He said Congress should not be hasty about amending the Constitution and noted that only a tiny number of amendments ultimately pass.

"We’ve had 11,000 attempts to amend the Constitution since 1789. Twenty-seven amendments have been passed, 10 of them in one shot with the Bill of Rights. And so, we’re now hearing that Republicans may want two, three days before they plunge us into the economic abyss, propose the eleven-thousand and first constitutional amendment so that in less than three days we pass that when it’s taken over 230 years to pass 27 out of the 11,000 that were proposed," Rep. Becerra said, adding, "That’s the height of ridicule."

Becerra was later named to the "super committee" that is developing a plan to comply with the budget cuts required by the debt ceiling vote.

Before we get to the numbers, it’s worth reviewing the process for amending the U.S. Constitution.

Amendments can be proposed two ways: in Congress or by a national convention assembled at the request of the two-thirds of the states legislatures.  

The national convention approach has been attempted twice but has never been successful. So the successful amendments have all originated in Congress.  

And according to a congressional tally, Becerra is just about right on target: Congress has considered "approximately 11,372 amendments" from 1789 through December 31, 2008, the most recent tally available, according to the Statistics and Lists section of the United States Senate website.

Why is it "approximately" 11,372? The site says that's because of a number of factors, including inadequate indexing of legislation in the early years of Congress.

Of those 11,372 proposed amendments, only 27 have been approved by Congress and ratified by the states. Why such a low success rate? Senate Historian Donald Ritchie told us that amending the Constitution is "an extremely complicated process" and an amendment "essentially only gets adopted when there’s a broad national consensus on the issue."

University of Pennsylvania law professor Kermit Roosevelt agreed, noting that "the founders wanted the bar set high because they believed that most issues should be left to the ordinary political process. A constitutional amendment takes an issue away from the normal process of democratic politics, quite likely forever. So it makes sense to require an extraordinary consensus to resolve it permanently."

Most proposals aren’t inspired by a broad national consensus, however. The motivation for introducing a constitutional amendment is often political. "Every time the Supreme Court makes a ruling some member of Congress doesn’t like, someone pushes for a constitutional amendment on the matter," Ritchie told us.

For example, the day after the Supreme Court ruled flag burning to be protected speech in 1989, U.S. Rep. Michael Bilirakis, R-Fla., introduced an amendment outlawing desecration of the flag. Amendments to ban flag burning have been introduced in every session of Congress since, spanning more than two decades.

Many amendments are introduced many times. An amendment defining marriage as between one man and one woman has been introduced numerous times in the last decade, including four times in a single session of Congress. Some are introduced many times but with variations. Following the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, members of Congress introduced amendments that would provide for the continuity of Congress in the event of a sudden mass vacancy in the Capitol. The amendments varied on what constituted that "mass vacancy" and how replacement lawmakers would be chosen. None of the amendments passed.

Back to Becerra. He was correct that only a tiny percentage of amendments ultimately pass and are ratified. He said 11,000; the official count puts the number at approximately 11,372. That's close enough to earn a True.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Tuesday, August 30th, 2011 at 11:38 a.m.

Subjects: Legal Issues

Sources:

Democratic Caucus, Transcript of Press Availability After House Democratic Caucus Meeting, July 29, 2011

National Archives, Constitution of the United States, full text

James Rogers, "The Other Way to Amend the Constitution: The Article V Constitutional Convention Amendment Process", published in the Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, pages 1009-1010, 2007

United States Senate, Statistics & Lists: Measures Proposed to Amend the Constitution,  Accessed Aug. 7, 2011

United States Senate, Virtual Reference Desk, Accessed August 11, 2011

United States Senate, Art & History: Historical Minutes, Accessed August 11, 2011

Interview with United States Senate Historian Donald Ritchie, August 16, 2011

Interview with Professor Kermit Roosevelt, August 16, 2011

Library of Congress, H.J. Res 302 - 101st Congress, Accessed August 16, 2011

Library of Congress, H.J. Res 89 - 110th Congress, Accessed August 16, 2011

Continuity of Government Commission, Proposals for Reform, Accessed August 16, 2011

Justia, Texas v. Johnson, Accessed August 16, 2011

Written by: Will Short Gorham
Researched by: Will Short Gorham
Edited by: Bill Adair

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments.

For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.

For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Truth-O-MeterTM:
Subscribe: