Virginia state employees "pay nothing" toward their pensions.
Bob McDonnell on Wednesday, July 13th, 2011 in a TV interviews
Gov. McDonnell says Virginia state employees "pay nothing" toward their pensions
Gov. Bob McDonnell recently proclaimed Virginia’s retirement system needs change.
"We’re one of only four states in the country that the state employees pay nothing (toward their pension)," McDonnell said in a July 13 interview with CNBC’s Squawk Box. "We pay the employee and employer share."
So state employees don’t contribute a dime to their own retirement?
A couple of our readers who saw the TV interview told us McDonnell’s is wrong. So we decided to look into the governor’s statement.
The CNBC interview began with McDonnell -- widely mentioned as vice-presidential prospect for next year's Republication national ticket -- accepting praise for Virginia's sound financial condition. When asked about the state's pension, McDonnell acknowledged it has $18 billion in unfunded liabilities and blamed part of the problem on the General Assembly's reluctance to ask state employees to kick in money.
Jeff Caldwell, a spokesman for the governor, said McDonnell’s claim was based on an October 14, 2008, report from the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission that said Virginia was among five states that did not require its employees to make pension contributions.
Caldwell said the other four were Tennessee, Florida, Utah and Missouri. But he said Virginia is now one of four states without employee contributions because Missouri, as of January 1, 2011, began requiring new hires to contribute 4 percent to their plans.
There are major problems with the governor’s claim, however.
State employees hired before July 1, 2010, recently began contributing 5 percent of their salary to their pension plans under a change that went into effect June 25, 2011 -- 18 days before McDonnell’s interview on CNBC. The new policy is contained in a well-publicized budget provision approved by the General Assembly earlier this year that gave state employees a 5 percent raise and simultaneously required them to contribute 5 percent of their salary to their pensions.
The governor was hardly a stranger to this development. He urged legislators to require state employees to pay into the pension fund during his State of the Commonwealth Address on Jan. 12. McDonnell signed a budget containing such a provision -- although more lenient than what he wanted -- on May 2.
The change reversed a deal made in 1983 when Virginia agreed to pay for its employees’ pension contributions instead of giving them a raise that year.
This year’s pension contribution deal only affected longer-serving workers. Newer workers, hired on or after July 1, 2010, had already been required to contribute 5 percent toward their pensions from the day they began work. That provision is part of a bill McDonnell signed on April 13, 2010.
McDonnell made his statement on CNBC four days after the pay period ended in which longer-serving state workers made their first contributions to pensions. New state employees had contributed for as long as a year, depending on their start dates.
Caldwell said Virginia is still paying the pension contribution for longer-serving workers, because the state gave employees the 5 percent raise in return for a 5 percent pension contribution.
"There was a requirement to pay in, but then the state paid employees to offset that," he said.
Caldwell offered no explanation how the governor’s statement could be true in light of the fact that newer employees have been paying into the system for as long as a year.
Those newer employees are not eligible for the 5 percent pay hike provided to longer-serving workers, according to the Virginia Department of Human Resource Management’s website. The newer employees received no salary boost to offset their pension contribution.
About 6,000 new state employees have been hired and started paying into their pensions during the past year, said Jeanne Chenault, a spokeswoman for the Virginia Retirement System. Another 84,000 veteran workers were affected by the 5 percent raise/pension contribution.
Ron Jordan, executive director of the Virginia Government Employees Association, said even with the raise, a burden for paying pension contributions has been placed on the backs of veteran workers. Next time there’s a raise, workers will pay the 5 percent contribution on a higher salary, Jordan said, meaning they will ultimately pay more towards their pension than what’s covered by the 5 percent raise given to them this year.
Jordan also took issue with the contention that veteran state workers’ immediate loss from the pension contribution was entirely covered by the 5 percent raise. He pointed to a document on the Department of Human Resource Management website saying some employees could see a drop in their take home pay after the pension contribution and raise go into effect.
McDonnell, in a CNBC interview, said state workers pay nothing toward their pension and that Virginia makes the contribution for them. That was the case for several decades, but it is no longer true.
For more than a year, new state employees -- those hired on or after July 1, 2010 -- have been required to make pension contributions from the day they reported to work. About 6,000 new state workers now fall under the legislation.
Longer-serving bureaucrats also are being required to ante up. McDonnell’s interview on CNBC came 18 days after after well-publicized provisions went into effect requiring longer-serving state employees to contribute 5 percent of their pay to Virginia’s pension.
The governor’s spokesman correctly points out that longer-serving employees were given a 5 percent raise to offset their pension contribution. Nonetheless, veteran state employees are now chipping in for their pensions and any future raises they receive will also increase their payments into the retirement fund.
The governor, in his interview, said Virginia is one of four states that foot the entire bill for pension contributions. But McDonnell removed a fifth state that had been on the list -- Missouri -- because at the start of this year, Missouri began requiring new hires to pay in.
So Virginia shouldn’t be on that list either. McDonnell’s claim goes beyond inaccurate and enters the realm of the absurd. We rate his statement Pants on Fire.
Published: Thursday, July 21st, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.
Gov. Bob McDonnell’s appearence on CNBC’s Squawk Box, July 13, 2011. (Statement is about 2 minutes into the interview).
Virginia Retirement System website, "Plan 1 state employees now pay 5% contribution," accessed July 18 2011.
Virginia Retirement System website, "VRS retirement plan 2," accessed July 18, 2011.
University of Virginia, "2011 budget and VRS-related legislation," April 12, 2011.
Virginia Department of Human Resource Management, "June 25, 2011 compensation changes," accessed July 19, 2011.
E-mail from Jeff Caldwell, spokesman for Gov. Robert McDonnell, July 19, 2011.
Interview with Jeff Caldwell, July 19, 2011.
Richmond Times-Dispatch, "New 5% VRS contributions likely mean small pay decline," July 15, 2011.
Richmond Times-Dispatch, "VRS back on track, but employee contributions expected to increase," July 12, 2011.
Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission, "Review of state employee total compensation, part 1," Oct. 14, 2008.
Richmond Times-Dispatch, "State makes small dent in pension debt, but payback looms," March 6, 2011.
Interviews with Ron Jordan, executive director of the Virginia Government Employees Association, July 18-19, 2011.
Interview with Robley S.Jones, director of government relations at the Virginia Education Association, July 18-19, 2011.
Interview with Jeanne Chenault, spokeswoman for the Virginia Retirement System, July 19, 2011.
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Virginia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.