On repeal of Wisconsin's smoking ban
Scott Walker on Thursday, June 30th, 2011 in a news release
On repeal of Wisconsin's smoking ban, Walker goes from pro to con
It’s been a year since you could light up a smoke in Wisconsin bars and restaurants.
The state’s smoking ban, approved by the Legislature and Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle in 2009, took effect in July 2010 and continues to stir debates.
Some tavern and restaurant owners say it’s hurt their business and driven away long-time patrons -- or sent them outside to shiver. Others say state government shouldn’t be mandating what businesses can and can not do.
Meanwhile, smoking ban supporters are pleased they can have a beer or a meal and not go home smelling like an ashtray.
On June 30, 2011, as the ban’s first anniversary approached, Gov. Scott Walker issued a statement that said he would not support a repeal of the ban. That sounded like a new stance from the conservative Republican governor.
So, we decided to roll out the Flip-O-Meter, which measures how consistent politicians have been on key issues. Remember: It does not examine whether a change in position is a good one from a political or a policy perspective.
Indeed, on contentious issues, some will view a switch as sensible flexibility in response to constituent demands. Others will see it as political appeasement or caving to pressure. As they say, where you stand depends on where you sit.
In this case, perhaps, especially if you sit at the bar.
Here is the sum total of Walker’s statement:
"Although I did not support the original smoking ban, after listening to people across the state, it is clear to me that it works. Therefore I will not support a repeal."
What did Walker say about the smoking ban in the past?
While a candidate for governor, Walker was opposed to the ban, and then his position shifted -- to being even more strongly opposed to it. The shift came in response to positions staked out by Mark Neumann, his opponent in the Republican primary election.
Here’s how that played out:
Walker said on July 6, 2010, that he would didn’t believe that government should have been involved. "On principle I don’t think the government or anybody else should be telling these establishments or anybody else what they should or shouldn’t do," he said.
A few days later, Neumann said he supported repealing the ban: "The smoking ban to me is a local issue and it’s about personal responsibility and personal freedoms and local control."
The following day, on July 10, 2010, Walker matched Neumann’s call for a repeal of the ban: "I don't think the government should have been involved in a smoking ban in the first place, and as governor, I would sign a repeal of this law."
The smoking ban did not become a key issue during the primary campaign or the general election. And Walker did not made any additional statements about the ban until the one where he said he would not back its repeal.
Studies by groups such as the University of Wisconsin Carbone Cancer Center said that air quality in state bars and restaurants had improved 92 percent since the ban took effect. And SmokeFree Wisconsin, a group that supported the ban, said 75 percent of state residents support the ban.
So, Walker started out opposed to the ban, even toughening his stance to promise a repeal. But now he’s opposed to a repeal, so the ban will remain. For those scoring at home, that comes in as a Full Flop.
Published: Thursday, July 7th, 2011 at 9:00 a.m.
Subjects: Public Health
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Doyle signs statewide smoking ban for bars, restaurants, workplaces," May 18, 2009
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Neumann supports repealing smoking ban," July 9, 2010
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Walker matches Neumann, is willing to repeal smoking ban," July 10, 2010
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Smoking ban improves air quality by 92%," Dec. 15, 2010
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Gov. Walker: Keep smoking ban in place, " June 30, 2011
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "One year later, smoking ban critics losing steam," July 5, 2011
SmokeFree Wisconsin survey, June 21, 2011
Emails, Cullen Werwie, spokesman, Gov. Scott Walker, June 30, 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.