President Barack Obama’s health care reform "slashed $500 billion from Medicare."
Sean Duffy on Thursday, June 7th, 2012 in a news release
Wisconsin GOP U.S. Rep. Sean Duffy says "Obamacare" law "slashed $500 billion from Medicare"
On June 6, 2012, Wisconsin Democrat Pat Kreitlow huffed and puffed in declaring that U.S. Rep. Sean Duffy, R-Wis., "voted twice to end Medicare."
It was a claim, made numerous times about others, that PolitiFact National labeled its Lie of the Year for 2011. Kreitlow, who is challenging Duffy in the November 2012 election, earned a Pants on Fire for his version.
A day later, Duffy fumed over Kreitlow’s support of President Barack Obama’s health care reform law, saying it "slashed $500 billion from Medicare."
That has been another popular claim for the Truth-O-Meter.
Let’s see whether Duffy is spouting anything more than hot air.
The first phases of the health care reform law, which was upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court in June 2012, took effect in March 2010.
Six months later, the 60 Plus Association, a conservative advocacy group for senior citizens, began running TV ads against Democratic members of Congress from Wisconsin and other states who voted for it.
The claim? The law "will cut $500 billion from Medicare" and "hurt the quality" of care for seniors.
PolitiFact National found the law does not take $500 billion out of the current Medicare budget, but reduces the growth of Medicare spending by just over $500 billion over 10 years.
In rating the claim Mostly False, our colleagues noted that the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office projects Medicare spending will rise to $929 billion in 2020, an increase of $430 million over actual spending in 2009.
So, Medicare spending continues to increase, but not by as much as it would have without the reform law.
The claims of a $500 billion cut to Medicare, however, have continued.
In May 2012, a Republican Ohio congressman accused a Democratic Ohio congresswoman of having "gutted Medicare by $500 billion" by voting for the health care reform law. PolitiFact Ohio rated the claim Mostly False, noting that Medicare spending would have grown at a faster rate without the law.
The same month, PolitiFact Florida gave a Mostly False to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce for saying "seniors will see $500 billion in Medicare cuts to fund ‘Obamacare.’" Our colleagues found that slowing the growth in Medicare spending is intended to offset, to some extent, the overall cost of the law.
(For a comprehensive look at Medicare and claims made about it, read "The PolitiFact guide to Medicare attack lines.")
Duffy's made his claim in a news release issued June 7, 2012 to criticize Kreitlow's support of the health care reform law. Regarding the law's effect on Medicare, Duffy said:
"Kreitlow's full-throated support for the government’s unwarranted takeover of healthcare slashed $500 billion from Medicare, too."
(Claims that Obama's law is a government takeover of health care was PolitiFact National's Lie of the Year for 2010.)
Duffy campaign manager Justin Richards argued that "slashed" is an accurate way of describing how the law reduces the growth in Medicare spending. But even though some of the news article excerpts Richards cited referred to cuts, he acknowledged that the reductions are in the growth of future spending.
Duffy said the federal health care reform law "slashed $500 billion from Medicare."
There is an element of truth in his statement because Medicare spending will grow by about $500 billion less than it would have without the law. But the law has not already reduced Medicare spending by $500 billion, as Duffy suggests.
We rate Duffy's statement Mostly False.
Published: Wednesday, July 11th, 2012 at 9:00 a.m.
PolitiFact, "Medicare ‘cuts’ in the health care law will hurt seniors, says 60 Plus Association," Sept. 20, 2010
PolitiFact Virginia, "American Crossroads says Tim Kaine urged $500 billion in Medicare cuts," June 20, 2012
PolitiFact Ohio, "Jim Renacci says that Betty Sutton ‘gutted Medicare by $500 billion’ with her vote for health care reform," May 21, 2012
PolitiFact Florida, "Chamber says Bill Nelson voted to cut Medicare $500 billion," May 15, 2012
PolitiFact, "The PolitiFact guide to Medicare attack lines," May 6, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.