"Wisconsin still ranks first among the 50 states in manufacturing jobs per capita."
Rebecca Kleefisch on Thursday, November 1st, 2012 in a radio address
Rebecca Kleefisch says Wisconsin ranks first among states in manufacturing jobs per capita
Wisconsin’s is unmatched nationally on a key jobs measure, Lt. Gov. Rebecca Kleefisch asserted while promoting a fall summit of small-business owners and officials of Gov. Scott Walker’s administration.
"You probably already know we lead the nation in making cheese, and you definitely know the Packers will always be at the top," Kleefisch said while delivering the governor’s statewide radio address Nov. 1, 2012. "But did you know that Wisconsin still ranks first among the 50 states in manufacturing jobs per capita? That’s right!"
Kleefisch’s radio statement also ran as an opinion piece that was published by various new outlets.
It’s well documented that Walker promised in the 2010 governor’s race that Wisconsin would add 250,000 private-sector jobs by the end of his first term, in January 2015. Through nearly two years of his four-year term, job gains total 31,911.
It’s also pretty well known that Wisconsin has lost a big chunk of its manufacturing sector going back a decade or more.
So is it possible the state is still the king of making things?
There’s more than one way to skin this statistical cat, but Wisconsin scores high on several manufacturing-job measures.
Manufacturing dependency: The factory sector here employs a bigger share of the state's workers than any other state except Indiana, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported on Oct. 7, 2012.
Idaho-based Economic Modeling Specialists Intl. reported in March 2012 that "Indiana is 86% more concentrated in manufacturing than average and just nudges Wisconsin for the top spot in our analysis." Indiana is home to Subaru and Honda auto plants, which give the state a boost.
Manufacturing vs. government jobs: Calculations by the Wisconsin Budget Project have shown that Wisconsin and Indiana are neck-and-neck for the highest ratio of manufacturing jobs to government jobs in the nation -- a ratio viewed by some as a good measure of a state’s economic health.
But Kleefisch referred to a third measure: Manufacturing jobs per capita.
We located U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports and crunched the numbers behind her claim. We separately enlisted Jon Peacock, research director of the Wisconsin Budget Project, an arm of the Wisconsin Council on Children and Families.
Wisconsin -- as Kleefisch claimed -- tops Indiana and every other state when you compare factory jobs to the overall state population.
Peacock took a slightly different tack, comparing those jobs to the overall pool of potential workers -- the non-institutional population age 16 and older.
"Wisconsin is #1, and by a much larger margin than I anticipated," Peacock said. "What I found is that 10 percent of Wisconsin’s population age 16 and older works in manufacturing. Indiana is #2 at 9.6 percent, followed by Iowa at 9.1 percent, and Kansas at 7.5 percent. The national average is 4.9 percent."
That’s good news and bad news, Peacock said.
It’s a point of pride -- and manufacturing jobs are extremely important for Wisconsin. But the state economy might be stronger if it diversified and became less dependent upon a sector that will probably continue to decline as a percentage of the national workforce, Peacock said.
Kleefisch, though, is on target with the numbers.
Part of the explanation is that Wisconsin dropped a smaller share of its manufacturing jobs than many other big factory-reliant states in the 2000s. Those job losses in the sector began to reverse in about January 2010, both nationally and in Wisconsin. Walker took office in January 2011.
Still, though, Wisconsin is 150,000 manufacturing jobs short of its January 2000 total, according to September 2012 federal figures.
Kleefisch claimed that Wisconsin "still ranks first among the 50 states in manufacturing jobs per capita."
Economists debate the wisdom of heavy reliance on that sector, but Kleefisch accurately describes the state’s ranking.
We rate her statement True.
Published: Sunday, November 11th, 2012 at 9:00 a.m.
Governor’s weekly radio address, archived for Nov. 1, 2012
Interview with Casey Himebauch, spokesperson, Lt. Gov. Kleefisch, Nov. 7, 2012
Interview with Jon Peacock, research director, Wisconsin Budget Project, Nov. 7, 2012
Interview with Tom Still, president, Wisconsin Technology Council, Nov. 7, 2012
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Huge task ahead for Obama or Romney to improve manufacturing," Oct. 7, 2012
PolitiFact.com, Truth-O-Meter item, "Barack Obama says U.S. has gained a half-million manufacturing jobs," Sept. 6, 2012
Economic Modeling Specialists Intl, "Ranking States by Their Dependence on Manufacturing," March 1, 2012
Economic Modeling Specialists Intl, "The Shrinking Sector: Manufacturing as a Proportion of all Jobs Since 2001," Dec. 31, 2011
Wisconsin Technology Council, "Even in a manufacturing state, a diverse economy is vital for job creation," Feb. 8, 2012
Wisconsin Budget Project, "Wisconsin has nation’s highest ratio of manufacturing jobs to government jobs," Issue Brief #2, updated May 2011
Center on Wisconsin Strategy (COWS), "The State of Working Wisconsin," 2012
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, database search, State and Metro Area Employment, Hours and Earnings, Nov. 6, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.