Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
Experts say the phrase “Chinese virus” could foster discrimination toward people of Chinese or Asian origin.
The stigma from the term can have a long-lasting effect.
The term can also hold back individuals from seeking medical care out of fear of being stigmatized.
The way President Donald Trump sees it, there’s nothing wrong with calling the new coronavirus the "Chinese virus." But the World Health Organization, the director of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and other health experts say that phrasing is wrong.
Reporters during White House briefings on the coronavirus have asked Trump why he uses that phrase even when critics say it creates a stigma and is racist.
Trump at a March 17 briefing suggested he was using the term in reaction to moves from China that he didn’t like.
"Well, China was putting out information which was false, that our military gave this to them," Trump said. "That was false, and rather than having an argument, I said I have to call it where it came from. It did come from China. So, I think it’s a very accurate term. But no, I didn’t appreciate the fact that China was saying that our military gave it to them. Our military did not give it to anybody."
Trump said he didn’t think his preferred phrase created a stigma. "I think saying that our military gave it to them creates a stigma."
On March 18, Trump again defended his phrasing after a reporter said there had been dozens of incidents of bias against Chinese Americans in the United States, and that the U.S. Health and Human Services secretary said ethnicity does not cause the novel coronavirus.
"It’s not racist at all, no, not at all," Trump said. "It comes from China. That’s why. It comes from China. I want to be accurate."
Trump added that "China tried to say at one point, maybe they stopped now" that the coronavirus was caused by American soldiers.
A spokesman for China’s foreign ministry on March 12 suggested, without providing evidence, that the United States was to blame for the coronavirus in China. "It might be U.S. army who brought the epidemic to Wuhan," Zhao Lijian tweeted.
The World Health Organization has said that an outbreak of COVID-19, the respiratory disease caused by a new coronavirus, began in Wuhan, China, in December 2019. It has not linked it to U.S. troops. China’s initial response to the outbreak has been criticized as slow and secretive.
Still, applying the word "Chinese" to a virus that’s now all around the world, that has upended daily life worldwide, and fueled global anxiety and fear is problematic and stigmatizes Chinese individuals, experts told PolitiFact.
"We want to keep the focus on the virus, not on ethnicity or racial differences," said Natalia Molina, a professor of American studies and ethnicity at the University of Southern California. "We want to keep the focus on prevention, not increase an us-them divide."
At a March 10 House hearing, Rep. Lois Frankel, D-Fla., asked CDC director Robert Redfield whether he agreed that calling the coronavirus the "Chinese coronavirus" was "absolutely wrong and inappropriate."
"Yes," Redfield said.
Neither the White House nor Trump’s re-election campaign provided an on-the-record response for PolitiFact’s story.
Geographic terms have been adopted in the past for diseases, such as the Spanish flu and Middle East Respiratory Syndrome. And Trump isn’t the only one to have used the phrase "Chinese virus."
A Twitter account managed by Trump’s re-election campaign tweeted a 38-second video compiling instances when cable TV news reporters — on Fox News, CNN, and MSNBC — used the term "Chinese coronavirus," "Wuhan coronavirus" or "Chinese virus" when reporting on the outbreak. (PolitiFact used the phrase "Wuhan coronavirus" in headlines of two January fact-checks.)
The March 12 Trump campaign tweet claimed Trump was accused of "racism and xenophobia for stating the facts."
"This is a foreign virus that originated in Wuhan, China. Just a few weeks ago, Democrats and the media were all saying it!" the tweet said.
But experts say it’s best to not name diseases after geographic places.
WHO in 2015 issued best practices guidance for the naming of new human infectious diseases, with the aim of minimizing "unnecessary negative impact" on industries and to avoid offending any cultural, social, national, regional, professional or ethnic groups. The guidance said disease names should not include geographic locations, such as cities, countries, regions and continents.
The phrase "Chinese virus" could foster discrimination toward people of Chinese or Asian origin, said Elizabeth L. Petrun Sayers, a behavioral and social scientist at RAND Corporation.
Using the geographic term suggests that they may be more susceptible to the virus and more likely to spread COVID-19, Petrun Sayers said.
"These types of assumptions are incorrect, because viruses do not target specific racial or ethnic groups, and have implications for shaping the general public’s attitudes towards persons of Asian origin," Petrun Sayers said.
The stigma can have a long-lasting effect.
Research about severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS, says that residents in Hong Kong, near the center of the 2003 outbreak, experienced shunning, insults and exclusion from professional and social circles, Petrun Sayers said. "Discrimination creates undeserved distress for those affected or believed to be affected and can severely decrease their quality of life," she said.
The term can also hold back individuals from seeking medical care out of fear of being stigmatized, Molina said. "They will be less likely to seek medical care, which undermines all of our public health," she said.
Molina said it’s important to keep in mind how rhetoric affects people.
"At a time when we are worried about how social isolation is affecting us," she said. "We need to understand that racial animus is only going to make things worse for those groups."
C-SPAN, President Trump and Coronavirus Task Force Hold Briefing, March 17, 2020
Phone interview, Natalia Molina, a professor of American studies and ethnicity at the University of Southern California, March 17, 2020
Email interview, Elizabeth L. Petrun Sayers, a behavioral and social scientist at RAND Corporation, March 17, 2020
Email interview, Katherine A. Mason, assistant professor of anthropology ay
Brown University, March 17, 2020
World Health Organization, Best practices for naming of new human infectious diseases, May 2015; Q&A on coronaviruses (COVID-19), March 9, 2020
Twitter, TrumpWarRoom tweet, March 12, 2020
Twitter, @zlj517 tweet, March 12, 2020
Sciencedirect.com, The experience of SARS-related stigma at Amoy Gardens, available online May 23, 2005
PolitiFact, Fact-checking Donald Trump’s mistakes about European travel due to coronavirus, May 12, 2020
ForeignPolicy.com, China Goes on Diplomatic Offensive Over Coronavirus Response, March 6, 2020
The New York Times, China Spins Coronavirus Crisis, Hailing Itself as a Global Leader, Feb. 28, 2020, updated March 3, 2020
The Wall Street Journal, How It All Started: China’s Early Coronavirus Missteps, March 6, 2020
CDC, SARS, page last reviewed Dec. 6, 2017
Nature.com, What China’s coronavirus response can teach the rest of the world, March 17, 2020
Twitter, @CSPAN, tweet, March 18, 2020
Twitter, @RepJudyChu tweet, Feb. 27, 2020