Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Democratic gubernatorial nominee Bill White has vowed to tighten rules restricting state employees from working as lobbyists, recently noting that Perry's top staffers have kept the revolving door spinning.
"Most of his chiefs of staff have been lobbyists," White said to a crowd of about 35 people in the North Texas town of Crowell on Aug. 14.
White was more specific in an ethics reform proposal he released in April: "Five of seven Perry chiefs of staff have been lobbyists."
Quick aside: State law regulates lobbying, defined as "direct communications" with members of state agencies, the legislative or executive branch of state government to influence legislation or administrative action. That includes the offices of the governor.
White proposed to prohibit the governor's senior staff from working on issues related to their former employment for two years. And "when departing, they will be prohibited from lobbying the governor's office or their state agency for two years," according to White's plan.
Mark Miner, a spokesman for Perry's campaign, has said that "the governor has some of the toughest ethics policies anywhere in the country," according to a Aug. 19 article in the Dallas Morning News. "You cannot lobby his office for one year and a legislative session."
Still, we wondered if White's chiefs-of-staff complaint was true.
So we went down the roster of the governor's chiefs of staff and combed through the Texas Ethics Commission's online database of registered lobbyists, who are required to report their compensation and expenditures. But that list only dates back to 1998, so we reached out to the former chiefs of staff themselves.
Barry McBee chief of staff, December 2000-August 2001; registered lobbyist 2001-02McBee was the first of the seven chiefs of staff Perry has had during his gubernatorial tenure. McBee has also been chairman of the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission, deputy commissioner at the Texas Department of Agriculture and an aide to former Gov. Bill Clements.
McBee was a lobbyist when he worked for the law firm Bracewell & Patterson (now Bracewell & Giuliani). The ethics commission lists nine clients for McBee, including AT&T and defense contractor Northrop Grumman, in 2002, his most recent year as a lobbyist. The commission reports McBee's compensation from the law firm that year as at least $200,000.
Where's McBee now? At the University of Texas System, where's he's worked as vice chancellor for governmental relations since 2006 — also a lobbying job, albeit for a public institution.
Mike McKinney chief of staff, September 2001-November 2002; registered lobbyist 1999-2001
McKinney served in the Texas House of Representatives from 1984 to 1991 and led the Texas Health and Human Services Commission during George W. Bush's first term as governor. McKinney was registered as a lobbyist from 1999 to August 2001 while he was a vice president of Centene Corp., a St. Louis-based health insurance company. Rod Davis, a spokesman at the Texas A&M University System, where McKinney is now chancellor, said he had "registered as a lobbyist as a standard precaution for having any contacts with legislators" but "was not primarily a 'lobbyist' by any means."
Mike Toomey chief of staff December 2002-September 2004; registered lobbyist 1990-2002, 2004-present
The ethics commission database lists more than 30 clients, including Merck and Philip Morris, for Toomey in 2002, the year he became Perry's chief of staff.
Since leaving the Perry administration, Toomey has resumed lobbying. Among his 25 clients listed for 2010 on the ethics commission report are AT&T, Corrections Corp. of America, Hewlett-Packard and Texas Instruments. This year, Toomey reported a minimum of $800,000 and a maximum of about $1.5 million in prospective compensation, according to the commission.
Deirdre Delisi chief of staff September 2004-June 2007
Delisi has been with Perry since he was lieutenant governor. She served as his chief of staff until Perry tapped her to serve as the chairwoman of the Texas Transportation Commission, which governs the Texas Department of Transportation.
Delisi told us that she has never been a registered lobbyist, and after searching news clips and lobbyist registries dating from 1998 on the ethics commission website, we confirmed as much.
Brian Newby chief of staff July 2007-October 2008; registered lobbyist 2009-present
Newby rejoined the law firm Cantey Hanger in 2009 after working for Perry and registered as a lobbyist the same year. This year, the Tarrant Regional Water District was listed as his client, and his prospective compensation from the district was reported as $10,000 to $24,999.99.
Jay Kimbrough chief of staff October 2008-June 2009
Kimbrough, a former Marine, has in recent years filled a troubleshooter role at the Texas Youth Commission and the Texas Department of Transportation. Prior, he was a special adviser to the Texas A&M board of regents.
Kimbrough told us that he's never been a lobbyist, and we didn't find any evidence to the contrary.
Ray Sullivan chief of staff July 2009-present; registered lobbyist 2002-09
Katherine Cesinger, a spokeswoman for Perry, told us that Sullivan first registered as a lobbyist in late 2002, although he doesn't show up in the ethics commission database until 2003. Before that, he worked in various capacities for Perry. Perry appointed him as chief of staff in July, prompting Wayne Slater at the Dallas Morning News to single Sullivan out as an example of "how things work in Austin."
According to the Aug. 19 article, "Ray has shuttled between top jobs on Perry’s staff and as a lobbyist representing interests with business before the state. His wife has directed the governor’s political fundraising. They haven’t broken the law or the rules governing the practice of politics and policy, and they’ve made between $4 million and $5.7 million since Perry’s been governor, according to campaign reports, lobby filings and state payroll records."
In 2009, Sullivan had seven clients listed to his name on the ethics website, including HNTP Corp., a toll-road engineering company.
Seven chiefs of staff later, what have we learned?
Far as we can tell, five have been registered as lobbyists, as White stated. Three of those — McKinney, Toomey and Sullivan — were lobbyists before Perry hired them as chief of staff.
We rate White's statement as True.
Office of the Governor, McKinney resigns as chief of staff, Nov. 13, 2002
Office of the Governor, Gov. Perry names Mike Toomey chief of staff, Nov. 15, 2002
Office of the Governor, Mike Toomey resigns as chief of staff, Sept. 3, 2004
Office of the Governor, Gov. Pery names Deirdre Delisi chief of staff, Sept. 7, 2004
Office of the Governor, Delisi to step down as chief of staff, June 19, 2007
Office of the Governor, Gov. Perry appoints Brian Newby chief of staff, June 20, 2007
Office of the Governor, Gov. Perry announces Eckels, Newby to lead Hurricane Ike recovery and coordination effort, Oct. 15, 2008
Office of the Governor, Gov. Perry names Kimbrough chief of staff, Oct. 16, 2009
Office of the Governor, Gov. Perry names Sullivan chief of staff, June 19, 2009
Texas Ethics Commission, Lobby lists & reports, accessed Aug. 24, 2010
The Texas A&M University System, Michael D. McKinney, M.D., accessed Aug. 24, 2010
The University of Texas System, Vice chancellor for governmental relations, Aug. 25, 2010
Bill White for Texas, Press release: Rick Perry's Texas is about Rick Perry and his friends; chief aide to Perry prime example of revolving door, Aug. 20, 2010
Dallas Morning News, Case of Perry aide and his wife show how things work in Austin, Aug. 19, 2010
Dallas Morning News, Jay Kimbrough still feels call to serve, Nov. 24, 2007
Austin American-Statesman, State government & politics: Perry picks new chief of staff, Nov. 16, 2002
Austin American-Statesman, Governor's right-hand man quitting, Sep. 4, 2004
Austin American-Statesman, 2 former Tech regents: Perry associates pushed resignation, Sept. 5, 2009
Austin American-Statesman, Team tasked with opening state agency to change, July 3, 2010
E-mail interview with Katy Bacon, communications director, Bill White campaign, Aug. 25, 2010
E-mail interview with Katherine Cesinger, spokeswoman, Gov. Rick Perry's office, Aug. 26, 2010
E-mail interview with Rod Davis, communications director, Texas A&M University System, Aug. 25, 2010
E-mail interview with Brian Newby, Aug. 26, 2010
E-mail interview with Mike Toomey, lobbyist, Texas Lobbying Group, Aug. 25, 2010
Interview with Deirdre Delisi, chairwoman, Texas Transportation Commission, Aug. 25, 2010
Interview with Jay Kimbrough, Aug. 25, 2010
Interview with Barry McBee, vice chancellor for governmental relations, University of Texas System, Aug. 25, 2010
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.