Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
It’s hard to confuse a Bulldog with a Papermaker. And Idaho with Wisconsin. And a school district experiencing a state of emergency with one receiving national praise.
But that’s what the American Federation for Children did in a direct mail piece sent to residents of the 1st state Senate District, which stretches from the Fox Cities northeast to include the Door County peninsula.
The seat is open after the retirement of Sen. Alan Lasee, a Republican who had held it since 1977. Seeking to replace him are Democrat Monk Elmer, a family practice physician and president of the Kimberly school board, and former state Rep. Frank Lasee, a Republican and distant relative of Alan Lasee.
The American Federation for Children, which advocates for school choice, is one of several outside groups active in the race, one of a handful that could determine control of the Senate.
The group sent out a direct mail piece headlined "Knock Knock, Monk Elmer and Higher Taxes are Calling." It listed a variety of complaints, each with an official-looking footnote, including this one:
"Monk Elmer just can’t stop spending ... Monk Elmer voted to exceed the spending caps."
Among those receiving it: Elmer himself.
Elmer, president of the Kimberly school board, didn’t recognize the name of the reporter or even the newspaper cited in the footnote: Amy Huddleston, Times-News correspondent.
With good reason: The reporter and newspaper are in Idaho.
The April 17, 2010 article from the Times-News in Twin Falls, Idaho, was about the Kimberly School District there declaring a fiscal state of emergency and approving a resolution seeking voter approval for a special $300,000 tax levy.
Yikes. Tough to campaign for higher office when you’re president of that school board.
Of the American Federation for Children, Elmer said: The group "thinks they can put down any information they want and they don’t think anybody’s checking them."
We left messages at the group’s national office and for former Assembly Speaker Scott Jensen, who heads the group’s state operation, but received no reply.
Elmer and the State Senate Democratic Campaign Committee complained publicly about the ad on Oct. 19, 2010. But there’s been no evidence that the group has modified the claim. Indeed, Elmer says it has shown up in other pieces of direct mail.
Of course, Elmer is doing some explaining to voters about the school board’s budgets since he’s taken over as president in Kimberly, Wis. (home of the Papermakers, population 6,146) and not Kimberly, Idaho, (Bulldogs, pop. 2,614).
The Kimberly, Wis. tax levy increased 0.2 percent to about $14.5 million in his first budget; for 2009-’10 the levy was up $1.2 million, or 8.4 percent, to $15.7 million. On Oct. 25, the board voted for a 2010-’11 tax levy of $16.67 million, up $989,000, or 6.3 percent.
Yes, tax hikes. But no vote to exceed spending caps -- and no state of emergency.
Elmer defended the tax increases, saying the district faced sharp cuts in state aid, while striving to provide excellent schools. Newsweek recently placed Kimberly (Wisconsin) on its list of the best school districts in the country (No. 1,637 out of 2,000, and 27th of the 32 state schools on the list.)
Let’s conclude with an obvious geography lesson:
In a key state Senate race, the American Federation for Children reached for a great headline and issue to use against Democratic candidate Monk Elmer. They reached all the way to Kimberly, Idaho, which is about 1,641 miles away from the home of Monk Elmer back in Kimberly, Wis. That’s about as far as that claim is from the truth. And that makes the claim ridiculous. Pants on Fire.
American Federation for Children website
American Federation for Children, campaign flier
Interview, Monk Elmer, Oct. 26, 2010
Elmer for State Senate website
Magicvalley.com, "Kimberly schools to pursue levy, declare financial emergency."April 17, 2010
Kimberly (Wis.) School District budget documents
Appleton Post-Crescent, "Economic issues at forefront of 1st Wisconsin state Senate race between Montgomery 'Monk" Elmer and Frank Lasee." Oct. 22, 2010
Appleton Post-Crescent, "Kimberly Area School District taxes to rise for second year in a row." Oct. 26, 2010
Newsweek. "America’s Best High Schools." June 13, 2010
Frank Lasee for Senate website
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.