Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Tom Kertscher
By Tom Kertscher September 11, 2011

Wisconsin Rep. Brett Hulsey says only one of 376 bill amendments proposed by a Democrat was adopted by GOP-controlled Assembly

In early August 2011, after surveys tagged him as possibly the nation’s most polarizing governor, Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker pledged a renewed focus on bi-partisanship and jobs.

Later that month, Wisconsin Assembly Speaker Jeff Fitzgerald, R-Horicon, echoed the call. He said some jobs-related bills proposed by Democrats were good and would take them up by the Assembly after it returns from its summer recess on Sept. 13, 2011.

Rep. Brett Hulsey, D-Madison, professed doubts about the sincerity of the GOP calls for bi-partisanship. On Aug. 27, 2011, the day Fitzgerald’s comments were posted online, Hulsey said in an opinion column in The Capital Times of Madison:

"On the floor of the Legislature, Assembly Republicans have rubber-stamped Walker’s corporate agenda while rejecting hundreds of Democratic amendments, even though many were common-sense measures that emphasized accountability or saved money. So far, Republicans have accepted only one out of 376 amendments offered by Assembly Democrats."

Bi-partisanship, of course, can be measured in many ways. But the one-out-of-376 statistic caught our attention, so we decided to check it out.

We started by asking Hulsey to clarify his statement.

Hulsey said that of all the bills adopted by the Assembly in 2011 before it adjourned for the summer, only one of 376 amendments proposed by a Democrat was adopted. Some amendments were proposed on the Assembly floor and others in Assembly committees, he said.

The single Democrat-sponsored amendment that was approved, according to Hulsey, was to Assembly Bill 94. That bill made administrative changes to the Milwaukee school choice program, which uses taxpayer dollars to send children to private schools.

The amendment was introduced by Rep. Jason Fields, D-Milwaukee, a school choice supporter. It specifies that a pupil currently participating in the choice program may continue to attend a private school if their family’s income increases above current income eligibility requirements and that the pupil’s siblings are not subject to current income eligibility requirements, according to the Wisconsin Legislative Council, which provides legal and other services to legislative committees.

To check Hulsey’s numbers, we contacted the Assembly chief clerk’s office, which referred us to the Wisconsin Legislative Technology Services Bureau. Hulsey contacted the bureau, as well. The bureau determined there were even more Democratic amendments than Hulsey had claimed -- 399 -- and that only the Fields amendment was adopted.

We asked Walker spokesman Cullen Werwie and Fitzgerald spokesman John Jagler about the numbers. Neither disputed them.

Jagler said many of the Democratic amendments were voted down because they were politically motivated. He also said that for the 2009-2011 state budget -- adopted when Democrats controlled the governor’s office and both chambers of the Legislature -- Republicans offered more than 120 amendments and none were adopted.

That suggests Hulsey’s statement is just a measure of the reality of what happens when one party has outright control in Madison.

Is the number of opposition amendments adopted a good measure of bi-partisanship?

We put that question to two former state lawmakers, one from each party, who served in both the Assembly and the Senate.

Mordecai Lee, a Democrat who represented Milwaukee and now teaches governmental affairs at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, said the sheer volume of Democratic amendments rejected by the Republican-controlled Assembly is evidence "that these people despise each other."

Brian Rude, a lobbyist and a Republican who represented the La Crosse area, agreed that the number of rejected amendments indicates a split, but added: "Partisanship has always been part of the process. Parties get elected to stand for something."

For his part, Werwie cited a spreadsheet produced by the governor’s office on the 44 bills Walker has signed into law. It shows there were a total of 331 yes votes by Assembly Democrats on the bills.

That means, on average, 7.5 of the 38 Democrats voted yes on each of the 44 bills.

Our conclusion

Hulsey said the Republican-controlled state Assembly adopted only one of nearly 400 amendments offered by Democrats to bills that were adopted by the Assembly. Complete official data is not available, but GOP leaders don’t dispute that only one Democratic amendment was approved. We rate Hulsey’s statement True.

Featured Fact-check

Our Sources

Interview and email interview, Rep. Brett Hulsey, Aug. 30 and Sept. 7, 2011

Email interview, Rep. Brett Hulsey spokesman Ben Tobias, Sept. 1 and 2, 2011

Rep. Brett Hulsey, spreadsheet of 2011 Assembly bills

Email interview, Assembly Speaker Jeff Fitzgerald spokesman John Jagler, Aug. 31, 2011

Email interview, Gov. Scott Walker spokesman Cullen Werwie, Sept. 6, 2011

Gov. Scott Walker, spreadsheet on 44 bills signed into law in 2011

Interview, lobbyist and former Republican state representative and senator Brian Rude, Sept. 7, 2011

Wisconsin Legislature, Legislative documents search page

WISN-TV, Jeff Fitzgerald interview, posted Aug. 27, 2011

The Capital Times, "Rep. Brett Hulsey: My, Gov. Walker, what big teeth you have," Aug. 27, 2011

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Loved by Republicans, loathed by Democrats, Scott Walker remains in a political class by himself," June 5, 2011

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Walker says he’ll focus on bipartisanship, jobs," Aug. 10, 2011, "Horicon mayor will seek Jeff Fitzgerald’s seat," Sept. 6, 2011, Rep. Brett Hulsey tweet, Sept. 2, 2011

Wisconsin Legislature,  Assembly Bill 94

Wisconsin Legislature, Amendment 3 to Assembly Bill 94

Wisconsin Legislature, 2011-2012 session calendar

Wisconsin Legislative Council, memo on Assembly Bill 94 and two amendments, May 13, 2011

Interview, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee professor of governmental affairs and former Democratic state representative and senator Mordecai Lee, Sept. 6, 2011

Wisconsin Legislative Technology Services Bureau, Assembly votes on Democratic floor amendments spreadsheet

Email interview, Wisconsin Legislative Reference Bureau analyst Kinnic Eagan, Sept. 7, 2011

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Tom Kertscher

Wisconsin Rep. Brett Hulsey says only one of 376 bill amendments proposed by a Democrat was adopted by GOP-controlled Assembly

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up