Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
On the CNBC morning show Squawk Box, Republican presidential hopeful Rick Perry made a claim on Texas job growth that sounded a lot like something we’ve checked before, with a twist.
Noting that Perry has said on the campaign trail that government doesn't create jobs, interviewer Andrew Ross Sorkin told the Texas governor that over Perry's 10-plus years as governor, his state's total number of government jobs had increased 19 percent, while the private sector saw only a 9 percent bump.
"How do you square that circle?" Sorkin asked.
Perry responded: "Well, our teachers in Texas are public employees, so we've had a huge influx of people into the state of Texas, so you have to have more teachers obviously to do that as well. But the private sector job creation over the last … 10 years has been 1 million jobs created, while this country lost 2.5 million. So we square that rather well with the rest of the country."
Perry made a similar claim about Texas job gains during the Sept 7, 2011, Republican presidential debate at the Reagan presidential library in California, although he didn't say he was talking specifically about the private sector. "When you look at what we have done over the last decade, we created 1 million jobs in the state of Texas," Perry said. "At the same time, America lost 2.5 million."
For instance, more than 20 states enjoyed net job gains over the same period, so the governor of any one of them could make a similar boast, leaving the misimpression that only his or her state gained jobs while the rest of the country lost jobs. For example, using the Perry campaign's methodology, Alaska created 43,700 jobs during Perry's time in the governor's office while the rest of America lost 1.4 million.
Also, the Texas economy was rocking before Perry became governor. And, generally, many are skeptical about how much influence governors have over their state's economy.
For this article, we wondered whether the roughly 1 million net increase in jobs in Texas during Perry's tenure all occurred in the private sector, as Perry told Sorkin.
Precisely, the number of jobs in Texas increased by nearly 1.1 million between December 2000 and July 2011. In the period, government sector employment grew by 286,000, according to federal Bureau of Labor Statistics data and agency economist Cheryl Abbot. The BLS data on government workers contains federal, state and local employees, including postal workers but excluding military personnel.
The Texas breakdown:
Federal government: Increase of 19,900 jobs
State government: Increase of 51,000
Local government: Increase of 215,100
Private industry was responsible for the rest of the state's net increase in jobs, or about 790,000 positions, 73 percent of the total.
According to the BLS data, the private sectors that experienced job increases during the 128-month period were education and health services (404,900 increase), categories that do not sweep in jobs in public schools or hospitals; leisure and hospitality (215,200); professional and business services (196,800); trade, transportation and utilities (107,300); mining and logging (99,200); financial activities (57,500); construction (17,600); and other (18,400).
Two sectors saw job decreases: manufacturing (233,400 drop) and information (91,100).
Perry cited a figure for private-sector jobs that he's previously used to describe total employment gains. That could lead close followers of his campaign with the misimpression that nearly all the job gains were in the private sector. To the contrary, government jobs represented about 27 percent of the total.
But even though Perry was off by 200,000, he was in the neighborhood on his million-jobs statement. We rate his statement Half True.
CNBC, Gov. Rick Perry interview on Squawk Box, Sept. 29, 2011
PolitiFact Texas, "Rick Perry says that with what 'we have done,' Texas created 1 million jobs while rest of nation lost 2.5 million," Sept. 11, 2011
PolitiFact National, "Ron Paul says under Rick Perry, government jobs grew by 170,000 in Texas," Sept. 14, 2011
Rick Perry’s presidential campaign, website, "Job Creation Record," accessed Sept. 29, 2011
Email interview with Cheryl Abbot, economist, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Sept. 29, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.