Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Since becoming a member of Congress last year, Rep. Jim Renacci has held numerous "town hall" style public meetings, even though he recognizes that hostile political entities are videotaping all his remarks in hopes that he’ll make a gaffe they can exploit.
A redistricting plan that eliminated two of Ohio’s congressional seats put Renacci, a Republican from Wadsworth, into the same congressional district as Rep. Betty Sutton, a Democratic from Copley Township, prompting a November face-off. The upcoming contest has made both Renacci and Sutton top political targets.
In a news release announcing Renacci will hold a town hall meeting for Rocky River on June 14, Renacci’s re-election campaign chided Sutton for not holding such meetings herself, and claimed it was part of a "disappearing act."
"In a stunning and stark contrast, there is no record of Congresswoman Betty Sutton, who has been in office for the better part of a decade, ever holding a single in-person town hall meeting open to the general public - and she certainly has never done so while running to represent the 16th District," the news release said.
Has Sutton really never held open meetings with constituents? PolitiFact Ohio decided to check out the claim, particularly since it has seen news releases about town hall meetings that Sutton had scheduled during her three terms in office. For example, a 2007 release that’s still available online announced events in Akron and Elyria.
"Sutton will open the event with brief remarks, introduce her district staff, and spend the majority of the event responding to questions," the news release said. " Those interested in attending and/or submitting a question for the Q & A period should RSVP to the email address below or contact either of Sutton's district offices in Lorain or Summit County."
The Plain Dealer also published at least one article that mentioned Sutton conducting a town hall meeting. That meeting occurred in July 2009. At that time of the August 2009 article - when opponents of proposed health care reform legislation were disrupting congressional meetings around the country - Sutton told The Plain Dealer that many of her constituents said they didn’t want to attend such a meeting because "they would fear for their safety."
Afterwards, she announced that she’d hold a constituent meeting on the subject by teleconference, and invited callers to dial-in.
In light of that evidence, PolitiFact Ohio asked Renacci’s campaign for the basis of its claim that there’s no record of Sutton ever holding a single in-person town hall meeting open to the general public.
Spokesman James Slepian responded that the campaign is certain that Sutton has not conducted such a town hall meeting since she announced her run against Renacci last year. He said Sutton had announced she’d hold a semi-public June 3 event in Renacci’s hometown - Wadsworth - but canceled it.
An email to The Plain Dealer about the Wadsworth event indicated it was not a town hall meeting, but a fundraiser that a local Democratic party group had scheduled at a restaurant near Renacci’s campaign headquarters. The fundraiser was cancelled because of a scheduling conflict.
Slepian said the campaign was "unable to find a clear record of her holding such an event at any other time during her career in Congress. And by clear record, I mean some record detailing when and where the town hall occurred, was it open to the public, did Sutton field questions from the audience (all the same information that is readily available about the town halls that Mr. Renacci holds regularly)." Slepian accused Sutton of repeatedly announcing town hall meetings and then cancelling them, citing as evidence August 2009 posts from conservative and Tea Party websites that expressed disappointment that Sutton opted to hold a teleconference phone call with constituents about the health care bill instead of in-person meetings.
Slepian said the news release that announced the Sutton’s 2007 event did not constitute "proof" that it occurred, and he could find "no record" that the July 2009 town hall meeting referenced in the August 2009 The Plain Dealer article had actually happened.
"In addition to the clear differences in their respective voting records, another glaring difference between Jim Renacci and Betty Sutton is that while Jim Renacci believes he owes it to the voters to answer them regularly and in person as their voice in Washington, Betty Sutton feels no such obligation to the people of Northeast Ohio," Slepian said in an email.
Sutton spokesman Anthony DeAngelo said Sutton has recently conducted seniors listening tour events, which are open to the public, and where constituents can ask Sutton questions and offer comments.
"That’s what a ‘town hall’ is," DeAngelo said.
An article on the North Royalton Post website chronicled much of what Sutton said at an April 2 "listening tour" event that Sutton held at the North Royalton branch of the Cuyahoga County Public Library. The article, accompanied by photos from the event, said it was attended by "less than a handful of seniors."
To Renacci’s credit, he has held regular town hall meetings with constituents even as hostile videographers have doggedly recorded them. And his staff could have argued that they think he meets with constituents more often or that Sutton does not hold town hall meetings often enough.
But his claim that "there is no record" of Sutton "ever holding a single in-person town hall meeting open to the general public" does not stand up to scrutiny.
News releases that have announced such events and newspaper articles about those events provide sufficient evidence that they occurred.
On the Truth-O-Meter, Renacci’s claim rates False.
American Bridge 21st Century, Renacci: Ryan Plan "not a voucher system," Nov. 3, 2011
Jim Renacci for Congress, news release, Renacci announces details for next town hall meeting, Sutton still M.I.A., May 31, 2012
Press release, "Rep Sutton to hold town hall meetings next week; Congresswoman will highlight Congress’ first 100 hours;" Feb. 13, 2007
The Plain Dealer, "Ohio’s congressional delegation fans out across the state to discuss health care overhaul," August 12, 2009
The Plain Dealer, "Rep. Betty Sutton to hold Wednesday health care conference call for constituents," August 25, 2009
Lorain County 912 Tea Party, Posting on Betty Sutton, Aug. 13, 2009
Brainshavings, Betty Sutton lies, chickens out w/ "tele-town hall," Aug. 21, 2009
Email from Medina County Democratic Party, Betty Sutton June 3 event, May 29, 2012
Medinacountyevents.com, Betty Sutton event canceled,
Emails with Anthony DeAngelo, Sutton campaign spokesman, June 1-4, 2012
Emails with James Slepian, Renacci campaign spokesman, June 1-4, 2012
Office of Rep. Betty Sutton, news release, Sutton to launch ‘seniors listening tour" in Norton, North Royalton, March 27, 2012
North Royalton Post, via Royaltonpost.com, "Rep. Sutton is advocating for Medicare," April 12, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.