Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
The past week’s political sandbox match between Gov. Chris Christie and Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul kicked up a lot of dust.
But after a week of increasingly insulting barbs between the two possible Republican presidential contenders for 2016, fueled by a disagreement about national security matters, there’s one claim that caught the Truth-O-Meter’s attention – and it’s not whether Christie is the "King of Bacon" when it comes to government spending, as Paul claimed July 30 during an interview on CNN.
"In fact New Jersey is a donor state, we get 61 cents back on every dollar we send to Washington," Christie said July 30 in response to Rand’s claim that New Jersey has a ‘gimme, gimme, gimme’ attitude about federal spending. "And interestingly Kentucky gets $1.51 on every dollar they send to Washington."
Kentucky receives more than double what New Jersey gets in federal funding? For this claim, Christie’s got the numbers on his side.
We reviewed data from the business-backed Tax Foundation, which tracked from 1981 through 2005 how much each state gets back in expenditures for every dollar sent in taxes to the federal government.
Tax Foundation spokesman Richard Morrison said the group is working to update the data.
The Washington, D.C.-based foundation calculated the federal tax burden -- a measurement meant to account for taxes that are assessed in one state, but impact taxpayers elsewhere -- to conduct its analysis.
Christie’s figures come from data for 2005, which shows that New Jersey received 61 cents and Kentucky received $1.51 for every dollar each state sent to Washington.
Paul didn’t challenge Christie’s numbers but noted that two military bases in Kentucky (Fort Campbell and Fort Knox) might be one reason why Kentucky gets the rate of federal funding it does.
Perhaps the senator didn’t know that New Jersey has five active military bases: the Joint Base McGuire-Dix-Lakehurst; the Army’s Picatinny Arsenal; the Coast Guard’s Loran Support Unit in Wildwood and the Training Center in Cape May; and Naval Weapons Station Earle.
Let’s look beyond Christie’s claim and review the Tax Foundation’s 25 years’ worth of data in more depth. For example, as New Jersey’s rate of return on dollars sent to Washington decreased from a high of about 72 cents in 1981, Kentucky’s increased, from $1.06 that year to $1.51 in 2005.
Further, in 17 of the 25 years analyzed, New Jersey came in last place, receiving 70 cents or less for every dollar it sent to the federal government. Kentucky, however, has climbed from about 23rd place among all states to 9th place.
But since Christie’s data is about eight years old, we also checked with other organizations that track these types of numbers.
The Northeast-Midwest Institute, a research organization based in Washington, D.C., that promotes 18 states in the region, released a May 2011 report on federal spending and taxation patterns that focused on New Jersey.
New Jersey ranked 48th nationwide, according to the report. Only Minnesota and Delaware received smaller returns on their federal tax dollars in 2009.
Colleen Cain, a senior policy analyst with the Northeast-Midwest Institute who prepared the 2011 report, said in the report that New Jersey’s low ranking is due to the state’s "relatively high income levels and greater-than-average business income tax contribution, coupled with a relatively low need for federal aid. It does, however, underscore the importance of states like New Jersey in supporting the fiscal health of the nation generally."
Cain did not respond to a request for additional comment.
Christie said, "In fact New Jersey is a donor state, we get 61 cents back on every dollar we send to Washington," in response to Rand’s claim that New Jersey has a ‘gimme’ attitude about federal spending. "And interestingly Kentucky gets $1.51 on every dollar they send to Washington."
Christie’s claim is right on the money: even though the most recent data available is eight years old, the Tax Foundation backs up the governor’s statement to the exact penny for both New Jersey and Kentucky.
So when it comes to a game of fiscal "gimme, gimme, gimme," it might behoove the senator to check his own state’s coffers first before attacking New Jersey.
Christie’s statement rates True.
To comment on this story, go to NJ.com.
NJ.com, Chris Chistie calls Rand Paul another ‘Washington politician’, July 30, 2013, accessed July 30 and 31, 2013
PolitiFact New Jersey, Chris Christie says New Jersey receives the smallest return of any state on the federal taxes it pays, Nov. 18, 2012, accessed July 31, 2013
NJ.com, Christie vs. Paul: Feud between popular Republicans heightens over spending, July 31, 2013, accessed July 31 and Aug. 1, 2013
E-mail interview with Richard Morrison, spokesman, Tax Foundation, July 30, 2013
MotherJones.com, Most Red States Take More Money From Washington Than They Put In, Feb. 16, 2012, accessed July 30, 2013
Northeast-Midwest Institute, Getting To The Bottom Of Federal Spending And Taxation Patterns In The Northeast-Midwest Region, May 2011, accessed July 31, 2013
Tax Foundation, Federal Taxes Paid vs. Federal Taxes Received by State, 1981-2005, Oct. 19, 2007, accessed July 31, 2013
NJ.com, Rand Paul says he and Christie should share a beer to ‘kiss and make up,’ July 31, 2013, accessed Aug. 1, 2013
Tax Foundation, Federal Taxes Paid vs. Spending Received by State, 2007, accessed Aug. 1, 2013
Tax Foundation, Estimating Federal Tax Burdens For Major City Areas, Counties, And U.S. Congressional Districts, March 2007, accessed Aug. 1, 2013
U.S. Census Bureau, Consolidated Federal Funds Reports for Fiscal Year 2010, September 2011, accessed Aug. 1, 2013
Tax Foundation, Who Pays Taxes And Who Receives Government Spending? An Analysis Of Federal, State And Local Tax And Spending Distributions, 1991-2004, March 2007, accessed Aug. 1, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.