Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
The only way to make New Jersey a more affordable place to live is to have government spend less money, according to Gov. Chris Christie.
The Republican governor offered that solution when a man called into a Jan. 22 radio program and expressed concerns about the cost of living in New Jersey. The caller wanted to know the plan for keeping people like him in the state.
Christie told the man that property taxes have increased minimally in the last two years, because government spending has been capped. On the state level, spending is now lower than it was under Democratic Gov. Jon Corzine in fiscal year 2008, according to Christie.
"Now we’re making a difference. Because you know why? We’re capping spending," Christie said on New Jersey 101.5’s "Ask the Governor" program. "We’re saying you’ve got to spend less, and on the state level, we spend less today than Jon Corzine spent in fiscal year 2008, five years later."
The governor, who is seeking re-election this year, repeated the state spending claim on Thursday during a campaign stop at Tops Diner in East Newark.
Christie is right that state spending in the current fiscal year is lower than the spending level in fiscal year 2008, but the governor’s claim ignores the fact that spending has still increased with each new state budget since he took office.
Let’s break down the numbers:
For fiscal year 2008, Corzine approved a spending plan of about $33.47 billion, according to state Department of the Treasury reports. Final state spending that year ended slightly higher, at $33.61 billion, according to department reports.
In June 2012, Christie signed a budget for fiscal year 2013 that appropriates about $31.65 billion in state spending.
So, the governor’s current budget marks a nearly $2 billion decrease in state spending as compared to fiscal year 2008.
But just because state spending is lower than it was five years ago, doesn’t mean it hasn’t increased on Christie’s watch.
In his first budget after taking office in January 2010, Christie approved a roughly $28.36 billion spending plan for fiscal year 2011. For the next budget year -- fiscal year 2012 -- the governor approved a roughly $29.69 billion budget.
That means, in terms of the annual appropriations acts signed by Christie, state spending has increased by about $3.29 billion, or 11.6 percent, between fiscal years 2011 and 2013.
In response to our findings about spending increases during Christie's tenure, Treasury spokesman Bill Quinn said the following in an e-mail:
"We think your original question has been conclusively answered in the Governor’s favor as unequivocally true. You are now posing an entirely different inquiry that is not based on what the Governor actually said on the air that led to your fact check."
The increased spending since fiscal year 2011 is due in part to the governor’s policies boosting the state’s economy, leading to higher tax revenues, according to Quinn. He pointed out how two of the major areas of higher spending have been in education and pension contributions.
Quinn added that "the tough decisions needed to put the state budget on sound, responsible fiscal footing in fiscal years 10 and 11 allowed us to grow and make key investments in FY 12 and 13."
In response to a caller during New Jersey 101.5’s "Ask the Governor" program, Christie claimed that "on the state level, we spend less today than Jon Corzine spent in fiscal year 2008, five years later."
The governor is correct in that the fiscal year 2013 budget is nearly $2 billion less than the level of state spending under Corzine in fiscal year 2008. But Christie’s claim ignores the fact that state spending has still increased during his tenure.
That means the governor’s statement "is accurate but needs clarification or additional information." That meets our definition of Mostly True.
To comment on this ruling, go to NJ.com.
New Jersey 101.5, Ask the Governor, Jan. 22, 2013
Phone and e-mail interviews with Bill Quinn, spokesman for the New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Jan. 28-30, 2013
New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Fiscal Year 2013 Budget Summary, Feb. 21, 2012
New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Appropriations Handbook: Fiscal Year 2012-2013, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Appropriations Handbook: Fiscal Year 2007-2008, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Appropriations Handbook: Fiscal Year 2010-11, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Appropriations Handbook: Fiscal Year 2011-12, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Department of the Treasury, Fiscal Year 2009-2010 Proposed Budget: Summaries of Revenues, Expenditures and Fund Balances, March 10, 2009
New Jersey Office of Legislative Services, Fiscal Year 2013 Appropriations Act Summary, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Office of Legislative Services, Fiscal Year 2012 Appropriations Act Summary, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Office of Legislative Services, Fiscal Year 2011 Appropriations Act Summary, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
New Jersey Office of Legislative Services, Fiscal Year 2008 Appropriations Act Summary, accessed Jan. 30, 2013
PolitiFact New Jersey, Vincent Prieto claims Chris Christie’s proposed budget is largest spending plan in state history, June 25, 2012
The Star-Ledger, Video: Gov. Chris Christie responds to Sen. Barbara Buono's criticism of his economic record, Jan. 31, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.