Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
President Barack Obama, declaring that "Americans across the country are already paying the price of inaction" on climate change, announced sweeping measures on June 25 to reduce greenhouse gas pollution.
He said he would use executive power to require reductions in the amount of carbon dioxide emitted by the nation’s power plants, as the centerpiece in a three-part plan that includes new federal funds to advance renewable energy technology, and spending to protect cities and states from the ravages of storms and droughts aggravated by a changing climate.
Republicans led by House Speaker John Boehner of Ohio were quick to condemn the measures, saying they constituted government overreach that would constrict energy production and strangle the nation’s economic recovery.
"The president’s policies are not helping the economy, they’re making it worse," Boehner said in a news conference.
He said the policies would have the effect of "increasing the cost of electricity – especially in a state like mine, in Ohio, where about 95 percent of our electricity comes from burning coal."
That figure caught PolitiFact Ohio's attention. We asked Boehner's staff for a source to back it up.
They did not have a source for the figure, but Boehner spokesman Brendan Buck said: "Regardless, it’s clear the overwhelming majority of electricity in Ohio comes from the coal that the president is attacking."
In support of that statement, he cited a Washington Post article that looked at the question of whether Obama was waging a "war on coal."
So how much of Ohio's electricity does come from coal?
The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) has a feature on its website that asks and answers the question.
"Coal, a nonrenewable fossil fuel, is used to generate 77.87 percent of the electricity in Ohio," the PUCO site says.
PUCO says about 11 percent of Ohio electricity is generated by nuclear power, about 9.1 percent is produced using natural gas and other gases, and petroleum is burned to create steam to turn the turbine blades that generate about 1.0 percent of Ohio electricity. (PUCO lists as its source the Edison Electric Institute, EEI, the association of U.S. shareholder-owned electric companies.)
The U.S. Energy Information Administration rounds the figure to 78 percent for electricity generated by coal.
That percentage is far higher than the 42 percent of electricity generated by coal nationally, according to the EIA.
Our colleagues at the Washington Post Fact Checker also examined Boehner's statement. In addition to citing the figures from PUCO, they noted that the latest figures show that Ohio cut its net generation of electricity from coal by about 10 percent from 2010 to 2011.
Fact Checker also took note of Ohio law, cited by the PUCO and Energy Information Administration, that is designed to reduce reliance on coal by requiring that at least 25 percent of all electricity sold in the state come from alternative energy sources by 2025. Half of that must come from renewable sources such as wind, solar, hydroelectric power, geothermal and biomass.
Boehner's overall point was correct. As his spokesman said, the vast majority of Ohio's electricity does come from coal, and the percentage is far higher than the national average.
But the state officially is looking to reduce, not maintain, its reliance on coal, and has made progress in the effort.
And while the percentage of electricity from coal is high, Boehner's figure of 95 percent exaggerates it by 17 percentage points. That's a significant difference.
On balance, we rate the statement Half True.
New York Times, "Obama Outlines Ambitious Plan to Cut Greenhouse Gases," June 25, 2013
House Speaker John Boehner, "President Obama’s Policies Undermining Job Growth, Making Economy Worse," June 26, 2013
Email with Boehner press office, June 28 and July 1, 2013
Washington Post, "Is Obama waging a ‘war on coal’?," June 25, 2013
Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, "Where does Ohio’s electricity come from?," accessed June 28, 2013
U.S. Energy Information Administration, Ohio energy profile, July 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.