Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
It’s no revelation that Republicans are scarce at the General Assembly, Rhode Island’s most powerful political body. And some say that lack of partisan diversity in the Democrat-dominated legislature is unhealthy for the body politic.
That was a point made by longtime Republican Bernard Jackvony, former state GOP chairman, lieutenant governor and unsuccessful candidate for governor, who was a panelist on the May 31 broadcast of Rhode Island Public Television’s "A Lively Experiment."
"I say to people in Providence who have been complaining for 50 or 60 years, ‘Why don’t you try something different, because your schools aren’t getting better, your neighborhoods aren’t necessarily getting better, job opportunities aren’t getting better. Why do you vote for the Democrat?’" Jackvony said. "There hasn’t been a Republican in the legislature or the City Council in Providence in over 30 years."
Is the GOP desert that vast in the capital city, we wanted to know.
We phoned Paul R. Campbell, Providence city archivist, whose desk is perched in the attic at City Hall, and dropped in on Claudia J. Haugen, chairwoman of the Providence Board of Canvassers and Registration, who is on the first floor.
Institutional memory told us that lawyer Malcolm Farmer III was the last Republican on the council, but we were unsure just when he left office. And we thought Jackvony might be in for a surprise regarding the legislature.
Haugen reported there are 100,253 active registered voters, of which 60,627, or 60 percent, are Democrats. The rest are: 34,402 unaffiliated, or 34.3 percent; 4,950 Republican, or 4.94 percent; and 274 Moderate Party, or .76 percent.
Until the 1980s the Republicans were influential on the affluent East Side, especially in Ward 2.
But the East Side, too, has turned deep blue.
We asked Campbell to identify the last Republican council member. He assigned archival assistant Caleb Horton to take what he said would be the quickest research route: poring over, ahem, old Providence Journal-Bulletin Almanacs, where the certified results of elections were published.
For the last Republican General Assembly member from Providence, we turned to state librarian Thomas R. Evans, who consulted lists published by the Joint Committee on Legislative Services.
Their answers: Farmer served from 1979 through 1990, when he opted not to seek reelection, representing Ward 2 as the last Republican on the council -- 22½ years ago. And Mary C. Ross represented the old House District 17, in the West End, for one term in 1993-94 -- 19½ years ago. Both were considerably more recent than Jackvony’s remark that it has been "over 30 years."
"As they say in the State House, close enough for government work," Jackvony quipped, when we called him with the results of our research. He attributed the Republican eclipse in Providence to demographic and social changes similar to those that have occurred in many urban areas.
Jackvony, in his statement on "A Lively Experiment," was making the point that it has been a long time since a Republican sat on the council or represented the city in the Assembly.
While he said over 30 years, it’s in fact 19½. His overall point may have been sound, but his numbers weren’t. The judges rule Mostly False.
Interview, Bernard Jackvony, former Rhode Island lieutenant governor, June 11, 2013
Interview, Thomas R. Evans, Rhode Island state librarian, June 11, 2013
Interview, Claudia J. Haugen, chairwoman, Providence Board of Canvassers and Registration, June 11, 2013
Interview, Paul R. Campbell, Providence city archivist, June 11, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.