Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Scott Henson of Austin, who writes the Grits for Breakfast blog on criminal justice policy and politics, told the Austin Post, an online community newspaper, that Texas and the nation have "criminalized far too much of public life."
"I think we have somewhere in the range of 2,500 or so felonies on the books in Texas," Henson said in an interview posted online Feb. 25, 2013. "There are 11 different felonies you can commit with an oyster."
That cracked our interest, partly because the conservative Texas Public Policy Foundation likewise said about a month earlier that Texas has 11 felonies (not a dozen, dang it) related to harvesting oysters. Felonies are considered the most serious criminal offenses.
By email, the center’s Marc Levin, director of its Center for Effective Justice, pointed out a January 2012 publication, the "Current Offense Severity Rankings List," written by the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles.
Henson told us by email that Levin was his source for the count when he initially wrote about the topic in 2007. He also said he would check his claim against the state’s "offense severity" list.
Among the state-listed 2,324 felonies, Levin said, some are rather similar or are enhancements of lesser offenses, though the agency "presumably uses a consistent methodology to delineate each separate offense." He said the tally of oyster-related felonies aired by the foundation "allows for some that the parole board counts as separate offenses which some might consider to be essentially the same offense."
We spotted 16 oyster-connected felonies on the list but pruned three that appeared to be duplicates.
Also, as Levin noted, two felonies appeared distinct from others only because they take into consideration repeat offenses. Theft of oysters from a private bed is a felony, as is theft of oysters from a private bed and having two or more previous convictions. Similarly, harvesting oysters in a restricted area is a felony, as is oystering in a restricted area with a previous conviction.
Adjusting for the seeming duplications and near-similar felonies knocked the oyster-tied felonies in state law to 11: theft of oysters placed on a private seabed; interfering with an oyster buoy or marker with two previous convictions; oystering in a restricted area as designated by the state; night dredging of oysters; night dredging in a restricted area with a previous conviction; night dredging in a polluted area; not having an oystering license; harvesting oysters for non-commercial purposes without a license; harvesting oysters without a commercial license; selling sport oysters; and violating oyster regulations.
By telephone and email, a Texas Parks and Wildlife Department official confirmed the felonies, though Brandi Reeder, the agency’s fisheries law administrator, stressed that a person could be charged with each felony only if they have been convicted of similar misdemeanor violations in the previous five years--sometimes just once, in other cases two or more times, according to the relevant statutes.
At our request, Reeder reviewed our identified 11 felonies, later saying by email that she would say there are seven distinct oyster-related offenses or crimes.
Broadly, Reeder said, the oyster felonies are in place for a reason, to deter nefarious, potentially risky activities. "An oyster can kill you," Reeder said, referring to the possible presence of viruses, bacteria and parasites in raw shellfish. "That’s why we take it seriously."
But Texans rarely face oyster felony charges, Reeder said, because nearly all offenders stop after being charged with a misdemeanor. Statewide in the fiscal year ending Aug. 31, 2012, according to the agency, no such felonies were charged.
By telephone, neither Henson nor Levin expressed surprise that no oyster felonies were charged in a recent year or that no one can be charged with such a felony without a prior misdemeanor conviction. With a laugh, Henson said: "I guess the laws worked. They stamped out oyster crime in Texas."
Henson and Levin each said, too, the oyster felonies demonstrate regulatory issues--such as having a license or fishing in restricted waters--being placed inappropriately into criminal statutes. Levin said there is an opportunity to shrink the number of state crimes starting from a Texas House proposal to create a commission that would recommend changes in advance of the 2015 legislative session.
Henson said there are 11 Texas felonies one can commit with an oyster.
He could have said 16, according to the state’s breakdown of felony offenses, though Parks & Wildlife suggests such oyster-related crimes break down to seven distinct offenses. Significantly, too, these felony charges are rare. No one can even face one without having previously been convicted of at least one related misdemeanor.
We rate this claim as Mostly True.
News article, "Grits for Breakfast Shines Spotlight on Texas Justice," The Austin Post, Feb. 25, 2013
Email, response to PolitiFact Texas including email from Marc Levin, from Brendan Steinhauser, director of communications, Right on Crime, Texas Public Policy Foundation, March 6, 2013
Email and telephone interview, Scott Henson, Austin, March 6 and 27, 2013
Publication, "Current Offense Severity Rankings List," Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles, January 2012 (accessed March 20, 2013
Telephone interview and email, Brandi Reeder, assistant commander, fisheries law administrator, Texas Parks & Wildlife Department, March 20, 2013
Email, response to open-records’ request regarding citations for and dispositions of oyster-related offenses in fiscal 2012, Laura Russell, attorney, Texas Parks & Wildlife Department, March 25, 2013
Telephone interview, Marc Levin, March 26, 2013
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.