Stand up for the facts!

Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.

More Info

I would like to contribute

C. Eugene Emery Jr.
By C. Eugene Emery Jr. February 9, 2014

Providence Mayoral candidate Daniel Harrop says the city needs $1.2 billion to finance its pensions but has only about $250 million

Providence Mayor Angel Taveras had to deal with near bankruptcy in the capital city after he took office in 2011. As the city struggled to fix its budget problems, he won union concessions to reduce pension costs.

But critics question how far the pension deal negotiated by Taveras, now a candidate for governor, went to fix the problem. The most recent figures released last month show the plan is only 31.4-percent  funded.

Republican mayoral candidate Daniel Harrop raised the issue during the Dec. 15, 2013, edition of WPRI's "Newsmakers" program.

Asked why he wants to run again, he said the city needs a mayor who will stay around to solve the city's long-term problems and not have aspirations for higher office, like Taveras and his predecessor, David Cicilline, now a member of Congress.

"We see a quarter billion dollars in a pension fund that needs to be funded at $1.2 billion," Harrop said.

That would mean that the city, at the time, had a pension system that was only 20 percent funded. (The U.S. Government Accountability Office says public pension plans should be at least 80 percent funded.)

First, we need to explain why we're ruling on a seemingly-straightforward statement two months after it was made.

We began work on this item in December but getting up-to-date numbers about the city's pension fund turned out to be maddeningly difficult. The city was often slow to respond and listed different amounts in different reports over different time frames.

We decided to wait for the completion of the latest estimate of the city's accrued liability, in part because the city has refused to release an earlier actuary report for the year ending June 30, 2012, citing a dispute over its accuracy.

Finally, a week ago, the city released the latest actuarial report, for the year ending June 30, 2013, allowing us to proceed.

So let’s go back to December, when Harrop made his statement.

At that point, we asked Harrop about his figures. He cited two blog postings on the Providence pension system from reporter Ted Nesi of

One, published Oct. 30,  reported that the fund had $283 million in assets on Oct. 22. The other, published Dec. 7, said the fund had a liability of  "almost $1.2 billion."

Featured Fact-check

Harrop also cited a 2011 city report saying the liability as of June 30, 2010, was $1.256 billion, with assets of $316 million.

We don't know the precise status of the pension system the day Harrop made his statement. But now that we have the up-to-date financial reports, we do have a snapshot of what the system's assets and liabilities were as of June 30, 2013.

According to that latest actuary report, released Jan. 31, 2014, on June 30 the city needed $1.2 billion to cover its current and future pension obligations. On that point, Harrop turns out to have been right on the money.

At the same time, according to both the actuary report and the city's latest annual financial report, released about a month after Harrop made his statement, the Providence pension fund had $336 million in investments and other assets, a lot more than what Harrop stated.

The amount in the city's investment account was $247 million. In addition, there was $3 million in cash and $59 million the city paid into the fund that year. Finally, the report counted as an asset $26 million owed to the fund from loans made to people in the retirement system at a rate of 9.25 percent, according to David Ortiz, spokesman for Mayor Taveras.

Add all those together and you get the $336 million.

In Harrop’s defense, at the time he made his statement, up-to-date data on the city’s pension obligations were not available. The city was withholding it as part of an ongoing dispute with its actuary, Buck Consultants, who the city accused of making "fundamental and inexcusable errors" in its 2012 pension calculations. This year Providence used a different firm, Segal Consulting.

Our ruling

In December, Daniel Harrop said, "We see a quarter billion dollars in a pension fund that needs to be funded at $1.2 billion."

Harrop was citing numbers from different sources and different years, and those numbers are moving targets. They all support his underlying point: Providence's pension program is woefully underfunded, even with recent concessions negotiated with the city's unions.

Based on the latest report of the city's actuary, which was not available at the time Harrop made his statement, the candidate was correct on his $1.2 billion figure.

At the same time, there was significantly more than a quarter billion dollars set aside in the city's coffers for pension costs. But the number he cited accurately reflected the approximate amount the city had in its investment portfolio.

On balance, we rate his statement Mostly True.

(If you have a claim you’d like PolitiFact Rhode Island to check, email us at [email protected]. And follow us on Twitter: @politifactri.)

Our Sources, "Newsmakers," Dec. 15, 2013, "Taveras moves $11M of city pension assets out of hedge funds," Oct. 30, 2013, and "The Saturday Morning Post: Quick hits on politics & more in RI," Dec. 7, 2013, all accessed Dec. 17, 2013

Interview and email, Daniel Harrop, candidate for Providence mayor, Dec. 17-19, 2013, "City of Providence, Report on the Municipal Finances Review Panel, February 2011," accessed Dec. 18, 2013, "Current Investment Position and Performance Estimate," undated, "City of Providence, Rhode Island, Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, Fiscal Year Ended June 20, 2012," Dec. 31, 2012, accessed Dec. 18, 2013; "Providence Finalizes Historic Pension Agreement," April 12, 2013; and "City of Providence, Rhode Island, Comprehensive Annual Financial Report, Fiscal Year Ended June 20, 2013," Dec. 31, 2013, accessed Jan. 21, 2014, "Critical Status Emergence Plan; The Employees' Retirement System of the City of Providence," November 2012, "10-22-13 City Of Providence Employees' Retirement System - Current Investment Position And Performance Estimate," Oct. 22, 2013, accessed Oct. 24, 2013 and "6-30-13 City of Providence Employees' Retirement System - Current Investment Position and Performance Estimate," Sept. 6, 2013, accessed Oct. 31, 2013

Interview and emails, Dan Sherman, Sherman Actuarial Services LLC, Wakefield, Mass., Dec. 26, 2013, and Feb. 4, 2014

Interview, Michael D'Amico, director of administration, Providence Mayor Angel Taveras, Jan. 7, 2014

Interviews and emails, David Ortiz, spokesman, Providence Mayor Angel Taveras, Dec. 18, 2013 - Feb. 7, 2014

Buck Consultants report, "Section VI - Accounting Information," Page 8, undated, accessed Jan. 7, 2014, "The Employee Retirement System of the City of Providence; Actuarial Valuation and Review as of July 1, 2013," Segal Consulting, received Jan. 31, 2014

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by C. Eugene Emery Jr.

Providence Mayoral candidate Daniel Harrop says the city needs $1.2 billion to finance its pensions but has only about $250 million

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up