Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
For more than a year, U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse has delivered weekly Senate speeches about the dangers of climate change. He frequently denounces climate-change deniers, and urges growth of green jobs and technologies to reduce America’s reliance on foreign fossil fuel.
In a May 27, 2014 commentary in The Providence Journal, Whitehouse argued for a nationwide price on carbon pollution. And he expressed hope for a prosperous, clean-energy future and faith that "there is more economic security in our own American know-how than in corrupt foreign fossil fuel countries."
To that end, Whitehouse noted that there "are already more American jobs in the solar industry than in coal mining."
This claim is reminiscent of his November 2012 statement that "we have more people working in clean and green energy than in oil and gas in this country." (PolitiFact Rhode Island ruled that claim as True.)
The solar industry has seen tremendous growth. But have solar industry jobs actually eclipsed the number of coal-mining jobs?
Whitehouse communications director Seth Larson cited two sources to back up the senator’s claim.
The first is a U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics report issued in May 2013 that counts an estimated 80,030 jobs for all occupations within the coal-mining industry -- a sector of the coal industry as a whole.
For solar jobs, Larson cited The Solar Foundation’s "National Solar Jobs Census 2013," which states that the solar industry "employs 142,698 Americans as of November 2013."
First, let’s look at coal-mining jobs.
We checked with the Bureau of Labor Statistics and found that Whitehouse had quoted the May 2013 number correctly. (The more recent April 2014 BLS month survey counted 78,500 coal-mining jobs. Neither of those include self-employed contractors.)
BLS press officer Gary Steinberg said its estimated numbers are drawn from "an annual survey of employers, by occupation," based on data sent by businesses. They reflect jobs, not people.
We also found three other sets of coal-mining numbers. Spoiler alert: they are not all apples-to-apples. They use different methodologies and different definitions. But they provide an overall picture.
A 2013 report from the U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration cited 123,227 jobs -- substantially more than the BLS, but still less than the number of solar jobs Whitehouse cited. MHSA surveys the mines themselves as opposed to the companies, and therefore includes contractors as well as regular workers.
SNL Energy, a leading energy data provider, analyzes MSHA data to capture "snapshot" industry trends. Its June 2014 report, "U.S. coal miner employment sustains free fall beyond 2nd year," cites an 8.3% drop in the one-year period ending March 31, to 79,658 employees. That excludes contractors and 33 not-yet-reported mines.
By contrast, the National Mining Association, a trade group, counted 195,494 coal-mining jobs in 2012. The breakdown: miners (including contractors): 137,650; support activities: 6,930; transportation: 50,914. That’s nearly 53,000 more than Whitehouse’s solar jobs number.
Spokeswoman Nancy Gravatt said the NMA maintains that the additional support services "should be included because all of these activities are integral to the daily work in the mines."
But the NMA’s definition of coal-mining jobs goes far beyond those used by the federal agencies, including such transportation workers as railroad engineers and seamen on coal freighters.
In other words, data from three sources supports Whitehouse’s claim.
The NMA count does not.
Now let’s check out the solar data.
Larson cited The Solar Foundation’s "National Solar Jobs Census 2013," which states that the solar industry "employs 142,698 Americans as of November 2013."
The Solar Foundation is an independent, national 501(c)(3) nonprofit, non-lobbying group, that strives "to increase the widespread adoption of solar energy through educational outreach, policy research, and market transformation." Their data is considered "the most authoritative" by the Congressional Research Service.
Its report defines "solar workers" as those who spend "at least 50 percent of their time supporting solar-related activities." According to its 2013 census, "approximately 91 percent of those who meet our definition of a solar worker spent 100 percent of their time working on solar."
Andrea Luecke, the foundation’s executive director, said the foundation surveys the "known universe" of self-identified solar companies, of which there are about 6,000 nationwide.
"We go out directly to those companies. This year, we made 74,000 phone calls and sent 11,000 emails," over the course of one month.
The foundation also surveys companies "that help supply the ‘known universe’ with raw materials," Luecke said. "It’s a census approach, so we’re doing a direct count and extrapolate to get national numbers, which is how the BLS does it."
Luecke said by the census report’s measure, "the solar industry is outpacing coal mining." But she noted, "You have to understand that coal-mining is one aspect of the coal industry - whereas we’re talking about the whole solar industry."
If you add in other coal industry categories, "it’s more than solar, for sure. But the coal-mining bucket is less, for sure."
Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse said that solar industry jobs have now outpaced coal-mining jobs.
The most recent data from three objective sources support his claim.
The one source that offered a contrary view, the National Mining Association, cited two-year-old numbers and counted categories such as off-site transportation workers on coal barges and ocean freighters.
Because Whitehouse’s statement was specifically about coal-mining jobs, we rule it True.
(Correction: The original version of this item misspelled the last name of Andrea Luecke, president of The Solar Foundation, and incorrectly reported the name of the Congressional Research Service.)
"Climate Change in a Tsunami of Denial," op-ed by U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, Providence Journal, May 27. Accessed June 3, 2014
Thesolarfoundation.org, "National Solar Jobs Census 2013," accessed June 3, 2014
Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2013, "National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates, NAICS 2121100 - Coal Mining, Accessed June 3, 2014
Congressional Research Service, "U.S. Solar Photovoltaic Manufacturing: Industry Trends, Global Competition, Federal Support," Page 14, footnote 60. June 13, 2012. Accessed June 3, 2014
SNL Energy, "U.S. Coal miner employment sustains free fall beyond 2nd year", June 9, 2014, accessed June 30, 2014
Interview and emails, Seth Larson, spokesman for U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, June 3-6, 2014
Interview and emails, Gary Steinberg, Bureau of Labor Statistics press officer, June 3-6, 2014
Interview and emails, Andrea Luecke, president of The Solar Foundation, June 4 and 5, 2014
Emails, Nancy Graffat, senior vice president for marketing, National Mining Association, June 3-9. Interviews with NMA chief economist Paul Georgia, and Leslie Coleman, senior director, statistics, June 6, 2014.
Emails, Courtney R. Nielsen, marketing associate, SNL Financial LC, June 27, 30, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.