DeKalb one of the nation's best sheriff's offices?

The DeKalb County battle to replace Sheriff Tom Brown is a rare local political fight this year. And it cries out for fact checks.

Brown stepped down in March to focus on his unsuccessful race to unseat U.S. Rep. Hank Johnson.

Former DeKalb County CEO Vernon Jones and Jeff Mann, Brown’s former chief deputy who became interim sheriff last spring, beat back six other candidates in May’s nonpartisan special election.

Whoever wins Tuesday will fill out Brown’s unexpired term.

Jones and Mann have appeared together recently only once, in a debate taped to air at 10:30 a.m. Sunday on Georgia Public Broadcasting.

Each candidate made claims about the other at the session.

But Mann focused more on his tenure with Brown and their work to professionalize the department. At the GPB debate, Mann implied that DeKalb has been recognized in recent years for having one of the best sheriff’s departments in the nation.

"We have received the National Sheriff’s Association Triple Crown distinction," Mann said. "We are in the top 1 percent of sheriff’s offices in this nation."

Those are bold claims anywhere.

But they especially set the AJC Truth-O-Meter in action given corruption investigations, indictments and convictions that ended the careers of three DeKalb sheriffs between 1972 and 2000.

All that happened before Sidney Dorsey, the defeated incumbent sheriff, ordered the assassination of winning candidate Derwin Brown just days before he was to take office in 2000.

The department has had no major scandals in recent years. Some observers of DeKalb’s history find that fact remarkable in itself.

The National Sheriffs’ Association confirms that DeKalb did receive its Triple Crown honor in 2008 under Brown. The award recognizes those departments that have earned simultaneous accreditation from three agencies:

Featured Fact-check

Facebook posts

stated on March 21, 2024 in a Facebook post

Georgia district attorney Fani Willis was disbarred.

• The Commission on the Accreditation of Law Enforcement Agencies, which sets standards on the law enforcement function of the department whose main roles are to protect the courthouse and run the jail.

• The American Correctional Association's Commission on Accreditation for Corrections, which lays out policies and rules governing hiring practices and staffing in the department.

• The National Commission on Correctional Healthcare, which focuses on the health care aspect of running the jail.

Each agency has its own standards and requires a sheriff’s office to submit files and submit to site visits to confirm compliance.

Meeting the standards generally requires thousands of dollars and a significant time investment. The ACA accreditation, for instance, takes at least 18 months to complete.

"To get all three is a significant accomplishment," said Fred Wilson, the NSA’s director of operations. "It shows a commitment to and an intent to achieve high standards."

The NSA counts about 39,000 sheriff’s offices nationwide and lists 51 agencies that have achieved the Triple Crown.

That would make DeKalb among the 1 percent to earn that honor. Wilson said DeKalb and other award winners would benefit from lower insurance costs connected to the distinction.

So a focus on professionalization can minimize liability for taxpayers. But does it mean those sheriff’s offices are the best?

Consider that also on the Triple Crown list is the Fulton County Sheriff’s Office, which earned the achievement in 2003 under then-Sheriff Jacqueline Barrett.

But faulty jail locks, understaffing and other problems have prolonged a nearly decade-old lawsuit over jail conditions in Fulton. The litigation has cost taxpayers more than $200 million, including bills for renovations and outsourcing inmates.

Being plagued with those kinds of problems can sometimes be a function of size, said Frank V. Rotondo, the executive director of the Georgia Association of Chiefs of Police, which does not handle sheriffs’ standards.

But for any department, earning accreditation is not a silver bullet, he added.

"It certainly doesn’t mean you’ll never have problems," Rotondo said. "It really says you’ve established you will meet a very high set of standards, to try to preclude problems."

That means the distinction works both ways. So Mann was accurate to claim DeKalb had achieved a rare accomplishment.

That honor can have financial benefits for taxpayers but not protect them entirely from big expenses associated with improving operations.

Mann’s statement certainly contains an element of truth but overstates the significance of the award. We rate Mann’s claim as Half True.