Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
U.S. Rep. Pete Gallego invoked pickup trucks to frame his case for making it easier for college students and young graduates to refinance student loans.
"The average student loan debt in Texas is over $22,000," the Texas Democrat wrote in a May 14, 2014, email blast. "That also happens to be the cost of an average size pickup truck!"
"But here’s what’s truly alarming: students are NOT allowed to refinance their loans at lower rates -- the same way car owners can," Gallego wrote.
Democratic-sponsored legislation would provide federal aid so students and graduates stuck with high interest rates could repay the loans at the lower rates Congress approved for new student loans in 2013, though a May 16, 2014 National Journal news story called the proposal a long shot in the Senate, where Republicans were described as likely to resist higher taxes on the wealthy to pay for the refinancing wrinkle.
Gallegos revved our curiosity thrice over.
Average student loan debt
By email, Gallego’s campaign manager, Anthony Gutierrez told us the congressman’s average student-loan debt figure came from a news story posted online May 8, 2014, on the GovBeat blog of The Washington Post. That story said more than a million Americans would graduate this year with substantial student loan debt, a conclusion it attributed to the National Conference of State Legislatures.
"The graduates will have an average of $26,500 in student loans," the Post story said, "joining the tens of millions of other adults who collectively hold more than $1 trillion in student loan debt. That burden is largest, on average, in many Northeastern and Mid-Atlantic states, a few Southeastern states and California."
An accompanying U.S. map shows more than 20 states including Texas where the average student loan debt is $22,000 to $25,000"
The Post credited these conclusions to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, using data from the third quarter of 2012. We ventured to a web page for the reserve bank where its entry on student loan debt led us to a research paper, published in 2012 and revised in April 2013, by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.
According to the revised paper, student loan debt increased dramatically over the last several years, from about $346 billion in the fourth quarter of 2004 to $996 billion in the fourth quarter of 2012, a surge of nearly 14 percent a year. By comparison, the report said, total credit card debt was $679 billion and auto debt was $783 billion.
Then again, the report states, increasing levels of debt were driven largely by growth in the number of borrowers, rather than growth in average debt levels of borrowers. The report said that in the fourth quarter of 2012--a few months after the period analyzed in the Post’s chart--the "median borrower holding student loan debt owed $13,924 in student loan debt. The average amount of student loan debt across all consumers with student loan debt was $24,699." That’s the latest available calculation, Bill Medley, spokesman for the Kansas City Fed, told us by email.
Pricing average pickup trucks
Next, did Gallego capture the price of an average-size pickup?
Gutierrez told us the campaign researched average used truck prices on the Cars Direct website. He pointed us to an April 5, 2012, article on the site showing suggested retail prices for five 2010 and 2007 models. "These prices are for a base model pickup truck with standard options and no additional accessories," the article said.
According to the story, the average manufacturer’s suggested retail price for a 2010 two-door Ford F-150 was $22,355 and the average for a 2010 Dodge Ram 1500 was $21,510--prices close to the $22,000-plus cited by Gallego. Then again, the Cars Direct article listed estimated prices for two 2010 models at less than $22,000. It also listed the price for another 2010 truck as nearly $6,000 higher.
But Gallego priced used pickups; we looked on Edmunds.com, which compiles car and truck prices, for manufacturer’s suggested retail prices for model-year 2013 and 2014 pickups. According to the site, the price for a basic Ford F-150 "regular cab" starts at $24,070 (2013 model) and $24,735 (2014). A Toyota Tacoma "regular cab" starts at $17,625 (2013) and $18,125 (2014), the site says.
Limits on refinancing student loans?
Finally, are students really not allowed to refinance college loans?
Gutierrez pointed out news articles including a Feb. 20, 2013, Time magazine piece stating that unlike other consumers who have taken advantage of reduced interest rates to refinance purchases, student borrowers have been restricted because Congress—not the free market—"sets the interest rate on the vast majority of student debt, and because these loans are not secured by collateral private lenders are loath to undercut the federal government’s terms."
The Time story noted that student loan debt was at $1 trillion—and of that, the federal government backed $864 billion. Also, most of the debt was being carried at an interest rate higher than 6 percent, a figure Time attributed to a Feb. 13, 2013, report from the left-leaning Center for American Progress. "That’s almost twice the rate of an average 30-year mortgage," Time said.
By telephone, Heather Jarvis, a North Carolina attorney specializing in student loan law, said that some graduates may be able to refinance student loans at lower rates through private lenders, though she said this would only happen in cases of substantial income. (Car owners, in contrast, have four-wheeled collateral.)
By email, Jarvis said "refinancing federal loans with a private loan is risky. The borrower gives up important protections that accompany federal loans (like flexible repayment and discharge provisions)."
Students repaying federally backed loans, Jarvis said, are effectively barred from refinancing opportunities because federal law makes no provision for the government to make such offers.
Also by phone, Brian Stewart of the Center for American Progress -- which has urged the Democratic-backed action -- said it’s possible but difficult to refinance student loans with private lenders while there's no way for students to get the federal government to refinance a government-backed loan. Stewart, a spokesman for Generation Progress, a center project focused on young adults, said the center has been researching student-loan issues for about two years.
Gallego said the "average student loan debt in Texas is over $22,000...the cost of an average size pickup truck." But unlike car owners, he said, "students are not allowed to refinance their loans at lower rates."
This claim reflects the latest estimate of average student-loan debt and a findable price for an average-size pickup. It’s also so that most college loans are federally backed and Uncle Sam doesn’t offer a way for students and graduates to refinance. On the other hand, students taking loans from banks or other private lenders aren’t prevented from refinancing; this claim lacks that clarification.
We rate this statement as Mostly True.
MOSTLY TRUE – The statement is accurate but needs clarification or additional information.
Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Emails, Anthony Gutierrez, campaign manager, Pete Gallego campaign, June 2, 2014
News story, "Map: Where the average student loan burden is largest," GovBeat blog, The Washington Post, May 8, 2014 (accessed June 2, 2014)
Blog entry, "Economic Snapshot: Student Loan Debt," Inside the Vault blog, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, spring 2013 (accessed June 2, 2014
Research working paper, "Student Loans: Overview and Issues (Update)," Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, August 2012, revised April 2013 (accessed June 2, 2014)
Email, Bill Medley, public information director, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, June 2, 2014
Telephone interview, Heather Jarvis, attorney specializing in student loan law, Wilmington, N.C., June 3, 2014
Telephone interview, Brian Stewart, communications director, Generation Progress, Center for American Progress, Washington, D.C., June 4, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.