Before introducing former President Bill Clinton at an Oct. 24, 2014 campaign event in Milwaukee, Democrat Mary Burke leveled a number of criticisms at her election rival, Gov. Scott Walker.
Including this one:
"He gave $6 million in tax breaks to a corporation and told them that they can keep that money even if they lay off half their workforce."
Typically, when the state offers financial assistance to a company, the company has to create jobs.
So what’s going on here?
Burke was alluding to a deal offered by the Wisconsin Economic Development Corp. to Ashley Furniture Industries.
WEDC is the state’s primary agency for helping businesses create jobs. Walker created it to replace the state Department of Commerce; he heads the WEDC board.
Ashley Furniture, based in Arcadia in western Wisconsin, is the country's largest furniture manufacturer and retailer.
The deal for the furniture company was reported in late-August 2014 by the Wisconsin State Journal.
According to the Madison newspaper, the WEDC board in January 2014 approved a $6 million enterprise zone tax credit that would help Ashley Furniture with a $35 million expansion of its headquarters.
More specifically, the $6 million would pay for the relocation of Meyers Valley Creek, which flooded downtown Arcadia and the Ashley plant in 2010, allowing for the company to launch a 480,000-square foot expansion to reconfigure and change the layout of production lines.
The company, which the State Journal said had 3,848 Wisconsin employees at the time, did not have to commit to create a certain number of jobs. In fact, the credits would remain in place even if the company laid off as much as half of its workforce within the next several years.
Quoting a memo to the WEDC board, the newspaper reported that Ashley Furniture had indicated "that if the project is not undertaken, it will either downsize or close the Arcadia manufacturing plant completely."
So, based on what the company was telling the WEDC, the agency was motivated to try to stop the loss of many jobs.
The tax credits deal had not been made public because WEDC had not finalized a contract with Ashley Furniture, although the company confirmed to the newspaper that it was seeking state subsidies that include terms allowing for job reductions.
The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel followed up on the story.
Ashley confirmed that the deal would allow the tax credits to stand even if Ashley cut up to half its Wisconsin employment. But the company said it was advertising 200 job openings and had no plans to cut jobs in western Wisconsin.
The company said the layoff provision was meant to cover a worst-case scenario -- protecting the company, for example, in case a disastrous fire or flood should force a shutdown and layoffs.
Moreover, the deal amounts to a pass-through, rather than cash in Ashley’s pocket, given that the company would be donating $6 million to the City of Arcadia for the flood-control project.
WEDC spokesman Mark Maley told us that the WEDC board has discussed giving the tax credits to Ashley for the flood-control project.
He would not release details of the board’s closed-door meeting at which the credits were approved, saying there still is not yet a signed contract between the agency and the furniture maker.
But he said: "WEDC is committed to doing whatever it can to work with the company and preserve those jobs."
Burke said Walker "gave $6 million in tax breaks to a corporation and told them that they can keep that money even if they lay off half their workforce."
Walker heads the board of the Wisconsin Economic Development Corp., and that board has approved $6 million in tax credits to aid an expansion of Ashley Furniture.
The tax credits would be used toward a flood-control project in the city where the furniture maker is headquartered, but the project clearly is part of the company’s plan to expand.
If Ashley did lay off half its workforce, the credits could still remain in place, but since they would be used for a flood-control project, it’s not as though the company could "keep the money."
For a statement that is partially accurate but leaves out important details, our rating is Half True.
To comment on this item, go to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s web page.
Wisconsin Eye, video of Mary Burke-Bill Clinton campaign event (Burke quote at 22:10) Oct. 24, 2014
Wisconsin State Journal, "WEDC board OK’d Ashley Furniture getting $6 million tax credit, cutting 1,900 jobs," Aug. 25, 2014
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "State reportedly OKs $6 million in tax credits to Ashley Furniture," Aug. 25, 2014
Email interview, Wisconsin Economic Development Corp. spokesman Mark Maley, Oct. 24, 2014
Email interview, Gov. Scott Walker press secretary Laurel Patrick, Oct. 27, 2014
Email interview, Mary Burke campaign spokeswoman Stephanie Wilson, Oct. 24, 2014
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.