Is it true that when juveniles get arrested for car theft in Milwaukee County, they just get sent home until their case comes up in court?
That’s a claim from Milwaukee Police Chief Edward Flynn, whose department is arresting an increasing number of juveniles for auto thefts.
Appearing at a public forum at the Marquette University Law School on Aug. 27, 2015, Flynn talked about auto theft in Milwaukee, where his department has jurisdiction. He also alluded to Milwaukee County, since juveniles arrested for crimes are prosecuted in the county Children’s Court.
"If they're a juvenile, they get sent immediately home," Flynn stated, "because under the point system in juvenile court, as to whether or not you're going to be held for any period of time, a stolen car counts as zero points."
As we’ll see, it’s possible for a juveniles suspected of car theft to be sent home after their arrest, but it’s not at all automatic.
Scope of the problem
Juveniles are a significant part of the problem in the city. According to statistics provided to us by Milwaukee police:
Juveniles made up 39 percent of the suspects arrested for auto theft and auto theft-related crimes in 2014.
The 363 juvenile arrests in those cases was twice as many as in 2013.
Through the first nine months of 2015, there were 301 juvenile arrests in auto theft and auto-theft related cases, a slightly higher per-month clip than in 2014
Flynn told us he didn’t have direct evidence to back his statement. In an email, his spokesman, Capt. Mark Stanmeyer, wrote:
"Chief Flynn's statement is based on information he has heard over the years from a variety of sources, both internal and external to the department, as he works to encourage the stakeholders in the juvenile prosecution, adjudication, and corrections ‘systems’ to take the issue of juvenile auto theft and general offender reform more seriously."
Per Milwaukee police policy, officers take all juveniles arrested for auto theft or operating a vehicle without the owner’s consent to the county Juvenile Justice Center, in the Milwaukee suburb of Wauwatosa. That’s because both offenses are felonies.
The first decision -- the one Flynn is referring to -- is where the juvenile should stay until making the first appearance in court.
In auto theft cases, the arrested juvenile is ordered to appear in Children’s Court on the next court day, said Tom Wanta, administrator of the Milwaukee County Delinquency & Court Services Division. That could be the day after the arrest, or it could be later, depending on weekends and holidays.
Staff evaluate the juvenile in order to choose from among three options on where the juvenile should be prior to the court appearance: released to go home; held in secure detention at the center; or sent to to an alternative setting, such as a temporary shelter,
To make that decision, staff use something called the Detention Risk Assessment Instrument.
The DRAI uses a point system, which is what Flynn referred to in making his claim.
Points are determined based on the arrest for the auto theft, but also on what are known as aggravating and mitigating factors, if there are any.
Aggravating factors -- which can lead to secure detention -- include whether the facts of the auto theft are more serious than a typical case; whether the juvenile has any prior or pending criminal cases; and whether the juvenile has a documented history of violence.
Mitigating factors -- which can reduce the point total and lead to release -- include whether the juvenile is stable in school, and whether a responsible adult is available to supervise the juvenile.
Staff has some discretion in assigning points. Here’s a summary of how the total points are scored:
Where juvenile suspect should be before appearing in court
0 to 9
10 to 16
Alternative location, such as a temporary shelter
17 and up
Secure detention at juvenile center
Auto theft is worth 10 points -- not zero, as Flynn claimed -- which initially puts a juvenile in the middle range of the scoring system.
But it’s possible staff could decide to release the juvenile, with an order to appear in Children’s Court on the next court day, if mitigating factors reduce the score to 9 or lower.
If there are aggravating factors that raise the score to 17 or higher, staff could decide to hold the juvenile in secure detention until the first court appearance.
At the court appearance, the staff makes a recommendation to the judge on where the juvenile should be while the case is prosecuted, assuming that the district attorney’s office decides to file charges. Then the judge decides.
Flynn said that in Milwaukee County, juveniles arrested for car theft "get sent immediately home, because under the point system in juvenile court" on holding suspects, "a stolen car gets zero points."
It’s possible for a juvenile arrested on an auto theft-related charge to be released home until appearing in court, usually the next day. It depends on the facts of the case and factors such as whether the juvenile can be supervised by a responsible adult.
But under the point system, auto theft is worth 10 points, not zero, which typically would result in the juvenile being held in secure detention or at an alternative facility until appearing in court, depending on factors such as the juvenile having a prior record.
For a statement that contains only an element of truth, we rate the claim Mostly False.
Marquette Law School, video of Milwaukee Police Chief Edward Flynn, remarks at Marquette Law School (quote at 27:45), Aug. 27, 2015
Email interview, Milwaukee police spokesman Capt. Mark Stanmeyer, Aug. 30, 2015
Interview, Milwaukee County Delinquency & Court Services Division administrator B. Thomas Wanta, Oct. 6, 2015
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Car thefts by teens illustrate shortfalls in criminal justice system," Feb. 28, 2015
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Change in focus leads to decrease in auto thefts," Sept. 11, 2015
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "After years of decline, auto thefts soar in Milwaukee," Aug. 8, 2014
Email exchange, Milwaukee police media producer Jeff Gallagher, Oct. 7, 2015
Email exchange, Milwaukee police Sgt. Timothy Gauerke, Oct. 14, 2015
Milwaukee County Delinquency & Court Services Division, Detention Risk Assessment Instrument
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.