Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Refugee center in Hoxter, Germany, that primarily serves refugees from Syria. (Mark Hoffman photo)
The 30-second spot shows a woman in her kitchen with two children. She starts by talking about Trump and terrorist attacks in Europe and California.
"Sure, I get some grief when I say I'm voting for Donald Trump. But you know what? I want to protect my family. Paris, San Bernardino and now Brussels? I want a president that will keep us safe.
"We need to control our borders and stop letting in dangerous people. Trump will do that. And Ted Cruz? He wanted to let in more Syrian refugees and give amnesty to illegal immigrants. That won't protect my family. Donald Trump will."
Cruz -- who handily won Wisconsin, but has almost no chance to win the Republican presidential nomination on the first ballot at the party’s convention -- has cast himself as tough on terrorism and border control.
We found that the ad’s clever use of the past tense -- in saying the Texas senator wanted to let in more Syrian refugees and give amnesty to illegal immigrants -- has some foundation.
But the foundation isn’t entirely solid. And when the woman in the ad returns to speaking in the present tense -- "That won’t protect my family" -- the ad leaves a misleading impression of Cruz’s current positions.
Setting the table
A few notes up front:
Great America PAC, founded in February 2016 and formerly known as TrumPAC, didn’t respond to our requests for information to support the ad’s claim.
A Cruz campaign spokesman told us that on immigration, the senator never backed amnesty and that on Syrian refugees, he never backed an increase in the numbers.
‘Wanted to let in more Syrian refugees’
As reported during the presidential campaign by the Huffington Post, Cruz in 2014 expressed support for allowing Syrian refugees into the United States. He said in a Fox News report on Syrian refugees (as shown in a video is on Cruz’s own Senate web page):
"We have welcomed refugees — the tired, huddled masses — for centuries. That’s been the history of the United States. We should continue to do so." He added: "We have to continue to be vigilant to make sure those coming are not affiliated with the terrorists, but we can do that."
The Fact Checker found in reviewing other Cruz statements in 2014 that he was not a particularly vocal advocate for accepting more refugees, but he supported the idea.
Wanted to ‘give amnesty to illegal immigrants’
Some consider amnesty to be anything less than deporting all illegal immigrants, while others think of amnesty as letting immigrants stay with no punishment or additional requirements.
Both the Fact Checker and FactCheck.org found it impossible to sort out Cruz’s position on the 2013 comprehensive immigration reform bill from the so-called Gang of Eight.
FactCheck.org noted that one Cruz amendment to the bill would have stripped out a proposal for a path to citizenship for those currently in the country illegally -- but, purposefully, also left intact provisions to provide legal status for them.
And the Fact Checker pointed out that Cruz introduced five amendments to the bill, including one that expanded legal immigration, and gave passionate speeches in support of his amendments. Cruz now contends his amendments were meant as a "poison pill" to kill the bill, which ultimately fell apart.
But as the Fact Checker observed, "there’s no way to prove which version of the story is the truth; what we can say is that Cruz was being disingenuous then or disingenuous now."
As for now, Cruz is adamantly against amnesty.
Great America PAC says Cruz "wanted to let in more Syrian refugees and give amnesty to illegal immigrants."
Cruz in 2014 supported continuing to allow Syrian refugees into the United States and in 2013, he appeared to back measures to give legal status to illegal immigrants. At the same time, the political action committee’s ad suggests those positions are current ones, when they aren’t.
For a statement that is partially accurate but takes things out of context, our rating is Half True.
Political TV Ad Archive, Great America PAC "Concerened" ad first aired March 31, 2016
Interview, Ted Cruz campaign director of rapid response Brian Phillips, April 1, 2016
PolitiFact National, "Cruz repeats False attack about immigration bill letting Syrians in without background checks," Feb. 3, 2016
PolitiFact National, "Ted Cruz: most GOP candidates ‘have supported amnesty,’" Aug. 7, 2015
Washington Post Fact Checker, "Pro-Trump group misleads viewers about Ted Cruz’s stance on refugees and immigration," April 4, 2016
Dallas Morning News, "Pro-Trump PAC ad calls Cruz weak on ISIS and border security," April 4, 2016
Huffington Post, "Ted Cruz last year: We should welcome Syrian refugees, and we can do it safely," Nov. 19, 2015
FactCheck.org, "Did Cruz support legalization?," Dec. 16, 2015
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.