Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
It’s the Democrats’ favorite game this election season: Pin the Trump on the down-ballot Republican candidate.
One of the bigger targets is Colorado Rep. Mike Coffman, a four-term Republican incumbent in the 6th Congressional District, a crescent-shaped swath of Denver suburbs considered one of the country’s most competitive swing districts.
Coffman is in a fierce contest with Democratic state Sen. Morgan Carroll.
Since last year, Democratic groups and Carroll have been working hard to shackle Coffman to the now-presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump and his controversial comments about immigrants, minorities and women.
The latest broadside came from Colorado’s Voice -- the state chapter of America’s Voice, an immigration reform group. It issued an email news release headlined, "Mike Coffman Is With Trump."
So is he?
February statement, subsequent remarks
Colorado's Voice is using a statement Coffman’s spokeswoman gave to the Colorado Statesman as evidence he’s "with Trump."
But the statement, from Kristin Strohm, also clearly said Coffman supported Marco Rubio. Here it is.
"Will Mike Coffman support the Republican nominee over Bernie or Hillary?" Strohm said in a story published Feb. 2. "The answer is obviously yes. And he believes strongly it is going to be Marco Rubio."
At the time, Trump was one of 11 Republicans still in the race.
However, Coffman political director JD Key suggested to PolitiFact that Coffman might be having second thoughts about automatically supporting the GOP nominee.
"Rep. Coffman has not endorsed or voiced support for Donald Trump," Key said.
In fact, Coffman has issued blistering criticisms of his party’s de facto presidential nominee.
When Trump blasted the Colorado GOP’s caucus system as "rigged," Coffman, a Marine Corps combat veteran, fired back with this April 18 Facebook post: "If there is anyone who knows what a rigged system looks like it’s Donald Trump who was able to evade the draft during the height of the Vietnam War when the U.S. was losing, on average, 1,000 troops every month. That system was clearly rigged in favor of young men from politically influential families but Donald Trump never complained about that."
And on May 4, Coffman said in a statement that Trump has yet to earn Coffman’s support.
"Both Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump have tapped into a legitimate anger about the failures of Washington but instead of running a campaign built on a positive vision for overcoming these failures, Donald Trump has conducted a polarizing and divisive campaign," Coffman said. "Hillary Clinton is a non-starter and lacks the integrity to lead this nation but Trump has a long way to go to earn the support of many – me included."
Coffman isn't alone in walking back previous comments. House Speaker Paul Ryan had said he would back whoever won the Republican nomination, only to hold back on endorsing Trump. And former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush broke a pledge to support the GOP nominee no matter who it was.
A May 6 Politico story headlined, "Which Republicans have endorsed Donald Trump?" listed both Coffman and Ryan under "Not there yet."
Lining up on positions
So Coffman certainly is hedging on his campaign’s previous statement that he would support the GOP nominee, who is now almost certainly Trump.
But do the two candidates line up issue-wise?
The Colorado’s Voice news release pointed to Coffman’s position on immigration legislation. "Colorado already knows Coffman supports the Trump agenda on immigration. He voted … multiple times to deport DREAMers by ending the DACA program. He opposes DAPA, the policy that offers a modest but critical step forward for the parents of U.S. citizens."
DACA is the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which President Barack Obama created by executive order in 2012. It allows undocumented immigrants brought to the country unlawfully as children a two-year reprieve from deportation along with the opportunity to receive a renewable work permit and a driver's license.
DAPA is short for Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents. Obama used a 2014 executive order to create the program that would shield parents of children who are citizens or are living in the country legally from deportation and make them eligible to work in the United States.
The fate of DAPA and an expanded DACA is being deliberated on by the U.S. Supreme Court after Texas and 25 other states led by Republicans sued over the programs, saying the Obama administration had usurped power that belongs to Congress.
Here, too, Coffman’s position isn’t cut and dried.
Coffman voted against the DREAM Act in 2010, a bipartisan bill to allow children brought into the country unlawfully a path to citizenship if they attended college or served in the military. (DACA was in many ways Obama’s response.)
"The Dream Act will be a nightmare for the American people," Coffman said at the time. "No doubt, we need immigration reform but the Dream Act is written far too broadly and it will only encourage more illegal immigration, promote chain migration, and will be a magnet for fraud."
But Coffman's immigration positions softened in 2011, when his district was redrawn and its population became 20 percent Hispanic. He began taking Spanish lessons to better communicate with his constituents, and in January 2013, he introduced the Military Enlistment Opportunity Act, which sought to provide immigrant children an opportunity to serve in the U.S. military and gain a path to citizenship.
During the 2014 election, Coffman and his Democratic opponent, former state House speaker, Andrew Romanoff, debated in Spanish.
"There’s a narrative out there about Republicans being not just anti-illegal immigrant, but anti-immigrant," Coffman told the Wall Street Journal in January. "It was very important to me to break the narrative."
Colorado’s Voice director Alvina Vasquez said while Coffman "makes sweeping and broad statements about immigration reform, his actions show his true beliefs."
Critics cite Coffman’s June 2013 vote to defund DACA and his March 17 vote supporting the House filing an amicus brief with the Supreme Court "opposing the Obama administration's executive overreach" on immigration reform programs.
Yet, in 2014, Coffman broke with the GOP to vote against efforts to end the DACA program for young "Dreamers."
Colorado’s Voice says "Mike Coffman is with Trump."
That’s hardly clear.
In February, Coffman’s spokeswoman said he would "support the Republican nominee," while hoping that person would be Marco Rubio. Since then, Coffman has criticized Trump’s "divisive campaign" and said the billionaire has a long way to go to earn his support.
The group also says Coffman "supports the Trump agenda on immigration" as evidence. Yet the congressman’s views have moderated, and Coffman has at times broken with hardline GOP positions on immigration.
Claims that Coffman is in lockstep with Trump go too far. We rate it Mostly False.
Colorado Statesman, "No surprises: Colorado candidates in top races say they’ll support party’s presidential nominee," February 2, 2016
PolitiFact, "Trump calls Colorado caucus system 'rigged,' but there's no proof rules favor anyone," April 19, 2016
VoteSmart.org, "Coffman Statement on the DREAM Act," December 8, 2010
Politico, "Ryan will back Trump if he's the nominee, despite criticism," March 15, 2016
Politico, "Which Republicans have endorsed Donald Trump?" May 6, 2016
Associated Press, "Supreme Court hears case on Obama immigration reform," April 18, 2016
Associated Press, "Republicans scramble for the center on immigration," February 8, 2013
Wall Street Journal, "Lawmakers Learn Spanish in Effort to Woo Hispanic Voters," Jan. 13, 2016
House Speaker Ryan release, "House Takes Legal Action Against Executive Overreach,"
April 4, 2016
CQ.com, House vote on "Fiscal 2014 Homeland Security Appropriations," June 6, 2013
CQ.com, House vote on "Amicus Curiae United States. et al v. Texas, et al," March 17, 2016
Rollcall.com, "Republicans Vote to End DACA After Tense Floor Debate," August 1, 2014
Fox News Latino, "GOP congressman Mike Coffman keeps up Latino outreach -- long after re-election," April 06, 2015
Interview with Alvina Vasquez of Colorado’s Voice on May 13, 2016.
Interview with JD Key of Coffman for Congress on May 13, 2016
Interview with Jennifer Koch Donovan of Carroll for Colorado on May 16, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.