Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
The Wisconsin Freedom Alliance, a conservative political group, splashed into the news briefly in 2016 when it funded ads criticizing various Republican state Senate candidates during primary campaigns.
Now the group is back with a campaign charging that taxpayers are on the hook for bloated pensions, salaries and other benefits for state lawmakers of all political stripes.
In an April 2017 radio ad, the alliance ripped a practice that pays Wisconsin state lawmakers a per-diem amount when they travel to the Capitol for business.
"Did you know state politicians can collect their per diems even if they don’t spend a dime on meals, or lodging or travel? No receipts are required for them to get paid. No receipts! It’s the honor system for politicians paying themselves. Does that sound like a good idea?"
Is that the way the system works?
Legislators in most states qualify for per-diems. In many cases they receive more than Wisconsin lawmakers can get.
That hasn’t prevented the per-diems from coming under occasional attack in Wisconsin. They top out at $115 a day for state senators, and $78.50 a day (and $157 for an overnight) for Assembly members.
In 2016, overall payments to Assembly members ranged from a low of $916 to state Rep. Nancy VanderMeer (R-Tomah) to a high of $9,591 to state Rep. Peter Barca (D-Kenosha), the Assembly minority leader. In total, the 99 Assembly members received $484,504.
The 33 senators received $200,860 in 2016. The payments ranged from $2,024.00 to state Sen. Terry Moulton (R-Chippewa Falls) to $14,256 to state Sen. Scott Fitzgerald (R-Juneau), the majority leader.
Lawmakers living close to Madison qualify for lower per-diem rates.
Lawmakers base salary is $50,950.
The Wisconsin law governing the benefit says legislators "shall be entitled to an allowance for expenses incurred for food and lodging for each day that he or she is in Madison on legislative business." (italics ours).
So, if the allowance is tied to spending on food and lodging, is it possible, as the alliance contended, that it is paid "even if they don’t spend a dime on meals, or lodging or travel?"
Michael Flaherty, executive director of the Freedom Alliance, cited a Dec. 30, 2016 story by the USA Today Network-Wisconsin, headlined "Madison lawmakers max out hometown perk".
The story said "Lawmakers can collect the money as income without spending a dime on meals, lodging or gas. No receipts of expenses are required to get paid."
The no-receipts claim is on target, according to the clerks for the Senate and Assembly. Lawmakers are not asked to itemize.
As for whether a lawmaker who skips meals and drives home to sleep can still get a per diem, the answer is, yes, that’s possible.
But it’s impossible to say how often that happens, given the loose accounting system.
"It’s a benefit, an allowance," said Senate Chief Clerk Jeff Renk.
In Renk’s opinion, despite the statute’s talk of expenses incurred, lawmakers who incur no expense while collecting a per diem are not violating the law.
The perk is so automatic that lawmakers, at the beginning of a two-year legislative session, choose whether to receive the maximum daily reimbursement for days they travel to Madison within that period. That’s how the law was written.
All they have to do to collect is confirm their appearances by entering a mark in a computer program.
One piece of the group’s claim requires a minor clarification. Travel costs in the form of mileage are reimbursed separately from the per-diem payments.
The Wisconsin Freedom Alliance claimed that state lawmakers get daily expense payments "even if they don’t spend a dime on meals, or lodging or travel," and "no receipts are required for them to get paid."
Per diems are built on an honor system that requires no documentation that any travel or lodging expense has been incurred. Travel costs, though, have nothing to do with per diems, and some clarification is necessary here because no one can say how often lawmakers get the per diem without spending anything.
We rate the claim Mostly True.
Wisconsin Freedom Alliance radio ad, April 25, 2017
Interview with Michael Flaherty, executive director, Wisconsin Freedom Alliance, April 25, 2017
Interview with Patrick Fuller, Assembly Chief Clerk, April 25, 2017
Interview with Jeff Renk, Senate Chief Clerk, April 26, 2017
USA TODAY NETWORK - Wisconsin, "Madison lawmakers max out hometown perk," Dec. 30, 2016
USA TODAY NETWORK - Wisconsin, Senate hikes per diem pay by 31 percent, Feb. 22, 2017
Assembly State Legislature, Salary and Benefits, 2017-18 Session, as of Jan. 3, 2017
National Conference of State Legislatures, 2016 Legislator Compensation, December 8, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.