An image shared widely on Facebook and Reddit chides Fox News host Sean Hannity for having a double standard on presidents talking to North Korea.
It says that in 2008 Hannity said that President Barack Obama’s "willingness to meet with North Korea is one of the most disturbing displays of Obama’s lack of foreign policy experience." But in 2018, Hannity said President Donald Trump’s "willingness to meet with North Korea is a huge foreign policy win."
We hit the transcripts and video files. For the most part, those words accurately reflect what Hannity said.
A week before Election Day 2008, Hannity gave 10 reasons not to vote for Obama. No. 2 on his list concerned talking to unfriendly regimes.
"One of the most disturbing displays of Obama's lack of foreign policy expertise came during last year's YouTube debate," Hannity said Oct. 26, 2008. "The junior senator from Illinois gave what many called a naive answer for a question from the audience about whether he would meet with the leaders of Syria, Venezuela, Cuba or North Korea without preconditions."
Asked during that debate if he would be willing to meet with those leaders without preconditions, Obama said "I would," and compared that to previous presidents.
"Ronald Reagan and Democratic presidents like JFK constantly spoke to the Soviet Union at a time when Ronald Reagan called them an evil empire," Obama said. "And the reason is because they understood that we may not trust them and they may pose an extraordinary danger to this country, but we had the obligation to find areas where we can potentially move forward."
The image mentioned only North Korea, while Hannity listed several countries.
When news broke that Trump was open to meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, Hannity voiced support.
"A huge foreign policy win for President Trump," Hannity said March 8. "Little Rocket Man blinks. Now, the president’s tough rhetoric, his bold action, his severe sanctions, they appear to be working tonight. President Trump is accepting an invitation to meet with the North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un by May, and Pyongyang is agreeing to stop all nuclear and missile tests while these talks are underway. And the sanctions? They will continue."
So the text in the image matches what Hannity said.
But his criticism of Obama and his praise for Trump came in the context of different policies.
Obama’s policy on North Korea grew more complicated over time. But initially, it was fairly simple, said Penn State international affairs professor Joseph DeThomas.
Preconditions meant that in order for talks to happen, North Korea had to agree that the purpose was the complete denuclearization of North Korea.
"During the campaign and early in his term Obama was very open to talks without preconditions," DeThomas said.
For Trump, the picture is murkier.
When Trump tweeted that he would meet with Kim Jong Un, North Korea had not taken any steps toward denuclearization. He said they had "talked" about it.
"Kim Jong Un talked about denuclearization with the South Korean representatives, not just a freeze," Trump wrote. "Also, no missile testing by North Korea during this period of time."
But for North Korea, denuclearization applies to the entire peninsula, which has implications for the American presence and military posture in South Korea. That is not the same as simply agreeing to a North Korea without nukes.
DeThomas said testing halts are customary during talks with North Korea. Beyond that, North Korea made no concessions or took any steps toward ending its nuclear program.
Trump has imposed stricter sanctions and has been more ready to hint at using military force against North Korea. But in terms of having direct talks between the leaders of both nations, DeThomas said this administration set a lower bar than what previous presidents have demanded.
"The Trump precondition for talks was that North Korea had to halt nuclear and missile testing for some unspecified period of time prior to commencement of talks," DeThomas said. "
In February, Vice President Mike Pence drew headlines when he said sanctions and direct talks could happen at the same time.
To some observers, that meant the administration was willing to talk without the precondition of North Korea agreeing to a future free of nukes. DeThomas characterized such words as "loosey goosey," but not indicative of a major change.
In that regard, when Hannity praised Trump, the administration’s overall policy was tougher than what Obama had articulated when he ran for president. But the fact remains that Trump had agreed to a meeting before North Korea had taken any concrete steps toward ridding itself of nuclear weapons.
The side-by-side quotes cast Hannity as criticizing Obama for being willing to talk to North Korea while praising Trump for his willingness to do the same thing. The quotations are pretty much accurate.
But the image glosses over the different policy preferences of each man at the time Hannity spoke. In 2008, Obama said simply there were no preconditions for a meeting with the leader. In 2018, Trump’s administration voiced some relaxation on preconditions, but not a full rejection of them.
At the same time, Trump agreed to a meeting before North Korea had done more than agree to hold off on testing during any talks.
The image leaves out some context, but overall, we rate it Mostly True.
Bloggers, Facebook post, March 11, 2018
Fox News, Hannity's Top 10 Reasons to Not Vote for Barack Obama, Oct. 26, 2008
CNN, CNN/YouTube Democratic presidential debate transcript, July 24, 2007
Fox News, Hannity: Trump is causing little Rocket Man to back down, March 8, 2018
Donald Trump, tweet, March 8, 2018
New York Times, North Korea, Seeking ‘Equal Footing,’ Rejects Preconditions for U.S. Talks, March 3, 2018
Washington Post, Pence: The United States is ready to talk with North Korea, Feb. 11, 2018
New York Times, U.S. Opens Door to North Korea Talks, a Victory for South’s President, Feb. 13, 2018
White House, Press Briefing by Press Secretary Sarah Sanders, Feb. 26, 2018
Email interview, Joseph DeThomas, professor,Penn State’s School of International Affairs, March 14, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.