Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Incumbent Gov. Bruce Rauner struck a number of familiar notes in his speech Tuesday night as he claimed a narrow primary victory over insurgent Republican challenger Jeanne Ives, talking about tax cuts, job growth and term limits for elected leaders.
But the multi-millionaire Rauner also sought to frame his coming general election battle against Democratic nominee J.B. Pritzker as one pitting the interests of the little guy against entrenched political insiders allied with the billionaire Pritzker.
Then Rauner threw in a new wrinkle to his standard line of attack. "Newspapers have framed this election as my fight against the Illinois mafia," he told the applauding crowd. "But it’s really the people versus the Illinois mafia."
Rauner has long been free with tossing around incendiary terms to describe rivals, in particularly Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan, whom the governor frequently lambastes as "corrupt." But this latest turn of phrase, which Rauner attributed not to himself but "newspapers," got us to wondering. Which newspapers?
So we reached out to his campaign for an answer. A spokesman quickly responded by emailing a link to a single opinion column published a few weeks ago in the Wall Street Journal titled, "Bruce Rauner vs. the Illinois ‘Mafia.’"
In the piece, which represents the views of a single columnist and not the paper’s editorial board, Rauner pins Illinois’ problems squarely on Madigan. The Journal quotes Rauner referring to his archrival as "the mafia kingpin of Illinois" and then taking an additional swipe at Madigan for simultaneously serving as a powerful lawmaker and as a partner in a law firm specializing in property tax appeals.
"It’s a mafia protection racket," Rauner said of Madigan’s dual roles.
But the ‘mafia’ references in the headline and column come from Rauner’s own mouth, not from the impressions of the writer, who also goes on to note that: "Mr. Rauner sounds confident and plans to spend whatever it takes to make the election a referendum on reform versus the Madigan Mafia."
Rauner campaign aides did not respond to our follow-up email asking whether they believed other newspapers had framed the election in similar terms.
After barely squeaking out a victory over a primary challenger, Gov. Bruce Rauner declared to supporters that, "Newspapers have framed this election as my fight against the Illinois mafia."
Incendiary rhetoric has been a staple of Rauner speeches for years, but in upping the ante even more in his fight against Pritzker it appears the governor is also projecting his own words onto the thoughts of others. Newspapers, or more precisely one column in the Wall Street Journal, did not frame Rauner’s re-election fight in terms of a struggle with a mafia-like force.
That is Rauner’s own characterization and he is simply quoting himself while seeking to attribute the observation to others.
This dizzying feedback loop earns Rauner’s primary night claim a False.
Bruce Rauner Declares Victory In Illinois GOP Primary For Governor, CBS, March 20, 2018
Gov. Rauner, facing primary challenge, reacts to criticism by blaming Madigan, ABC 7, Dec. 4, 2017
Email interview, Justin Giorgio, Rauner campaign spokesman, March 21, 2018
Bruce Rauner vs. the Illinois ‘Mafia,’ Wall Street Journal, March 2, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.