Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
The relationship between Gov. Tony Evers and Republican legislative leaders has been icy at best since Evers took office in January 2019.
Both sides have claimed they want to work together, while accusing the other side of failing to do so. One such claim from Assembly Majority Leader Jim Steineke, R-Kaukauna, caught our eye.
"Just recently, we’ve made overtures to meet on a regular basis so we can continue to communicate, and (Evers has) refused to even meet with us," Steineke said March 31, 2019 on WISN-TV’s UpFront program. "So it’s extremely frustrating when he’s saying one thing about working in a bipartisan manner, but the actions just haven’t been there. … He’s not talking to us at all."
Adrienne Pederson, the host, followed up to ask if GOP leaders have reached out to Evers specifically and not heard back.
"Yes," Steineke said. "Over and over again we’ve offered to meet on a regular basis … and he’s not willing to talk to us."
Has Evers, a Democrat, really "refused" to meet with Republican leaders?
Let’s see what we know.
Steineke’s claim prompted a back-and-forth on Twitter between the respective leaders.
Evers tweeted the next day that he had met with more than 100 lawmakers from both parties. He included pictures of several of those meetings — including one with Steineke.
Steineke responded that his point was about meeting with GOP leadership over the budget, a "wholly different" level of communication from an initial get-to-know-you meeting.
Assembly Speaker Robin Vos added: "(Gov. Scott Walker) made a point of meeting with legislative leaders on a regular basis. We extended a similar offer to (Evers), but it seems he's only interested in talking every few months."
Clearly, Evers and GOP legislative leaders are figuring out the new "normal" of a divided state government after eight years of Republican control.
With Walker in office, Republican leaders had a standing Wednesday meeting with the governor, which hasn’t happened under Evers.
But communication in Madison isn’t limited to elected officials. A lot of work gets done in meetings between staffers, or legislators meeting with gubernatorial appointees. That was common under Walker as well.
At a March 5, 2019 news conference Evers had this to say about meetings with lawmakers:
"We’ll meet with (Republican leaders) as often as we need to. I’m not sure we need to schedule Tuesday morning at 10 o’clock every week, but the bottom line is we need to have good conversations and we need to involve staff members in those conversations, so we truly have a good dialogue going."
In a March 31, 2019 tweet that came after the Steineke interview aired, Patrick Marley of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel noted that the previous week Evers said he hadn’t been talking to legislative leaders directly, but his top aides were in contact with them.
Alesha Emmert, communications director for Steineke, said the lawmaker’s claim on UpFront was referring to substantive meetings with Republican leaders.
"Our office is aware Governor Evers has been introducing himself to legislators since he took office – we tweeted a photo from our own meeting," Emmert wrote. "But to be clear, these interactions have been very brief. In Rep. Steineke’s 15-minute meeting, some niceties were exchanged, and the only substantial conversation was a request made by my boss to have more regular, structured meetings."
As evidence, she noted Evers’ opposition to weekly meetings at the March 5 news conference, the Marley tweet and several letters to Evers in which Republican leaders referenced wanting to work together with the governor.
Emmert did not provide an example of any specific invitation that Evers declined.
Vos communications director Kit Beyer said the speaker has had one sit-down with Evers aside from the initial meet-and-greet. Like Emmert, she noted that Republican leaders have asked for a regular meeting, but Evers has not shown an interest in that.
Meanwhile, Evers’ staff says attempts on their end to set up meetings have found little traction.
Melissa Baldauff, Evers’ spokeswoman said an aide had reached out to staffers for Vos, R-Rochester, and Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald, R-Juneau, the week before Steineke’s comment. The aide was seeking a meeting with them and Evers but did not immediately get a response. She shared an April 1, 2019, email the aide sent that reiterates the request for the three leaders to meet.
Baldauff also provided emails that referenced Evers’ staffers attempting to set up a meeting between Fitzgerald, Senate Minority Leader Jennifer Shilling, D-La Crosse, and Evers’ chief of staff to talk about gubernatorial appointments.
Another email referenced attempts to arrange a meeting between policy directors for Evers and Vos, as an outgrowth of an earlier meeting between Evers and Vos.
We’ll note that all this back and forth — also detailed in a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel story on April 9, 2019 — did eventually lead to a meeting plan. Vos, Fitzgerald and Evers scheduled a sit-down for April 10, 2019.
Amid ongoing tension between Wisconsin’s Democratic governor and Republican Legislature, Steineke said GOP leaders have "made overtures to meet on a regular basis" but Evers has "refused to even meet with us."
Evers has, as Steineke notes, shown little interest in regular sit-downs like his Republican predecessor.
But Steineke is off base claiming there was a refusal to meet. His staff offered no evidence of a specific meeting being refused.
And in fact, the opposite appears true. Evers’ staff reached out to facilitate a meeting between Evers and Republican leaders in the days before Steineke’s TV appearance, and they received no immediate response.
That makes Steineke’s claim Half True.
WISN-TV, 'UPFRONT' recap: Republican lawmaker: 'State is absolutely in a constitutional crisis', March 31, 2019
Email exchange with Alesha Emmert, communications director for Rep. Jim Steineke, April 2-3, 2019
Email exchange with Melissa Baldauff, spokeswoman for Gov. Tony Evers, April 2-9, 2019
Email exchange with Kit Beyer, communications director for Sen. Robin Vos, April 8-9, 2019
Twitter.com, @SpeakerVos (State Sen. Robin Vos), April 1, 2019
Twitter.com, @jimsteineke (State Rep. Jim Steineke), April 1, 2019
Twitter.com, @patrickdmarley (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Reporter Patrick Marley), March 31, 2019
Emailed meeting invitation, from Evers staff to staffers for Vos and Fitzgerald, April 1, 2019
YouTube.com, WisconsinEye, News Conference: Gov. Evers "The People's Budget" Tour, March 5, 2019
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, In divided Wisconsin, the governor and legislative leaders are barely talking, April 9, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.