Amy Sherman
By Amy Sherman January 23, 2019

Sen. Rick Scott said he always supported Dreamers, but that's not correct

Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla., applauded President Donald Trump’s proposal to swap border wall funding for protection for Dreamers, immigrants who came to the United States illegally when they were children.

In an effort to end the government shutdown, Trump offered to continue to provide temporary protections for 700,000 Dreamers in exchange for $5.7 billion for a border wall. Scott called on Democratic leaders in Congress to accept his offer, but they rejected it.

"Children should never be punished for the actions of their parents," Scott tweeted Jan. 19, "and I’ve always supported protections for our DREAMers."

Scott did soften his stance on illegal immigration during his eight years as Florida governor. But his support for their cause was not "always" there.

We are not judging whether Scott's change of positions on immigration, including Dreamers, was sound policy, but whether his words abut his own record are accurate. It's worth noting that in Florida, there has been significant support among some high-profile Republican politicians — including members of Congress — for helping Dreamers. Scott's most recent position more closely aligns with that perspective.

Scott opposed Dreamer protections in early years

Early in his tenure, Scott took stances that were counter to helping undocumented immigrants, including Dreamers.

A few Twitter users replied to Scott’s tweet with a link to a a statement Scott made about Dreamers in 2010, a few weeks before the was sworn in..

Hours before the U.S. House of Representatives voted to pass the Dream Act, Scott said he opposed the legislation.

"I'm against the Dream Act," Scott said Dec. 8, 2010, while touring the Port of Miami. "Why? I don't believe in amnesty."

The bill would have given a conditional path to citizenship to hundreds of thousands undocumented immigrants. The bill passed the House but then narrowly died in the U.S. Senate. Miami's three Republican Cuban-American lawmakers, Reps. Lincoln and Mario Diaz-Balart and Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, joined Democrats in voting in favor of the bill.

At the time, Scott’s comment was consistent with the approach of his Republican primary campaign against illegal immigration. Scott promised to adopt a law similar to Arizona’s controversial SB1070, which required immigrants to show their citizenship papers if stopped by law enforcement, among other stances.

Once he was elected governor, Scott stopped talking about that promise.

In June 2012, Obama announced Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, an extension of executive power to defer deportation for Dreamers who met certain criteria on a renewable two-year basis.

Featured Fact-check

In 2013, Scott vetoed a bill to let Dreamers get driver’s licenses. Among other reasons, Scott criticized DACA as a policy "absent congressional direction" in his veto message.

The same month that Scott vetoed the bill, the U.S. Senate was moving toward voting on a bill to change immigration laws, including a path to citizenship. The bill was written by a bipartisan group of senators, including Marco Rubio, a Florida Republican. While some leading Florida Republicans publicly endorsed the bill, Scott’s response was more tepid. When asked by the Tampa Bay Times on June 13, 2013 whether he supported the bill, Scott wouldn’t commit either way but praised the border security portion of the bill.

"I think Senator Rubio has really done a great job, focusing on the discussion, making sure we have an immigration policy that works. I'm happy that he's really focused on securing our borders and having a policy that we all understand," Scott said.

When asked about it again in July 2013 — a couple weeks after it passed the Senate — he called the bill the "right thing" and mentioned border security repeatedly, but nothing on the path to citizenship.

When Scott shifted his position

As he sought re-election in 2014, Scott took a more positive approach: He signed a bill that easily passed the Legislature to give Dreamers in-state tuition.

"Students who have spent their childhood here in Florida deserve to qualify for the same in-state tuition," he said.

That was a Full Flop from 2011 when he said, "With regard to in-state tuition for illegal immigrants I completely oppose it."

In September 2017, the Trump administration announced it would phase out DACA. (The renewals stand for now, after the U.S. Supreme Court took no action.)

In response to the planned phase-out, Scott called on Congress to act and help the Dreamers.

"I do not favor punishing children for the actions of their parents," Scott said in a statement Sept. 1, 2017. "These kids must be allowed to pursue the American Dream, and Congress must act on this immediately."

Scott was most direct in his support of Dreamers during his successful 2018 bid for the U.S. Senate.

In a USA Today op-ed, Scott said Congress should "secure the immigration status of Dreamers" and "do the right thing for these kids by removing the uncertainty hanging over their future goals and dreams."

As then-U.S. Rep. Carlos Curbelo, R-Fla., was trying to force votes on immigration in June 2018, Scott again called on Congress to "get DACA legislation done."

We asked Scott’s press office if he had evidence that he "always" supported protections for Dreamers. Sarah Schwirian pointed to Scott’s USA Today op-ed and signing the bill for in-state tuition. "Sen. Rick Scott has been an outspoken opponent of illegal immigration but has been clear that he supports a legal pathway for kids who were brought here through no fault of their own," she said.

Our ruling

Scott said, "I’ve always supported protections for our DREAMers."

In 2010, Scott said, "I'm against the Dream Act," and called the legislation "amnesty." In 2013, he criticized Obama’s deferred action program for Dreamers, saying that Obama bypassed Congress. He also vetoed a bill to give Dreamers driver’s licenses.

Scott has softened his position in recent years, and politicians are allowed to change. But his rewrite of his Dreamers record doesn't match what really happened. We rate his statement False.

Our Sources

U.S. Sen. Rick Scott, Tweet, Jan. 19, 2019

Interview, Sarah Schwirian, U.S. Sen. Rick Scott spokeswoman, Jan. 22, 2019

WLRN, "Gov. Scott Signs Bill Allowing DREAMers To Qualify For In-State Tuition," June 9, 2014

New York Times, "Trump Offers Temporary Protections for ‘Dreamers’ in Exchange for Wall Funding," Jan. 19, 2019

Tampa Bay Times The Buzz, "House passes 'Dream Act' with help from a few Florida Republicans," Dec. 8, 2010

Miami Herald, Gov. Scott on DACA: 'These kids must be allowed to pursue the American Dream', Sept. 1, 2017

Sun Sentinel, "Top Florida lawmaker is pushing for an Arizona-style crackdown on illegal immigration," May 28, 2010

TIME, "Florida Governor: Alex Sink vs. Rick Scott," Oct. 28, 2010

NAACP, Press release, June 16, 2010

Rick Scott, Campaign press release, May 11, 2010

The Hill, "Poll: Nearly 9 in 10 want DACA recipients to stay in US," Jan. 8, 2018

NPR, "NPR Poll: 2 In 3 Support Legal Status For DREAMers; Majority Oppose Building A Wall," Feb. 6, 2018

Miami Herald, "Rick Scott: take up DACA later if that's what it takes to get the government running," Jan. 22, 2018

Gov. Rick Scott op-ed in USA Today, "On DREAMers and border security, Congress should just do it: Gov. Rick Scott," Jan. 16, 2018

Orlando Sentinel, "Democrats blast Gov. Scott on his shifting immigration stance," Jan. 20, 2018

New York Times, "Florida Advances Tuition Aid for Children Brought to U.S. Illegally," May 2, 2014

Miami Herald, "Florida Gov. Rick Scott signs bill to give in-state tuition to undocumented students," June 9, 2017

Washington Post, "Republicans press Trump to save DACA," Sept. 2, 2017

Miami Herald, "Rick Scott: take up DACA later if that's what it takes to get the government running, Jan. 22, 2018

Miami Herald, "Rick Scott appears to support Curbelo's immigration plan, but how would he vote?" June 8, 2018

Tampa Bay Times The Buzz, "Wavering Gov. Scott won’t take a stand on federal immigration bill," June 13, 2013

Tampa Bay Times The Buzz, "Scott likes Rubio's push on immigration reform, or at least, that part on border security," July 9, 2013

PolitiFact’s Scott-O-Meter, "Bring Arizona's immigration law to Florida," June 25, 2012

PolitiFact’s Scott-O-Meter, "Will fight immigration amnesty," July 2, 2014

PolitiFact, "Rick Scott opposed in-state tuition for DREAMers before he embraced it," May 2, 2014

PolitiFact, "Rick Scott says bill he vetoed to give driver licenses to DACA immigrants changed 'nothing," Oct. 20, 2014

PolitiFact’s Trump-O-Meter, Terminate Barack Obama's immigration executive orders 'immediately,'" Aug. 6, 2018

PolitiFact, "Democrats' attack on Gov. Rick Scott's immigration stance out of date," Nov. 2, 2018

 

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Amy Sherman

Sen. Rick Scott said he always supported Dreamers, but that's not correct

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up