Jon Greenberg
By Jon Greenberg October 25, 2019

Bernie Sanders overstates recession aid to Wall Street banks

Sen. Bernie Sanders marked his return to the campaign trail after a heart attack with a huge outdoor rally in New York City. Sanders stayed focused on his core message that corporate power drives government policy at the expense of hundreds of millions of Americans. 

On student debt, Sanders said he would cancel every bit of it with money from a new tax on financial transactions.

"If Congress eleven years ago, against my vote, could bail out the crooks on Wall Street and provide them with trillions of dollars of zero interest loans," Sanders said Oct. 19. "You know what? We can cancel all student debt in America with a modest tax on Wall Street speculation."

In this fact-check, we look at whether the federal government provided trillions of dollars of zero interest rate loans.

Sanders is not fully accurate. Most of the loans –– and there were different types –– came at rates that were quite low, but above zero. 

The total reaches $2 trillion, but not all of it went to the big players on Wall Street.

The bailout money

In 2008, a financial house of cards built on junk home mortgages collapsed. With warnings that $5 trillion in U.S. assets could be wiped out virtually overnight, Washington moved to stem the crisis.

The Federal Reserve was the biggest player, especially in terms of loans to the Wall Street banks. Congressional action was hefty, in the hundreds of billions, but much smaller compared to the Fed. 

The Sanders campaign highlighted the work of the Fed, citing news reports of trillions of dollars in aid.

"One program alone doled out nearly $9 trillion," said the Christian Science Monitor

But many of the loans involved banks rolling over short-term loans from one period to the next. Economics professor Todd Keister at Rutgers University said this produced a lot of double counting. He used the example of a home mortgage to explain what was going on.

"Suppose I borrow $100,000 to buy a house and then later refinance," Keister said. "The refinancing involves paying off the original loan and taking a new loan for $100,000. If we add up the loans I took, we would say that I borrowed a total of $200,000. But there is a clear sense in which the amount I borrowed to buy the house was always $100,000."

The actual amount was about $1.4 trillion.

That’s not trillions, as Sanders said, but it’s getting close.

Federal Reserve data shows that interest rates were very low, but not at zero.

"Those interest rates were subsidized," said University of Louisiana finance professor Linus Wilson. "Nevertheless, the interest rates were not zero."

Sanders took liberties in suggesting all the benefits went to Wall Street, though it’s fair to say the big banks did well. In some cases, outside the Fed, they got billions of dollars outright and through a number of federal actions, the biggest banks grew bigger.

But many regional and community banks also benefited. About two-thirds of the loans in the largest program — the Term Auction Facility — came through Federal Reserve banks outside of New York.

Another $1.1 trillion in play

Among its other programs, the Fed was also buying bundles of home mortgages that the biggest banks had on their books. By June 2010, the Fed’s Agency Mortgage-Backed Securities program peaked at $1.1 trillion. 

This was not a loan, but it helped the banks by moving the risks tied to those mortgage from the banks to the Fed.

Not every expert would count it as aid to the banks, but if you do, it would bring the total aid to $2.5 trillion. 

The TARP factor

Outside of the Fed, Congress authorized direct government bailouts, in the form of the Troubled Assets Relief Program and the government takeover of the government-chartered home mortgage finance giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

According to a running tally by the nonprofit investigative journalism group ProPublica, the federal outlays were $633 billion. While Wall Street banks including Citigroup, Bank of America and Goldman Sachs pocketed $135 billion, the money went to many places other than Wall Street banks, such as General Motors.

Adding all of it though to the Fed’s activities gives us two totals: either about $2 trillion if we don’t count the mortgage security purchases, or about $3.1 trillion if we do.

Sanders said Congress gave Wall Street free money. The focus on Congress is a bit off, because while Wall Street did get billions, to get to trillions, the Fed dollars are essential. And the Fed operated on its own.

"Congress delegates responsibility to the Fed," said Rutgers economist Eugene White.

Our ruling

Sanders said that during the Great Recession, Congress gave Wall Street "trillions of dollars of zero interest loans."

By our calculations, the total across several actions ranged from $2 trillion to about $3.1 trillion.

But Sanders is less accurate regarding where the money went and the interest rate. The biggest Wall Street players benefited greatly, but banks and other business across the country also got help. And while very low, the interest rates remained above zero. Also, the Fed is not Congress.

Sanders oversimplified a complex response to an economic crisis. We rate this claim Half True.

Clarification, Oct. 31: We updated this piece to clarify the impact of the Fed purchases of mortgage-backed securities.

Our Sources

Bernie Sanders, Rally in New York City, Oct. 19, 2019

Federal Reserve System: Opportunities Exist to Strengthen Policies and Processes for Managing Emergency Assistance, Government Accountability Office, July 2011. 

Levy Economics Institute, $29,000,000,000,000: A Detailed Look at the Fed’s Bailout by Funding Facility and Recipient, December 2011

Federal Reserve System, Usage Of Federal Reserve Credit And Liquidity Facilities, Dec. 9, 2013

Federal Reserve system, What were the Federal Reserve's large-scale asset purchases?, Dec. 22, 2015

National Bureau of Economic Research, Unprecedented actions: The Federal Reserve’s response to the global financial crisis  in historical perspective, December 2014

Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, The Great Recession in retrospect, Dec. 18, 2017

Brookings Institution, The Fed’s balance sheet, Aug. 18, 2017

Journal of Monetary Economics, Managing markets for toxic assets, Oct. 14, 2014

Bloomberg, Secret Fed Loans Gave Banks $13 Billion Undisclosed to Congress, Nov. 27, 2011

CNN, Fed made $9 trillion in emergency overnight loans, Dec. 1, 2010

Rolling Stone, Secrets and Lies of the Bailout, Jan. 4, 2013

Congressional Budget Office, Report on the Troubled Asset Relief Program, April 25, 2019

University of Pennsylvania Journal of Business Law, Legal authority in unusual and exigent circumstances: The Federal Reserve and the financial crisis, March 2, 2011

Propublica, Bailout Recipients, Oct. 2, 2019

Rolling Stone, Secrets and Lies of the Bailout, Jan. 4, 2013

Congressional Budget Office, Report on the Troubled Asset Relief Program, April 25, 2019

Science Daily, Effectiveness of Federal Reserve emergency lending 2007-09, March 16, 2017

Washington Post, Did Wall Street get a ‘trillion-dollar bailout’ during the financial crisis?, March 18, 2019

Email exchange, Todd Keister, professor of economics,  Rutgers University, Oct. 24, 2019

Email exchange, Howell Jackson, professor of law, Harvard Law School, Oct. 24, 2019

Email exchange, Sherrill Shaffer, professor of banking and financial services, University of Wyoming, Oct. 23, 2019

Email exchange, Linus Wilson, assistant professor of finance, University of Louisiana, Oct. 22, 2019.

Email exchange, Mehrsa Baradaran, professor of law, University of California - Irvine, Oct. 22, 2019

Email exchange, Eugene N. White, professor of economics, Rutgers University, Oct. 24, 2019

Email exchange, Warren Gunnels, senior advisor, Bernie Sanders for President, Oct. 21, 2019

 

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Jon Greenberg

Bernie Sanders overstates recession aid to Wall Street banks

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up