Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
Fabricated or misreported quotes by Democratic politicians continue to circulate on social media.
The post includes the following purported remarks by politicians:
By Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee: "Homicide is the leading cause of murder."
By former Vice President Joe Biden: "No ordinary American cares about Constitutional rights."
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass.: "Having an abortion is no different than having one’s tonsils removed."
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y.: "Owning guns is not a right. If it were a right, it would be in the Constitution."
Let’s scrutinize these quotes one by one.
The quote attributed to Jackson Lee appears to come from a now-defunct blog called the Habanero of Texas. That post, or excerpts of it, was widely shared by other conservatives and pro-gun advocates on social media and in forums.
According to one blog that quoted the original Habanero of Texas post, Jackson Lee "held an informal press conference today announcing that her administration, through great efforts and much expense, had completed a decade-old study that focused on the cause of murders in the United States. She was reported as saying that the results were predominantly leaning towards ‘homicide’ as being the primary cause for the murders."
The original post appears to have been an attempt at satire, since the direct "quote" attributed by the blog to Jackson Lee is nearly unintelligible:
"Datas (sic) uncover (sic) today give us a clearer portrait of a couple of possible cause (sic) for murder, but let’s be clear.. Changes in the atmospheres (sic) and combustibles (sic) also play a roles (sic) in how peoples (sic) are behave (sic). By continuing homicide (sic) and climate changes (sic) we are ascend (sic) ourselves to vulnables (sic), and we cannot deny that, Nor shall we, Nor shall I, Nor shall we all, So say we all (sic). End homicide and end climate change, and we end murder. THIS, we know."
The apparent satire may have been inspired by remarks posted by the Blaze, a conservative website, that Jackson made in 2013. She said in part, "Homicide is the leading cause of death — second-leading cause of death — for young people ages 15 to 24. In my community, African Americans, it is the leading cause of death for those 10 to 24."
This quote spiraled out of a comment Biden made during a weapons control forum in 2013, but it has been altered and taken out of context.
A YouTube video posted in 2015 and titled "Biden: no ordinary American cares about his constitutional rights" has more than 33,000 views. The YouTube video tracks back to a February 2013 address Biden gave during a forum held at Western Connecticut State University, about two months after the Sandy Hook elementary school shooting.
At no point during the video does Biden say the words cited in the social media posts. In the clip, he talks about the "roadblocks" that are put up by those who oppose gun control:
"They say all you’re going to do is deny law-abiding citizens their rights under the Second Amendment. Not true. They say guns like the AR-15 are needed for self-protection and recreation. They are not. There are plenty of ways you can protect yourself and recreate without an AR-15. They say it isn’t about guns. They’re wrong; it is about guns. Let me say at the outset to all the press: No law abiding citizen in the United States of America has any fear that their Constitutional rights will be infringed in any way. None, zero. Look, common sense facts are these assault weapons are unnecessary and dangerous weapons that put our law enforcement personnel at risk…"
Warren did make a comparison between abortion and tonsil removal procedures, but the quote shared in the post is heavily edited and is not something Warren said or wrote. We have rated it Mostly False.
In a Jan. 21, 2018, opinion column in Time magazine, she wrote: "On the 45th anniversary of Roe vs. Wade, I think about what has changed since abortions became legal. Our health care system has pretty much dealt with the safety issue: thanks to Roe vs. Wade, abortion is now safer than getting your tonsils out. A lot of women are alive today because of Roe."
In the piece, Warren links to a Time magazine article, which reported in 2014 that women who get abortions are less likely to have complications than people who have their wisdom teeth removed, citing a study published in the peer-reviewed Obstetrics & Gynecology medical journal.
We didn’t find any credible sources corroborating her purported comment. We rated the claim that she said it Pants on Fire.
Ocasio-Cortez’s campaign website said of gun control policy, "Cities and states with strong gun laws have managed to cut gun violence significantly without running afoul of the Second Amendment. Alexandria believes that supporting common-sense gun legislation is necessary for any politician who claims to care about the lives of constituents."
Her campaign platform also said she thinks that "it’s clear that the founding fathers did not have assault weapons in mind when they wrote" the Second Amendment, and that she advocates for banning such guns.
Among other gun control measures, she thinks domestic abusers and stalkers should have to surrender their firearms, and she wants to require universal and improved background checks before someone can buy a gun.
"Keep the severely mentally ill and people with a history of domestic abuse from purchasing guns," Ocasio-Cortez said about a year ago while answering questions on Reddit. "I am a believer in the Second Amendment but this is where I draw the line."
All told, each of the four quotes is either made up or seriously mangled. We rate the statement False.
Facebook post received by PolitiFact on Dec. 27, 2019
Sheila Jackson Lee, video remarks, May 4, 2013
PolitiFact, "Joe Biden did not say quote about Americans not caring about constitutional rights," May 10, 2019
PolitiFact, "The Elizabeth Warren quote likening abortion to tonsil removal? It’s edited and taken out of context," Aug. 7, 2019
PolitiFact, "No, Rep. Ocasio-Cortez did not say that owning guns is not a right," Jan. 24, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.