Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
A photograph of National Guard soldiers sleeping outside is miscaptioned. It was taken in Minneapolis, not D.C., and shows soldiers taking a rest during a longer shift.
D.C. mayor Muriel Bowser didn’t make soldiers sleep in the streets, but out-of-state troops were relocated after a hotel billing dispute.
Were National Guard members forced to sleep on the streets of Washington, D.C., after the mayor kicked them out of their hotels, as some social media posts claim?
No. But a Facebook post takes a picture of National Guard members lying on the ground out of context and suggests it is evidence that D.C.’s mayor did just that.
The post’s full caption reads: "These are our soldiers that (sic) DC mayor kicked out of local hotels. We all should be raging mad at this sight."
This miscaptioned post stems from two real events — a photo taken in Minneapolis and an unrelated flap involving the D.C. mayor and the National Guard — but in both cases, the real story is less dramatic than this social media post suggests.
The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
First, the photo was taken in Minneapolis, not D.C.
When a reverse-image search surfaced hundreds of posts that shared the same image, some claiming it was taken in D.C., while others saying it was from Minnesota, we reached out to the Minnesota National Guard.
A spokesperson there confirmed that the photo shows some of its members taking a rest during a longer shift in Minneapolis. It was taken in front of a bank on May 30 and had nothing to do with the troops’ lodging arrangements.
"While other members of the unit provided security, these soldiers grabbed a quick nap in front U.S. Bank E 2800 Lake St. in Minneapolis," Maj. Scott Hawkins, spokesperson for the Minnesota National Guard, wrote in an email. "As more soldiers came on state activate duty orders, replacements became available to relieve them and regular 12 hour shifts were instituted. The Minnesota National Guard had plentiful sleeping arrangements within our staging areas with cots and food supplies. We were not dependent on hotel lodging."
Here’s what happened in D.C., meanwhile.
Thousands of National Guard troops from multiple states were sent to D.C. in response to the protests.
On June 5, Sen. Mike Lee, R-Ut., tweeted that Muriel Bowser, the Democratic mayor of D.C., evicted Utah National Guard members from hotels.
"These brave men and women have risked their lives protecting DC for three days," Lee wrote in a subsequent tweet. "Rioting, looting, arson, and vandalism have all disappeared bc (sic) these soldiers served. And now they are being kicked to the curb by an ungrateful mayor. This must be stopped."
Bowser responded on Twitter, acknowledging that Utah National Guard troops were in D.C. hotels but that "D.C. residents cannot pay" the troops’ hotel bills.
Reporters at WUSA9 looked into the Twitter spat and reported that Bowser was referring to a contract the District had with the Marriott Marquis hotel. The District had agreed to cover the accommodation costs of D.C. National Guard members who were activated for COVID-19 response.
At a June 5 news conference, Bowser said the District did not intend, nor would be able to, evict any guardsman from any hotel. She wanted it to be clear that billing arrangements for any out-of-state troops would have to be covered by the military or by their home states.
"We have an agreement with one of our hotels for our COVID response, for which the District has paid and the District has a contractual arrangement," Bowser said. "So our message to the hotel was that if they are going to use the rooms that we reserved, then they have to pay for them and you have to refund us our money. That, we understood, would just be a matter of the Guard or the Army making those arrangements. So those out of state troops would be covered either by the Army or their home states, not by D.C. residents."
We reached out to Bowser’s office for comment but did not hear back by time of publication.
The Utah National Guard released a statement on June 5 about the situation and said they were informed their 200 service members would be relocated from their hotel rooms and that the D.C. National Guard was working to resolve the matter. Hours later, an updated statement said that a different hotel had been identified, and that the soldiers would be relocated.
A photo of National Guard soldiers sleeping outside is being shared online. The caption says it was taken in Washington, D.C., after the mayor "kicked them out of local hotels."
The photo is from Minneapolis, not D.C. The Minnesota National Guard said the soldiers were on a longer shift and grabbed a quick nap but did have formal sleeping arrangements elsewhere.
D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser did request that the Army cover the costs of accommodations for out-of-state troops who were in the District in response to recent protests. She said certain rooms that the District paid for were reserved for COVID-19 responders.
There is some truth to the hotel dispute in D.C. concerning out of state National Guard members, but the photo is miscaptioned and there is no evidence that the mayor forced soldiers to sleep on the street. We rate this Mostly False.
Facebook post, June 6, 2020
Military Times, 5,000 National Guard troops in 15 states and DC activated to help quell growing civil unrest, May 31, 2020
Twitter, Mayor Muriel Bowser tweet, June 5, 2020
Military Times, This is why guardsmen on protest duty were kicked out of a DC hotel, June 5, 2020
Muriel Bowser press conference, June 5, 2020
ABC News, New hotel found for Utah National Guard troops in DC after billing dispute, June 5, 2020
Email interview, Maj. Scott Hawks spokesperson at the Minnesota National Guard, June 10, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.