In Context: Ilhan Omar’s “our country should be more fearful of white men” comment
A clip of Ilhan Omar saying Americans "should be more fearful of white men" took off on Twitter, but it includes some selective editing that doesn’t fully reflect her statements.
On July 25, Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., shared a 41-second excerpt from Omar’s interview on Al Jazeera from February 2018, when she was a Minnesota state legislator, months before the Minnesota Democrat won a seat in Congress. The interviewer asks Omar what she would say to conservatives who say the rise of Islamophobia is due to "jihadist terrorism" attacks such as in San Bernardino and Fort Hood.
Omar responded with a comment about terrorism saying that "our country should be more fearful of white men across our country because they are actually causing most of the deaths within this country."
We have fact-checked similar statements before. We found that measuring terrorism or violence by white nationalists can be tricky because it depends upon the definitions. However, data from multiple sources suggest extremist attacks associated with white nationalism and far-right ideology is on the rise.
In sharing the video from a Daily Caller News Foundation reporter, Rubio tweeted, "I am sure the media will now hound every Democrat to denounce this statement as racist. Right?"
The clip has been viewed more than 5 million times.
It helps to watch Omar’s full 10-minute interview to understand her quote in context.
She was asked about other things — for example, President Donald Trump’s early policies to restrict travel from Muslim-majority countries and anti-Muslim discrimination in the United States — but we’ve focused on the relevant portion of the video when she was talking about terrorism.
Interviewer Mehdi Hasan: "Within just a few days of taking office President Trump brought in his infamous travel ban, the Muslim ban. You are not just a Muslim immigrant to the United States, you are a former Muslim refugee who is from one of the countries on the banned list: Somalia. Do you think President Trump doesn’t want people like you in the country because he says it’s not personal, its national security?’"
Omar: "If we were really being honest about what could be masqueraded as a national security issue we know that no one from any of these countries has ever posed a threat within this country. And so we know that for him and his supporters this is just a political football, and they are using our communities and people who look like me as leverage."
Later in the interview, Hasan asked her about terrorism.
Hasan: "A lot of conservatives in particular would say that the rise of Islamophobia is the result not of hate but of fear — a legitimate fear they say of ‘jihadist terrorism’ whether it’s Fort Hood or San Bernandino or the recent truck attack in New York. What do you say to them?"
Here is her full answer (we put the portion that was cut in the Twitter video in bold):
Omar: "I would say our country should be more fearful of white men across our country, because they are actually causing most of the deaths within this country. And so if fear was the driving force of policies to keep America safe, Americans safe inside of this country, we should be profiling, monitoring and creating policies to fight the radicalization of white men."
Hasan: "But most of the funding and attention even under Obama obviously went toward Muslim communities — one of those communities is in Minnesota, your state, the Somali American community in Minnesota where I think over past few years more than 20 young Somali Americans have left to go and fight for Isil or Al Shabab or one of these ‘jihadist groups’ abroad. That’s a real threat, obviously nobody is pretending it’s not a threat. So what do you do about it?"
Omar: "I think, like I said, the focus of our policies should be about keeping Americans safe, keeping us domestically safe, and where we actually find a solution is looking at our foreign policy, looking at how we are engaging with the members of these communities and the kind of rhetoric, right, that is being spewed out of leaders within our city halls, within our state capitals and within our nation’s capital."
Hasan: "Some would say that is true, there is really bad rhetoric coming from politicians, security leaders, etc., but also a lot of bad rhetoric coming from Muslim community leaders, imams, etc. Is that fair?"
Omar: "I think both of those statements could be true. And I think it just goes to show what happens when you have segments within communities that are using fear and hate to mobilize their base, and it is important for us to actually have a conversation about what kind of communities we are trying to build and what this nation actually stands for."