We take a look at Carlos Gimenez's jobs goal
During his 2012 campaign, Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez announced that his top priority was job creation. "My plan is to attract new investment and create high-paying, quality jobs," he pledged.
In recent weeks, he's been negotiating with major sports franchises and stadium developers, including the Miami Heat, the Miami Dolphins and soccer superstar and impresario David Beckham. But how is he doing on helping everyday county residents secure good jobs?
Unlike Gov. Rick Scott -- who made a high-profile pledge to create 700,000 new jobs in seven years -- Gimenez didn't attach a number of jobs to his promise (nor, for that matter, did he define 'high-paying').
However, a spokeswoman told us previously that Gimenez was eyeing increases in jobs in information technology, engineering and life sciences.
Gimenez's promise overlaps with the Beacon Council's "One Community One Goal" initiative to create 75,000 new jobs by 2017 with a focus on targeted industries, including IT and life sciences. The Beacon Council is the county's economic development arm.
A couple of times a year, we check in with the Beacon Council and ask for a list of of additional IT, engineering and life science companies that reached agreements to add jobs in the county over the next three years.
Here is the list we received in May which adds up to about 278 jobs:
* Ratiokontakt, an international premium internet-service provider from Germany, opened a new location in Miami adding 15 jobs.
* Larkin Community Hospital is developing a postgraduate university campus that will add 122 new jobs within three years.
* Multicare Pharmaceutical, a drug wholesaler specializing in Brazilian and South American markets, is opening a new location in Doral, adding five jobs.
* GS Inima USA, a Spain-based construction and engineering group in the water sector, is expanding operations in its U.S. headquarters in downtown Miami, adding 30 jobs.
* Caribbean Radiation Oncology Center, a cancer treatment company from Puerto Rico, is building a new radiation oncology facility in Doral, adding 22 jobs.
* Cotral Lab., a French manufacturer of customized hearing protection devices, has opened a new location in Miami Lakes, adding 15 jobs.
* Terumo Latin America Corp., a medical device company, is expanding its Latin American headquarters in Doral, adding 9 jobs.
* Shiver Entertainment, a digital gaming start-up, has expanded its operations to include production and development, adding 60 jobs.
We sent the list to Kwame Donaldson, an analyst at Moody's who studies Florida. He sent us data on total payroll jobs and certain sectors between January 2012 and March 2014.
Jobs in the management; scientific; and technical consulting services sector and in architectural; engineering; and related services sector grew faster in Miami than overall payrolls did between January 2012 and March 2014. Jobs in the information field increased by less than the other sectors.
"Combined growth in the three categories is 7 percent, which is slightly better than overall growth in Miami-Dade and the state of FL. But since that final number is estimated and subject to substantial revision, I would characterize growth in IT, engineering and life sciences to be on par with overall growth in the region," Donaldson told PolitiFact Florida.
As we have noted in the past, it's difficult to determine how much credit Gimenez gets for the new jobs because no matter who is serving as mayor, some companies will decide to add jobs in Miami-Dade County. Also the company-by-company list of jobs we cited represents jobs being added, but we don't have any information on jobs in these sectors that have been cut.
On balance, we have decided to leave the rating at In The Works.
Moody's, Job data interview for Miami-Dade County, January 2012-March 2014
PolitiFact Florida's Scott-O-Meter, Create over 700,000 jobs, Last update Dec. 9, 2013
Interview, Maria Camacho, spokeswoman for the Beacon Council, May 20, 2014
Interview, Kwame Donaldson, Moody's analyst, May 30, 2014
More jobs promised in Miami-Dade
During his 2012 re-election campaign, Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez promised to "attract new investment and create high-paying, quality jobs."
But Gimenez was careful about that promise: he didn't attach a dollar figure or number of jobs to his promise. Gimenez's spokeswoman told us that the mayor specifically wanted to attract jobs in information technology, engineering and life sciences.
Gimenez's promise overlaps with the Beacon Council's "One Community One Goal" initiative to create 75,000 new jobs by 2017 with a focus on targeted industries, including IT and life sciences. When we wrote about this promise in June, the Beacon Council sent us a list of seven companies that reached deals that included 553 jobs in Miami-Dade County over three years -- which led us to give Gimenez an "In the Works" for his progress in June 2013.
We wanted to check in on his progress four months later.
The Beacon Council sent us a new list of additional IT, engineering and life science companies that reached agreements by Oct. 1 to provide jobs in Miami-Dade County over the next three years:
• Cable and Wireless Communications, from the UK, global telecom firm: 263 new jobs
• DBK Concepts, from Miami-Dade, service provider for data collection technology: 70 new jobs
• International Software Company (ISC, Inc.), from France, IT company: 5 new jobs
• Skyscanner, from Scotland, IT travel/flight search engine: 50 new jobs
• Vioearth, from the UK, energy efficient products designer: 45 jobs
The new batch of jobs add up to 433.
It's hard to pinpoint how much credit Gimenez should get for these new jobs. No matter who the county mayor is, some companies could choose to relocate or expand in Miami-Dade County. (Also, the data we received from the Beacon Council reflected jobs coming in -- not whether any jobs in these areas were cut.)
We sent a summary of what we learned from the Beacon Council to Chris Lafakis, a senior economist at Moody's who studies Miami-Dade's economy, and asked him to assess Gimenez's promise.
"The needle has barely moved ... a couple hundred jobs here or there is not going to have a measurable impact on the Miami economy, which employs over one million."
Lafakis sent us data that showed the number of jobs per month in Miami-Dade County in technical consulting, IT, engineering and other similar jobs have remained fairly stagnant over the past year.
Because the evidence seems mixed so far, we leave the rating as is: In the Works.
Interview, Maria Camacho, spokeswoman for the Beacon Council, Oct. 15, 2013
Interview, Chris Lafakis, senior economist Moody's, Oct. 15, 2013
Early signs of some job growth
When Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez ran for re-election in 2012, he promised on his campaign website to "attract new investment and create high-paying quality jobs.”
Gimenez didn't attach any specific numbers to that promise -- unlike Gov. Rick Scott who promised to create over 700,000 jobs which we have rated Stalled.
Though Gimenez's promise was vague, job creation is an important task for a mayor and we decided to track his progress on our Carlos-O-Meter.
Gimenez's spokeswoman Suzy Trutie told us that Gimenez wanted to attract jobs in information technology, engineering and life sciences. Trutie said that Gimenez had held meetings with individuals within those industries about locating or expanding in Miami-Dade County. We didn't rate his promise immediately and decided to watch his progress.
Several months after Gimenez won re-election in August 2012, we circled back to County Hall and other experts to evaluate his progress.
Gimenez's promise overlaps with the Beacon Council's One Community One Goal initiative to create 75,000 new jobs in Miami-Dade County between 2012 and 2017 with a focus on targeted industries including IT and life sciences. (In March, the board of the Beacon Council -- the county's economic development arm -- ousted it's longtime director Frank Nero and is searching for a permanent director.)
The Beacon Council sent us a list of companies that do work in IT, engineering or life sciences that have finalized deals with the council to add jobs in Miami-Dade County since October 2012.
Here are the companies and the jobs they promised to provide within three years:
Avadora USA from Brazil, web design/development: 15
Four Winds Interactive from Denver, digital signage: 70
Helix Hearing Care from Canada, treat hearing loss: 10
IECISA from Spain, information and communication technologies: 20
Neocis LLC, a Miami-Dade start-up and medical device company: 25
Sapient Corp., consulting/technology/marketing firm expansion: 67
Univision, TV network expansion: 346
The total adds up to 553 jobs. The lowest average salary for these firms is $50,000.
Two of these companies were approved for financial incentives by the county and/or state but only get the money after they created the jobs and promised investment.
These are companies that do some work in the sectors identified by Gimenez, but it doesn't mean all of the jobs are in IT, engineering or life sciences. For example, some of these jobs could be for receptionists or in the case of Univision, reporters. The average wage of these jobs will be $45,000.
Let's take a look at the one expected to produce the largest number of jobs: Univision/ABC news, which will launch a new English-language TV news network targeting Hispanics headquartered at the Univision studios in Doral. The company expects to spend about $275 million to create the network, and Miami-Dade promised about $3.5 million in incentives if the company meets hiring goals. Keeping the company in Miami-Dade was important to local officials as the company considered other locations such as Houston, New York and Los Angeles.
It's somewhat difficult to assess how much credit Gimenez should get for these business locations/expansions. The county is a partner in the Beacon Council but as mayor, Gimenez doesn't set the budget or hire the director (the county passes through business tax money.)
Overall, the employment picture in Miami-Dade is far from rosy. In April, the unemployment rate was 9.6 percent and Miami-Dade employers added 2,600 payroll positions. The Miami Herald reported that slow hiring was due to drops in local government employment, sluggishness in the construction sector and job losses at hospitals.
Chris Lafakis, a senior economist at Moody's who studies Miami-Dade's economy, called the area's job growth in IT, engineering and biotechnology "anemic.”
"In terms of the overall job picture, payroll employment in Miami is 1,032,000. That's up by 2,700 since November 2012; a 0.26 percent increase. For comparison, national payroll employment has risen three times as fast over the same period,” Lafakis told PolitiFact Florida in an email. "This being said, however, the mayor hasn't been in office for long enough to have an impact on the macro economy. So while he hasn't lived up to his promise so far, he still deserves the benefit of the doubt because not a lot of time has passed.”
Gimenez promised to "attract new investment and create high-paying quality jobs” and said that he wanted to focus on IT, engineering and life sciences. The new jobs only add up to about 550 -- and they are jobs promised over the next three years, so we don't know yet if they will materialize. We would need to see actual job growth in these areas -- and many more jobs -- to consider this a Promise Kept. But these first steps earn Gimenez an In the Works.
Miami Herald Naked Politics blog, "CEO of Miami-Dade Beacon Council ousted,” March 8, 2013
Miami Herald, "Univision-ABC channel reflects ‘new reality" of Hispanic rise in America,” Accessed in Nexis, Oct. 11, 2013
Miami Herald, "Slow hiring in Miami-Dade keeps unemployment close to 10 percent,” May 17, 2013
PolitiFact, "Gov. Rick Scott's job creation goal gets an unexpected boost, but ...,” March 21, 2013
Interview, Ana Acle-Menendez, spokeswoman for The Beacon Council, June 4, 2013
Interview, Vanessa Santana-Peñate, spokewoman for Miami-Dade county, June 4, 2013
Interview, Chris Lafakis, senior economist Moody's, June 5, 2013
Carlos Gimenez says job creation is a top priority in second term
After former Miami-Dade county commissioner Carlos Gimenez was elected county mayor in June 2011 to replace his recalled predecessor, PolitiFact Florida unveiled the Carlos-O-Meter to track the mayor's promises.
In August 2012, Gimenez won re-election to a four-year term which officially starts Nov. 20. We have added one promise to the meter from his 2012 campaign.
Gimenez promised on his campaign website to "attract new investment and create high-paying quality jobs.”
Gimenez didn't state the number of new jobs, size of investment or definition of a high-paying quality job attached to that promise. County spokeswoman Suzy Trutie said that the mayor was referring to jobs in information technology, engineering and life sciences.Trutie said that Gimenez has met with individuals and organizations within those industries to explore the feasibility of establishing or expanding their operations in Miami-Dade County.
During the campaign, Gimenez mentioned several steps he would take to achieve that promise, including an expedited permitting process and eliminating outdated regulations. Gimenez also wrote that he was a co-chair of the One Community One Goal Initiative -- a collaboration between multiple partners including The Beacon Council, the county's economic development arm.
That initiative aims to create 75,000 new jobs in Miami-Dade County between 2012 and 2017 with a focus on these targeted industries:
* creative design (advertising, architecture, fashion, etc.)
* hospitality and tourism
* information technology
* international banking and finances
* life sciences and health care
* trade and logistics
Tony Villamil, dean of the business school at St. Thomas University, chairs an economic roundtable for the Beacon Council. Villamil told PolitiFact Florida that it is difficult to forecast the number of new jobs because changes in the global economy will affect that outcome in Miami-Dade County.
The goal of the initiative is to "change the composition of the job growth” toward industries that have higher wages, he said.
Moody's projects job growth of about 85,000 for the county during that timeframe, Moody's economist Chris Lafakis told PolitiFact. (Here is the most recent jobs analysis from Moody's.)
Lafakis said that employment has risen by 5,900 since Gimenez took office in July 2011. But the largest increases have been in low-paying areas such as retail or moderate-paying jobs in professional and business services and education and health care.
The One Community initiative was independent of Gimenez's campaign, so we are not evaluating the goal of creating 75,000 jobs as a campaign promise. But we are going to evaluate Gimenez's progress toward the promise of attracting investment and creating high-quality jobs and that will overlap with the One Community initiative.
We have not heard enough specifics about actions Gimenez has taken toward this promise, so we are leaving it unrated for now.
Mayor Carlos Gimenez, Campaign website accomplishments page, 2012
Beacon Council, One Community One Goalplan andflyer, May 2012
Moody's, Miami-Dade County employment and income, July 2012
Interview, Suzy Trutie, spokeswoman for Miami-Dade County, Nov. 15, 2012
Interview, Jack Osterholt, Deputy Mayor for Miami-Dade County, Nov. 14, 2012
Interview, Ana Acle-Menendez, spokeswoman for the Beacon Council. Nov. 15, 2012
Interview, Tony Villamil, Dean of the Business School at St. Thomas University, Nov. 15, 2012
Interview, Chris Lafakis, economist at Moodys, Nov. 13, 2012