The United States has "an immigration system where only 6.5 percent of people who come here, come here based on labor and skill."
Marco Rubio on Saturday, January 12th, 2013 in an interview
Marco Rubio says only 6.5 percent of immigrants "come here based on labor and skill"
Florida Sen. Marco Rubio is a key to the Republicans’ hope to capture more of the Hispanic vote in 2016. And to achieve that goal, Rubio -- a potential presidential contender -- wants to be the face of the GOP’s immigration plans.
Rubio unveiled his plan for immigration legislation in the Wall Street Journal on Jan. 12. Rubio’s plan calls for allowing more immigrants into the country who bring investment or skills, a guest-worker program for farm laborers and a path to citizenship for certain people in the United States illegally.
Rubio sees his immigration plan as something that can spur economic growth.
"I'm a big believer in family based immigration," Rubio told the Journal. "But I don't think that in the 21st century we can continue to have an immigration system where only 6.5 percent of people who come here, come here based on labor and skill. We have to move toward merit and skill-based immigration."
That precise figure -- 6.5 percent -- caught our attention, so we decided to check it out.
Brookings policy brief
Rubio obtained the 6.5 percent figure from a January 2011 policy brief from the Brookings Institution, a centrist think tank. The author, Brookings vice president Darrell West, called for immigration reform that in the short term would allow employers to hire workers with scientific and technological skills.
West argued that some other countries such as Canada have already crafted policies to attract skilled and unskilled workers. Canada gives applicants points based on their field of study, education and employment experience.
"Some 36 percent of all Canadian immigrant visas are in the ‘skilled-worker’ category, as opposed to only 6.5 percent in the United States," West wrote. We contacted West to ask how he arrived at his figure.
West told us in an email that there are different numbers depending on the immigrant category and the definition of skilled workers. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security publishes numbers that relate to "legal permanent residents" and how many are family sponsored or employment-based.
"But even those numbers are not exact, because the employment category combines skilled and unskilled workers," West wrote. "My 6.5 percent figure was my best approximation of the conflicting numbers that exist in this area."
We looked at the numbers ourselves and found the vast majority of immigrants are accepted for family unification and a smaller slice are for employment, though the numbers vary depending on the type of visa and employment.
West’s number drew from a group known as legal permanent residents. In 2011, a total of 1,062,040 persons became legal permanent residents. Family sponsored was the largest category for people who earned this status in 2011. Employment-based preferences accounted for 13.1 percent.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security provides a breakdown for people receiving the employment-based preferences. "Professionals with advanced degrees" accounted for 6.3 percent. Another category combined "skilled workers, professionals and unskilled workers," and that accounted for 3.5 percent. (The combined category makes it difficult to pluck out a number for only "skilled" workers.) The 2011 Yearbook of immigrant statistics shows that within those employment categories, the numbers reflect not just workers, but their spouses and children.
In an interview on reforming our immigration system, Rubio said "I'm a big believer in family based immigration. But I don't think that in the 21st century we can continue to have an immigration system where only 6.5 percent of people who come here, come here based on labor and skill. We have to move toward merit and skill-based immigration."
Rubio pulled his number from a 2011 Brookings paper that said, "Some 36 percent of all Canadian immigrant visas are in the ‘skilled-worker’ category, as opposed to only 6.5 percent in the United States."
Immigration data shows that most people come here for family reasons. The number of legal immigrants who come based on an employment varies depending on the type of visa and category of employment. But one valid example is to look at legal permanent residents -- 13.1 percent were employment-based preferences in 2011, and professionals with advanced degrees accounted for 6.3 percent.
The data isn’t as precise as Rubio makes it sound, but his basic premise is correct, and some numbers do support his claim. We rate this claim Mostly True.
Published: Wednesday, January 16th, 2013 at 1:39 p.m.
Wall Street Journal, "Marco Rubio: Riding to the immigration rescue,"Jan. 12, 2013
Tampa Bay Times The Buzz blog, "Rubio proposal calls for legal status for millions of illegal immigrants that could lead to citizenship," Jan. 11, 2013
Miami Herald’s Naked Politics blog, "Marco Rubio’s amnesty-lite immigration plan vs. Obama’s amnesty plan,"Jan. 13, 2013
Pew Research Hispanic Center, "Unauthorized immigrants: 11.1 million in 2011," Dec. 6, 2012
Pew Research Hispanic Center, "When Labels Don’t Fit: Hispanics and their views of identity,"April 4, 2012,
PolitiFact, "Most Hispanics support the DREAM Act, but Marco Rubio does not," Feb. 9, 2012
Brookings, "Creating a ‘Brain gain’ for U.S. employers: the role of immigration,"Jan. 11, 2013
Department of Homeland Security,"Nonimmigrant admissions to the United States: 2011," July 2012
Department of Homeland Security, "U.S. Legal permanent residents: 2011,"April 2012
Department of Homeland Security, 2011 Yearbook of Immigration Statistics, September 2012
U.S. Department of State, "Classes of immigrant issued visas at foreign service posts,"2011
Pew Research Hispanic Center, "A portrait of unauthorized immigrants in the United States," April 14, 2009
ImmigrationWorks USA, Comprehensive Immigration Reform, December 2012
NPR, "Obama’s immigration move disrupts Rubio’s dream,"June 20, 2012
Interview, Steven Weiss, Research and Communications Coordinator, ImmigrationWorks USA, Jan. 14, 2013
Interview, Steven Camarota, Center for Immigration Studies, Jan. 15, 2013
Interview Mark Lopez, associate director of the Pew Research Hispanic Center, Jan. 14, 2013
Interview, Alex Conant, spokesman for Sen. Marco Rubio, Jan. 14, 2013
Interview, Darrell West, vice president and director of Governance Studies and Director of the Center for Technology Innovation at Brookings Institution, Jan. 14, 2013
Interview, Mark Krikorian, executive director of the Center for Low Immigration Studies, Jan. 15, 2013
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Florida Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.