PolitiFact.com
Powered by PolitiFact.com and ajc.com
The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Crozier

Karen Handel "would have felt like it was OK to go in and abort" Sarah Palin's son Trig, who has Down syndrome.

Melanie Crozier on Wednesday, July 21st, 2010 in a Politico article

Group says GOP candidate Karen Handel would be OK aborting child with Down syndrome

Now that the Republican gubernatorial runoff is on, some Georgia abortion foes are taking aim at front-runner Karen Handel.

Handel placed first in the GOP primary despite Georgia Right to Life's criticisms that she's not pro-life enough. A late endorsement by conservative darling Sarah Palin helped her rocket ahead of opponents.

And that's what concerns Melanie Crozier, the director of the Georgia Right to Life's Political Action Committee, Crozier said in a recent article for Politico, an online news site. 

"[Palin] has a son with Down syndrome, and under Karen Handel’s laws, Handel would have felt like it was OK to go in and abort that child," said Crozier.

Crozier added that they plan to back Nathan Deal, Handel's opponent in the GOP runoff.

We did a double take. Handel is fine with aborting a fetus that tests positive for Down syndrome?

No, she's not, Handel said. Her campaign called Crozier's statement a "cruel and revolting lie." She called on Crozier and GRTL President Dan Becker to step down. 

We requested to speak with Crozier. Instead, GRTL sent us a press release on their opposition to Handel's views on in vitro fertilization.

But Crozier did talk with WSB-TV. In the interview, she apologized for making a statement that was unclear and said she was really criticizing Handel's views on in vitro fertilization. GRTL thinks doctors should create only as many embryos as they plan to implant. Handel thinks that if any are left over, they should be considered for adoption.  

Crozier has not asked for a correction or clarification on the Politico story, according to its author. 

GRTL and Handel have tangled before. She, like other GOP candidates, has declared herself "pro-life," but some claim she's not "pro-life" enough.

In statewide runs, Handel has consistently opposed abortion except in the cases of rape, incest or when the life of the mother is at stake.

GRTL supports only one exception: the life of the mother.

Handel has taken hits from GRTL for her views for years, but she has stood her ground.

When Handel ran for secretary of state in 2006, GRTL sent out a postcard naming her primary runoff opponent as the race's only true right-to-life candidate. Handel won without the organization's support.

GRTL and Handel were at loggerheads again in June, after Becker used the word "barren" to talk about Handel's struggles with fertility and her position on abortion. She has previously talked publicly about how she tried unsuccessfully to have a child for 10 years.

And when Palin announced her endorsement of Handel on July 12, GRTL issued a press release to say they were "stunned" because Handel's views on abortion showed she did not cherish the lives of children with genetic disorders as much as she should.   

Palin's son Trig was born in 2008 with Down syndrome, a genetic disorder that causes physical problems and cognitive delays.

In a July 22 interview with Lori Geary on WSB-TV, Crozier tried to clarify the statement she made to Politico.

Crozier: "What I’m saying is, if a baby who is created through the process of in vitro fertilization ..."

Geary: "Which again, Palin’s was not ..."

Crozier: "But we’re saying, if this was the case, and was found to have Down syndrome, Karen Handel is OK with that life being exterminated."

Handel's campaign denies this claim as well.

"They're making a series of reaches beyond anything Karen believes," said her campaign spokesman Dan McLagan.

What Crozier told Politico doesn't stand up to to scrutiny. Neither does her clarification.

GRTL failed to provide any evidence whatsoever for the statement that Handel thinks it is fine to abort a child because it has Down syndrome. And the organization failed to explain how it came to its conclusion.

The group should have known that they were misrepresenting Handel's beliefs. They've been quibbling with her stances for years.

After Handel called for the resignation of GRTL's leadership, the group backed so far off its statement that Crozier claimed she wasn't really talking about aborting children with Down syndrome. Instead, she told WSB-TV, she was really talking about in vitro fertilization. 

But, as Geary pointed out, Trig wasn't conceived in a test tube. How could the subject apply to him?

Crozier made a baseless and outrageous statement.

She earns PolitiFact's lowest rating, Pants on Fire.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Monday, July 26th, 2010 at 6:00 a.m.

Subjects: Abortion

Sources:

Politico.com, "Romney lines up behind Handel," July 21, 2010

WSB-TV, "Handel calls abortion claim 'revolting lie,' " July 22, 2010

Anchorage Daily News, "Palins' child diagnosed with Down syndrome," April 22, 2008

Georgia Right to Life, "Leading Pro-Life Groups Shocked at Handel’s Latest Endorsement," July 12, 2010

Georgia Right to Life, press release, "Protecting Life; Not Attacking Politicians," July 23, 2010

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Political Insider" blog, "State GOP chair Sue Everhart has Karen Handel’s back on ‘pro-life’ label," June 6, 2010

Karen Handel for Governor Web site, "Karen Handel on Life and Planned Parenthood," July 15, 2010

Interview, Jessica Taylor, assistant editor, Politico, July 23, 2010

Interview, Dan McLagan, Karen Handel Campaign for Governor, July 23, 2010

Written by: Willoughby Mariano
Researched by: Willoughby Mariano
Edited by: Elizabeth Miniet, Jim Tharpe

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Georgia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Georgia Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe: