PolitiFact.com
Powered by PolitiFact.com and ajc.com
The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Isakson

"There has never been a death caused by a [commercial nuclear] reactor in the United States, even when Three Mile Island failed in the 1970s."

Johnny Isakson on Tuesday, March 15th, 2011 in a YouTube.com video

Isakson claims no deaths in U.S. from nuke plant operations

(Editor’s Note: Sen. Isakson’s statement was made in the context of a discussion about two commercial nuclear power plants -- Japan’s Fukushima Daiichi and the Votgle facility, a plant near Augusta that’s slated for expansion. Isakson was specifically addressing safety issues at commercial nuclear power generators.)

The fallout from Japan’s nuclear disaster has arrived in Georgia as a small cloud of worry.  

The construction of the nation’s first new nuclear reactors in decades is slated for just south of Augusta at the Vogtle power plant. When a deadly earthquake and tsunami triggered what is likely a partial meltdown at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant, a few residents near the Georgia site began to ask questions.

U.S. Sen. Johnny Isakson was quick to offer reassurances that Vogtle would be safe.

"There has never been a death caused by a reactor in the United States, even when Three Mile Island failed in the 1970s," Isakson said in a YouTube.com video posted by his office.  

Three Mile Island? That 1979 nuclear accident sank the U.S. into a three-decade freeze on the building of nuclear power plants. No one died?

Nuclear power companies have a lot at stake at Vogtle. They hope its new reactors will herald an industry renaissance.

Now that Fukushima Daiichi is in crisis, the future for nuclear power is uncertain. Members of Congress, such as independent Sen. Joe Lieberman of Connecticut, have urged regulators to be cautious as they proceed with the construction of more nuclear plants in the U.S.

We called up Isakson’s office and asked for more evidence. A spokeswoman pointed us to 2010 testimony by Greg Jaczko, the chairman of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, at a Senate committee hearing.

When a senator asked Jaczko whether a fatality had ever occurred "as a result of an accident at a commercial nuclear reactor in the United States," Jaczko replied with this:

"There has not as a result of plant operation, not at a commercial power plant. There have been other nuclear facilities where there have been fatalities, but not in a nuclear power plant."

We interviewed experts on Three Mile Island, epidemiology and the history of nuclear power. They agreed that no one died during the immediate crisis surrounding the Three Mile Island accident or in other commercial U.S. plants as a result of plant operation.

In addition, they agreed that the scientific consensus is that in the decades following Three Mile Island, no deaths have been tied to illnesses resulting from radiation exposure.

"The statement of the politician [Isakson] is correct -- as far as we know," said Sam Walker, who retired last year as historian for the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and is the author of a book on Three Mile Island.

The prevailing view is that despite early, anecdotal reports of deaths and disease, Three Mile Island’s impact on overall cancer deaths is minimal. Worker radiation exposure was higher than normal but not extreme, and experts think people living near the plant were exposed to low doses.

This does not mean, however, that the disaster has not caused deaths or won’t in the future. It can take more than a decade for radiation exposure to manifest itself as cancer, and it’s difficult to pinpoint whether radiation exposure, a smoking habit or other factors caused a particular person’s illness.     

The latest research suggests Three Mile Island may have some deadly long-term effects.  University of Pittsburgh professor Evelyn Talbott has been leading a major, decades-long effort to track the effects of Three Mile Island radiation in more than 32,000 people who lived in the area surrounding the plant.  

Talbott’s team noted no increase in overall cancer deaths 20 years afterward, but research they recently submitted for publication shows that adult men who they think received the highest doses of radiation from the accident are at greater risk for leukemia than others who were exposed, the scientist said.  

Women with similar amounts of radiation exposure showed a higher risk of breast cancer.

"So presumably there may have been excess deaths. We just don't know who specifically, as the cases were within a group of people exposed to more radiation but also had other factors which may have predisposed them," Talbott told PolitiFact Georgia.

Members of an impassioned minority think the impact may have been more severe. A study by scientists at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, found a link between Three Mile Island and increased incidents of cancer overall.

Critics think there are too few peer-reviewed studies published in medical journals on the disaster’s health effects. Joseph Mangano, the head of the Radiation and Public Health Project, thinks the dangers of radiation exposure in general are underplayed. He noted that only a handful of studies have been published on patterns of several types of cancer.
 
"I think the health research field has completely dropped the ball," Mangano told PolitiFact Georgia.

In conclusion:

Isakson’s statement that "there has never been a death caused by a reactor in the United States, even when Three Mile Island failed in the 1970s," reflects a prevailing view.

According to the latest research, that does not mean there has never been a death because of Three Mile Island’s long-term effects. It’s also worth noting that some scientists back a minority view that the accident increased overall cancer deaths.   

That said, Isakson specified in his claim that there has never been a death "caused by a reactor" in the U.S. This language is not clear, but it does indicate his claim is limited to plant operations, not the long-term aftermath of a nuclear accident. His backup information suggests this as well.

We rate Isakson’s statement True. 

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Friday, April 1st, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.

Subjects: Nuclear

Sources:

YouTube.com, "Johnny on the Crisis in Japan and Nuclear Energy," posted March 15, 2011

U.S. Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works, archived webcast, Subcommittee on Clean Air and Nuclear Safety hearing, "Oversight Hearing: Nuclear Regulatory Commission," May 5, 2010

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Southern Co. defends Vogtle project," March 15, 2011

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Georgians embrace jobs, not nuke fears," March 20, 2011

USA Today, "Japan disaster troubles few near growing Georgia nuclear plant," March 18, 2011

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, "Backgrounder on the Three Mile Island accident," accessed March 28, 2011

Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, "Three Mile Island: Health Study Meltdown," September/October 2004

Interview, Sam Walker, former historian, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, March 29, 2011

Interview, John Luetzelschwab, professor emeritus, department of physics and astronomy,
Dickinson College, March 28, 2011

Interview, Evelyn O. Talbott, professor, department of epidemiology, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, March 29, 2011

E-mail interview, Steve Wing,  associate professor, department of epidemiology,
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, March 28, 2011

Interview, Joseph Mangano, executive director, Radiation and Public Health Project, March 29, 2011

Interview, Joey Ledford, public affairs officer, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, March 28, 2011

Environmental Health Perspectives, "Mortality among the Residents of the Three Mile Island Accident Area: 1979-1992," June 2000

Environmental Health Perspectives, "A Reevaluation of Cancer Incidence Near the Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant: The Collision of Evidence and Assumptions," January 1997

American Journal of Epidemiology, "Cancer Near the Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant," September 1990

Written by: Willoughby Mariano
Researched by: Willoughby Mariano
Edited by: Jim Denery, Jim Tharpe

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Georgia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Georgia Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe: