PolitiFact.com
Powered by PolitiFact.com
The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Christie

Says "out of 588 school districts, we give 31 (former Abbott) districts 70 percent of the aid."

Chris Christie on Friday, November 18th, 2011 in a forum at the University of Notre Dame

Chris Christie claims 31 former Abbott districts receive 70 percent of the state aid

Staring at his audience, Gov. Chris Christie took a long pause after delivering this sobering statistic about how schools are funded in New Jersey: 70 percent of the state aid lands in 31 so-called Abbott districts.

During his Nov. 18 visit to the University of Notre Dame, the Republican governor explained how a court decision has delivered most of the state’s education dollars to 31 low-income, urban districts, formerly known as Abbott districts.

"The same way that the Abbott decision in New Jersey, which said that we must give 31 failing districts (a) disproportionate amount of the state aid has not solved the problem either," Christie said. "We now give 31 districts in New Jersey, out of 588 school districts, we give 31 districts 70 percent of the aid."

PolitiFact New Jersey determined Christie’s funding statistic is mostly accurate.

Between K-12 education aid and preschool aid for the 2011-12 school year, the 31 former Abbott districts — including towns such as Hoboken and Phillipsburg — are set to receive about 60 percent of the aid, according to our analysis of figures on the New Jersey Department of Education’s website.

Christie also was slightly off on the number of school districts. There are 590 districts operating school buildings, and 15 others that send students to other districts without operating their own facilities, according to the state Department of Education.

Justin Barra, an Education Department spokesman, confirmed our analysis of the percentage of aid dollars going to the former Abbott districts.

"The Governor made the point in his speech to Notre Dame that a very small percentage of districts in New Jersey receive a majority of state aid, which is undeniably true," Barra said in an e-mail.

Here’s a quick history lesson about the former Abbott districts:

In a legal battle stretching about 30 years, the Abbott vs. Burke court decisions have ensured greater state funding for certain districts as a way of addressing disparities between poor urban areas and the wealthier suburbs. The Abbott designation itself was effectively eliminated a few years ago when the new school funding formula was instituted.

The New Jersey Supreme Court issued the most recent decision in May, ordering the Christie administration to increase state funding to the former Abbott districts by nearly $500 million.

With that additional funding, the 31 former Abbott districts are slated to receive a total of about $4.4 billion in K-12 state aid in the 2011-12 school year. That’s about 57.6 percent of the roughly $7.6 billion in total K-12 aid.

Among the former Abbott districts, Newark is to receive the largest K-12 aid award at about $714 million, followed by Jersey City with about $417 million; Paterson with roughly $398 million; and Elizabeth with about $356 million.

The 31 districts also are set to receive 92 percent of the state’s preschool aid during the current school year, totaling about $569 million.

So, between the K-12 aid and the preschool aid, the former Abbott districts are to receive about 60 percent of the state aid in New Jersey.

Here’s the breakdown of our analysis for each former Abbott district:

County Former Abbott District K-12 Aid Preschool Aid Total Aid
Atlantic Pleasantville $64,996,534 $7,090,753 $72,087,287
Bergen Garfield $55,339,655 $8,563,251 $63,902,906
Burlington Burlington City $16,953,788 $2,703,880 $19,657,668
Burlington Pemberton Twp. $84,756,033 $7,294,335 $92,050,368
Camden Camden City $281,437,116 $25,533,940 $306,971,056
Camden Gloucester City $30,418,261 $2,920,972 $33,339,233
Cumberland Bridgeton $77,077,206 $9,534,330 $86,611,536
Cumberland Millville $67,936,623 $8,746,430 $76,683,053
Cumberland Vineland $136,433,400 $17,614,890 $154,048,290
Essex East Orange $179,617,054 $18,974,400 $198,591,454
Essex Irvington $113,133,130 $16,946,880 $130,080,010
Essex Newark $714,990,694 $81,093,908 $796,084,602
Essex Orange $71,158,031 $9,602,799 $80,760,830
Hudson Harrison $24,805,543 $4,757,571 $29,563,114
Hudson Hoboken $9,399,671 $8,930,595 $18,330,266
Hudson Jersey City $417,859,149 $60,292,769 $478,151,918
Hudson Union City $174,449,158 $25,340,662 $199,789,820
Hudson West New York $89,900,673 $15,742,994 $105,643,667
Mercer Trenton $227,907,566 $26,910,920 $254,818,486
Middlesex New Brunswick $119,688,982 $17,421,352 $137,110,334
Middlesex Perth Amboy $159,416,958 $20,217,042 $179,634,000
Monmouth Asbury Park $57,632,816 $7,811,335 $65,444,151
Monmouth Keansburg $28,010,210 $2,910,258 $30,920,468
Monmouth Long Branch $41,895,464 $11,193,300 $53,088,764
Monmouth Neptune Twp. $32,632,790 $6,255,811 $38,888,601
Passaic Passaic City $226,148,279 $25,126,258 $251,274,537
Passaic Paterson $398,844,161 $46,602,175 $445,446,336
Salem Salem City $16,494,552 $1,797,920 $18,292,472
Union Elizabeth $356,039,611 $48,381,036 $404,420,647
Union Plainfield $117,635,080 $19,168,606 $136,803,686
Warren Phillipsburg $37,863,535 $4,471,549 $42,335,084

 

It’s worth noting that although the districts only represent about 5 percent of all school districts in New Jersey, they educated nearly 20 percent, or one-fifth, of students during the 2010-11 school year.

Our ruling

At the University of Notre Dame, Christie claimed "we give 31 (former Abbott) districts 70 percent of the aid."

The governor wasn’t too far off. Between K-12 aid and preschool aid, the former Abbott districts are slated to receive about 60 percent of the state dollars allocated in the 2011-12 school year. We rate the statement Mostly True.

To comment on this ruling, go to NJ.com.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Thursday, December 1st, 2011 at 7:30 a.m.

Subjects: Education

Sources:

Gov. Chris Christie speech at Notre Dame Forum, Nov. 18, 2011

New Jersey Department of Education, DOE Archives: Abbott History, accessed Nov. 25, 2011

Education Law Center, Abbott v. Burke Overview, accessed Nov. 25, 2011

New Jersey Supreme Court, Abbott v. Burke Decision, May 24, 2011

New Jersey Department of Education, 2011-12 State Aid Summaries, accessed Nov. 25, 2011

New Jersey Department of Education, New Jersey Public Schools Fact Sheet, accessed Nov. 28, 2011

Email exchange with New Jersey Department of Education representatives, Nov. 28-30, 2011

Written by: Bill Wichert
Researched by: Bill Wichert
Edited by: Caryn Shinske

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The New Jersey Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe:

Keep up to date with Politifact New Jersey: