Says Chris Christie "inherited the highest taxes in America and the worst unemployment in the region."
Committee for Our Children's Future on Tuesday, January 31st, 2012 in a television ad
Ad claims Chris Christie “inherited the highest taxes in America and the worst unemployment in the region”
When Gov. Chris Christie took office, New Jersey distinguished itself in two unflattering ways.
The state had the highest taxes in the nation and the worst unemployment in the region, according to a television ad recently released by the 501(c)(4) advocacy group Committee for Our Children’s Future. Now, the group’s ad claims, Christie is working to cast off those unfavorable rankings.
"They inherited the highest taxes in America and the worst unemployment in the region, but Chris Christie and New Jersey reformers are cleaning up the mess," the narrator of the ad posted to YouTube on Jan. 31 says. "The result: the most job growth in 11 years, millions in new education funding, two budgets balanced. Now, Chris Christie and reformers are fighting to strengthen our economy, improve education and cut income taxes for all New Jersey families. So join our reform movement. Keep New Jersey moving forward."
PolitiFact New Jersey previously checked two ads released by Committee for Our Children’s Future. In those rulings, we found it’s true New Jersey had the most private-sector job growth in 11 years and the governor increased education funding in his latest budget. It’s also true he’s balanced two budgets, as required by law.
Now, we’re assessing the claim that when Christie took office New Jersey had the "highest taxes in America and the worst unemployment in the region."
New Jersey’s taxes are high, but whether they are the highest in the nation is debatable.
Brian Jones, a spokesman for Committee for Our Children’s Future, cited an analysis of state and local tax burdens by the Tax Foundation, a business-backed group that studies tax issues.
New Jersey tops a list compiled by the Washington, D.C.-based group for its state and local tax burden. The Tax Foundation defines tax burden as "effective tax rates calculated by totaling state-local level taxes paid by taxpayers in each state, then dividing by their income."
In 2009, the year before Christie took office, New Jersey had a state and local tax burden of 12.2 percent. New York was a close second at 12.1 percent, followed by Connecticut at 12 percent.
So, the group is right, according to the Tax Foundation. But other studies on tax burdens show New Jersey isn’t the highest. Our colleagues at PolitiFact Ohio addressed this issue in a September 2010 ruling. They found that tax experts disagree over how best to define tax burden and "rankings can vary wildly depending on which taxes are included, which data sets are employed and which projections are applied."
In an analysis by the Federation of Tax Administrators, which provides services to state tax authorities and administrators, New Jersey ranks ninth for the percent of personal income spent on state and local taxes. Alaska ranks first.
However, Ronald Alt, senior research associate at the Federation of Tax Administrators, said there are caveats to the rankings. For example, Alaska takes in a large share of its taxes from oil revenues and Alt said, "most likely their citizens don't pay a large portion of that."
The Tax Foundation puts Alaska 50th in the nation for its state and local tax burden.
Mark Robyn, an economist with the Tax Foundation, said his group sometimes calculates total tax collections as a percent of income, but "we just don't think it is appropriate to call that a ‘tax burden’" because it doesn’t address issues such as taxes shifting across state lines.
Alt said New Jersey’s taxes are high, but "it's very difficult to come out and claim that one state has the highest overall just because there are many different ways of looking at it and there many different types of taxes."
The group also claimed New Jersey had the "worst unemployment in the region" when Christie took office.
Jones said his group was defining the region as New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware -- all of which had lower unemployment rates than New Jersey when Christie took office. "We’re not getting up into New England," he said.
In January 2010, New Jersey’s unemployment rate stood at 9.8 percent. The same month New York’s was 8.9 percent, Pennsylvania’s was 8.8 percent and Delaware’s was 8.8 percent.
It’s worth noting that the U.S. Census Bureau classifies New Jersey as part of the northeast region with Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Pennsylvania, Vermont and Rhode Island. The region is split into two divisions. New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania belong to the middle Atlantic division.
So, New Jersey’s jobless rate was higher than the two other states in its Census division. But among states in the northeast region, Rhode Island had a higher unemployment rate of 11.8 percent than New Jersey in January 2010.
Committee for Our Children’s Future claims in an ad that the governor "inherited the highest taxes in America and the worst unemployment in the region."
A business-backed group ranks New Jersey worst in the nation for its state and local tax burden. The advocacy group is correct by that measure. But there are other measures of tax burden where New Jersey doesn’t rank first and there isn't clear consensus on how best to define tax burden.
New Jersey had the highest unemployment rate among its neighbors when Christie took office, and still does. Among all the states in the northeast, only Rhode Island’s jobless rate tops New Jersey’s.
We rate the statement Mostly True.
To comment on this ruling, go to NJ.com.
Published: Wednesday, February 8th, 2012 at 7:30 a.m.
Committee for Our Children’s Future’s YouTube Channel, Clean Up, Jan. 31, 2012
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS), accessed Feb. 3, 2012
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Labor Force Statistics including the National Unemployment Rate, accessed Feb. 3, 2012
Tax Foundation, State and Local Tax Burdens: All States, One Year, 1977 - 2009, Feb. 23, 2011
Tax Foundation, New Jersey, accessed Feb. 6, 2012
PolitiFact New Jersey, Chris Christie’s record touted in video ad by Committee for Our Children’s Future, Jan. 30, 2012
PolitiFact New Jersey, Television ad promotes Chris Christie’s spending cuts, increased education funding, Oct. 6, 2011
The Star-Ledger, Busting the myth: The real numbers show N.J. is not the most overtaxed state in the nation, June 26, 2011
The Star-Ledger, N.J. residents were highest-taxed in U.S. in 2009, report shows, Feb. 24, 2011
New Jersey Policy Perspective, State and Local Revenue, Fiscal Year 2007-08, accessed Feb. 6, 2012
U.S. Census Bureau, States Ranked by Total State Taxes: 2010, accessed Feb. 6, 2012
The Star-Ledger, Fact: N.J. is a highly taxed state, April 9, 2010
Forbes, In Depth: Most Taxed States, accessed Feb. 6, 2012
U.S. Census Bureau, Attachment C: Census Regions, Census Divisions, and Their Constituent States, accessed Feb. 6, 2012
Federation of Tax Administrators, 2009 State & Local Revenue as a Percentage of Personal Income, accessed Feb. 6, 2012
Interview with Ronald Alt, senior research associate with Federation of Tax Administrators, Feb. 6, 2012
Interview with Brian Jones, spokesman for Committee for Our Children’s Future, Feb. 6, 2012
Email interview with Mark Robyn, economist with Tax Foundation, Feb. 7, 2012
PolitiFact Ohio, John Kasich says Ohio is one of the most taxed states, Sept. 15, 2010
Federation of Tax Administrators, Tax Administrators News, "FTA Examines Tax Level Measurement Methods," September 1992
The Tax Foundation, Tax Foundation State and Local Tax Burden Estimates for 2008: An In-Depth Analysis and Methodological Overview, Aug. 7, 2008
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the New Jersey Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.